Read both sides quote-for-quote (verified against source): our
CSphere::slide_sphere port (TransitionTypes.cs:3054-3133) vs retail
0x00537440 (decomp 321403-321532). Findings:
1. Shape-1 (tick-22760 lost 3.57cm slide) is NOT the degenerate-offset
guard - retail's guard only kills slides under ~1.4cm. The real
divergence is the collision-normal SOURCE: our harness cn=(0,0,1) vs
live cn=(0,+1,0). Strong lead: TransitionTypes.cs:3701-3702 defaults
cn=Vector3.UnitZ when no valid normal.
2. Shape-2: retail's slide_sphere applies the slide IN-FRAME
(add_offset_to_check_pos @0x53777e, return SLID) - our in-frame slide
to Z=1.92 is likely retail-faithful and the D4 frame-1 hard-stop pin
is the stale one (pending the first-airborne-frame plane state).
3. Candidate epsilon-squaring divergence: retail compares SQUARED
quantities against 0.000199999995 (non-squared) while we compare
against EpsilonSq=0.0002^2 - possibly 1e4x too small. Explains
neither shape; DO NOT change without cdb (the test ah,5 branch
polarity is the undecodable BN construct from the PosHitsSphere saga).
No code change (oracle-first; the issue title calls for cdb and the BN
decomp is provably ambiguous on the branch signs). ISSUES.md #116 +
physics digest carry the leads + the scoped cdb plan.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
User re-gate 2026-06-12: ran past distant buildings, 'Seems to have
been fixed' - no flicker/vanish. The per-building flood-admission
bistability (#127, the building-flap mechanism behind the tower roof
flap and #123 'buildings vanish when running past') is gone.
Root: the bistable knife-edge admission died with the W=0
polyClipFinish clip port (987313a - the #119/#120 work that 'kills the
knife-edge class everywhere') plus the #120 containment-rejection
growth fix. The captured-pair evidence (tower-viewer-capture.log,
2026-06-11) PRE-dates all of those - it was that same near-eye knife
edge, not a separate distant mechanism.
Desk confirmation (both green at HEAD):
- CapturedFlipPair_AdmissionIsStable: the original 4 cm flip pair is
now |A|=|B| with zero diff across all FOVs and both pre-gate states.
- DistantBuildingStrafe_NoAdmissionChurn (new regression pin): 0
admission churn across all 21 building groups x {10,30,60,120,190} m
x 100 mm-step run-past strafes, both pre-gate states. A stable flood
toggles each cell at most once over a monotone eye path; this asserts
no cell toggles >=2x.
ISSUES.md #127 -> CLOSED with the DO-NOT-RETRY note (no re-opening the
BuildFromExterior seed gates for a flap symptom without a fresh HEAD
repro - the captured-pair lead is dead). Render digest banner updated.
Suites: App 264+1skip / Core 1443+2skip / UI 420 / Net 294.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
User visual gate 2026-06-12 ('Yes it is fixed.') - cellar climb clean,
outdoor terrain intact from above. Flip ISSUES.md #108 to CLOSED.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The cellar-ascent grass window was the UNDERSIDE of the z~94 grade
sheet. Retail terrain is single-sided: ACRender::landPolysDraw
(0x006b7040) draws each land triangle ONLY when the camera is on the
POSITIVE (upper) side of its plane (Plane::which_side2 vs
Render::FrameCurrent, zFightTerrainAdjust bias) - a below-grade eye
gets NO terrain, so retail shows sky through the cellar door.
We inherited WB's frame-global cull DISABLE (WB GameScene.cs:841 - an
editor camera goes underground by design) and TerrainModernRenderer.Draw
set no cull state of its own -> terrain rasterized both sides. From a
below-grade eye every aperture sight-ray RISES, so the only 'terrain'
it can see is the grade sheet's underside - which painted the exit-door
aperture (the landscape slice's 2D NDC clip planes (nx,ny,0,dw) have no
depth axis and cannot exclude between-eye-and-portal geometry) and slid
off the door exactly as the eye crossed grade. Membership/viewer was
exonerated by the harness in the previous commit.
Fix: TerrainModernRenderer.Draw owns its cull state (the 7th
self-contained-GL-state instance): Enable(CullFace) + CullFace(Back) +
FrontFace(Ccw), set -> draw -> restore the frame-global CW + cull-off
baseline. GL backface culling evaluates retail's per-triangle eye-side
predicate at rasterization; no shader change.
Pins:
- LandblockMeshTests.Build_AllTriangles_WindCounterClockwiseInWorldXY:
every emitted triangle CCW in world XY across both FSplitNESW split
directions - the winding invariant culling depends on.
- TerrainCullOrientationTests: under the production camera convention
(LookAt up=+Z, Numerics perspective) an up-facing triangle winds CCW
in window space from above (kept) and CW from below (culled) - guards
FrontFace inversion, which would blank terrain from above.
Oracle note: retail's through-portal clip has NO portal-face near plane
(PView::GetClip / Render::set_view install edge planes only); nearer-
than-portal exclusion comes from the eye-side cull + cell-level
admission. No register row: this PORTS the retail mechanism, retiring
an undocumented WB-heritage deviation.
Gate pending: cellar climb (grass window gone) + outdoor sanity glance
(terrain intact from above).
Suites: App 263+1skip / Core 1443+2skip / UI 420 / Net 294.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The headless replay of the captured indoor frame proved the look-in flood ADMITS the porch 0x017A (Diagnostic_LookInFlood_AdmitsHallPorchFromCottage: 14 cells). So the portal (a SERVER object - the teleport proves it - with ParentCellId 0xA9B4017A) routes to partition.Dynamics and draws NOWHERE under an interior root: dynamics-last viewcone-culls it (the main cone has no look-in cells) and post-seal it would z-fail beyond the root's door plane (the #118 lesson). This is AP-33's own recorded deferral - 'look-in DYNAMICS are not drawn' - the deferred case was the most-stared-at object in town. Outdoors the merge path puts the porch in the main cone -> drawn -> 'appears when I walk out'.
Fix: DrawBuildingLookIns pass 2 draws look-in-cell dynamics with the statics (whole, AP-33 over-include) and their emitters ride the same DrawCellParticles call. No double-draw: dynamics-last keeps culling them; DrawDynamicsParticles only sees its cone survivors. #124 CLOSED by user gate same session. AP-33 row updated. Suites: App 261+1skip / Core 1439+2skip / UI 420 / Net 294 green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The teleport capture pinned it: walking into the portal flipped pCell to 0xA9B4017A - the hall's PORCH EnvCell. The swirl emitter is owned by a static inside another building's cell. Outdoors the merge path runs the main per-cell pass incl. DrawCellParticles -> visible; under an interior root the #124 look-in sub-pass drew shells + statics but had no cell-particles call. Retail's nested DrawCells draws objects WITH their emitters (DrawObjCellForDummies pc:432878+). Fix: DrawBuildingLookIns pass 2 invokes DrawCellParticles per look-in cell with its static bucket. The owner-cone verdicts were geometrically correct all along (0xC0A9B462 = a porch torch); fixes 1-2 were real-but-adjacent (the unattached pass plugs an independent hole; the alpha deferral fixed#132).
Suites: App 260+1skip / Core 1439+2skip / UI 420 / Net 294 green. Awaiting the swirl gate.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
User gate on 20d1730: the candle is FIXED indoors ("now the candle
light is visible when I'm in the house when it is in front of the
opening") and the OUTDOOR sibling surfaced exactly as AP-34 recorded
("when I go out it is not showing unless I turn so the angle doesn't
put it in front of the opening"): under an OUTDOOR root the merged
building interiors draw AFTER the landscape stage (DrawEnvCellShells),
so a slice-drawn flame is overpainted by a punched aperture's interior
behind it.
Fix: outdoor roots SKIP the late-slice Scene-particle draw; attached
outdoor-static scene emitters draw in the POST-FRAME pass alongside the
T3 unattached pass, where depth is complete and flames composite
correctly against interiors. The owner-id set carries over from the
late slice (single full-screen slice outdoors); cell-pass and
dynamics-pass emitters keep their own passes (their owners are never in
the outdoor-static id set - no double-draw). Interior roots keep the
late-slice draw (their stage ends with the clear + seal discipline).
AP-34 row updated (the outdoor residual is now covered; the remaining
residual is translucent MESH batches within stage draw calls).
Portal swirl (#131): the user's "same results" on 20d1730 KILLS the
look-in-erasure hypothesis for the portal - the mesh now draws after
the look-ins and is still missing indoors. No further speculative fix;
the [outstage] probe now prints each outside-stage dynamic's
SourceGfxObjOrSetupId (portals have distinctive setups) and
[outstage-pt] lists up to 12 distinct UNMATCHED attached emitter owner
ids - the next capture identifies whether the portal entity reaches the
through-door draw at all, and where its emitters point.
Suites: App 259+1skip / Core 1439+2skip / UI 420 / Net 294 green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The user's screenshot pair re-attributed both reports to ONE mechanism -
a compositing gap in the #124 look-in sub-pass:
- #131: the portal swirl (a TRANSLUCENT MESH, not only particles) stood
exactly in front of the hall's doorway. The slice drew it BEFORE the
look-in sub-pass; translucents write no depth, so the hall's interior
- drawn into its far-Z-punched aperture - overpainted the swirl.
Outdoors the look-ins are the post-stage merge path, so the swirl
survives ("stepping out it pops into existence").
- #132: the candle/lantern flame is an attached emitter in the slice's
Scene-particle pass - same pre-look-in placement, same erasure
whenever "the opening through a house" sat behind it; against a wall
nothing overdraws it. Background-dependence explained exactly.
Retail cannot exhibit this class: every alpha draw of the landscape
stage is collected and flushed ONCE after LScape::draw
(D3DPolyRender::FlushAlphaList, PView::DrawCells pc:432722) - i.e.
after all building look-ins.
Port (the two-phase split): DrawLandscapeThroughOutsideView now runs
EARLY per slice (sky, terrain, outdoor STATIC meshes - the look-in
punches need their depth to mark against, the #117 lesson), then the
#124 look-ins, then LATE per slice (outside-stage dynamics' meshes +
ALL attached scene particles + weather + SkyPostScene), then the #131
unattached pass. New RetailPViewLandscapeLateSliceContext carries the
dynamics survivors + the particle-owner set (statics + dynamics cone
survivors). GameWindow's slice handler split accordingly. Outdoor
roots: no look-ins live in the stage, so the net order is unchanged
(zero behavior change outdoors).
Register: AP-34 added - the two-phase split vs retail's single
deferred flush, with the residuals recorded (outdoor-root slice
particles still draw before merged building interiors - the unreported
outdoor sibling; building exteriors' own translucent batches draw
early).
The earlier #131 unattached-emitter pass (1d3f9a8) remains - it fixes
an independent hole (that class had NO indoor pass at all) - and now
runs at the end of the late phase.
Suites: App 259+1skip / Core 1439+2skip / UI 420 / Net 294 green.
Awaiting the user gate: swirl through the doorway, candle flame with
the opening behind it, far-building interiors (#124).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The user's capture run + a code read pinned it in one step: every
particle pass under an interior root is id-filtered (the landscape
slice's Scene pass, the per-cell pass, and the dynamics pass all
require AttachedObjectId != 0 plus owner-set membership). An UNATTACHED
emitter - AttachedObjectId == 0: portal swirls, campfires, ground
effects anchored at a position - drew NOWHERE when the viewer root was
interior. The outdoor root has the dedicated T3 pass for exactly this
class (its own comment records that "unattached ones had NO pass on
outdoor-node frames"); the identical hole on interior-root frames was
never plugged. Walking out flips to the outdoor root and the T3 pass
picks the swirl up - "appears when I walk out again", verbatim.
The [outstage] capture corroborated the rest of the chain healthy
under the interior root: outside-stage routing correct, cone PASS for
the portal-family dynamics, 57 attached emitters matched and drawn
through the doorway. Only the unattached class was orphaned.
Fix: RetailPViewDrawContext.DrawUnattachedSceneParticles - invoked ONCE
per interior-root frame at the END of the landscape stage:
- pre-clear, because drawn after the depth clear + seals an outdoor
emitter beyond the door plane z-fails against the seal's door-plane
stamp;
- after the #124 look-in sub-pass, so swirls blend over far-building
interiors;
- once per frame, not per slice - alpha particles must not double-draw
(the #121 lesson);
- mutually exclusive with the outdoor T3 pass by root kind (interior
invokes this; outdoor keeps T3).
Residual (documented in the issue): unattached INDOOR emitters now draw
pre-clear and get overpainted by the room's shells - the same
invisibility they had before this fix; the proper per-emitter cell
classification is a future port.
[outstage-pt] probe extended with the unattached emitter count (the
probe's blind spot was exactly where the bug hid).
Suites: App 259+1skip / Core 1439+2skip / UI 420 / Net 294 green.
Awaiting the user gate: the swirl through the doorway. #132 (candle
flame vs through-opening background) remains open - different
mechanism, background-dependent.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two user reports from the #124 gate session, both axioms:
- #131: "the portal swirl is missing, when I look out from inside a
house. Appears when I walk out again." Mechanism frame: under an
interior root an outdoor dynamic's particles draw ONLY via the
landscape slice's Scene pass (#118 outside-stage routing; #121
excludes them from the last-pass particle callback) - if any link
fails, the swirl draws nowhere exactly when indoors. Desk-exonerated
already: filter key conventions uniform, the routing predicate
correct, sphere from vertex bounds.
- #132: "I have a candle ... when a wall is behind it it shows, but if
I turn a bit and the opening through a house is behind it candle
light disappears." Background-dependent => per-pixel depth/blend at
the aperture region, not owner culling. Possible overlap with the
#124 look-in sub-pass (new pre-clear content in those pixels) - the
pre-77cef4c check is in the issue.
Apparatus (env-gated, zero cost off): ACDREAM_PROBE_OUTSTAGE=1 ->
[outstage] per-slice outside-stage routing + cone verdict per dynamic
(print-on-change, RetailPViewRenderer) + [outstage-pt] slice
Scene-particle id set + live attached-emitter match count (GameWindow).
One capture standing inside looking at the portal pins which link
breaks.
Suites: App 259+1skip / Core 1439+2skip / UI 420 / Net 294 green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
From inside a building, looking out at ANOTHER building with an opening
showed its back walls missing (see-through to the world): per-building
look-in floods only ran for outdoor roots; under an interior root the
far building's interior never flooded.
Decomp anchor (named-retail, this session's read): retail runs the
look-in INSIDE the landscape stage for ANY root - LScape::draw is the
FIRST call of PView::DrawCells' outside-view branch (pc:432719),
strictly BEFORE the depth clear (pc:432732) and the exit-portal seals
(pc:432785). ConstructView(CBldPortal) (0x005a59a0) clips each aperture
via GetClip against the INSTALLED view - the accumulated doorway region
when looked into from inside - and build_draw_portals_only pass 1
far-Z punches ALL apertures before pass 2 floods + draws any interior
cell. The nested DrawCells has an empty outside view (PView ctor
draw_landscape=0): no recursive landscape/clear/seal.
Port:
- GameWindow's per-building gather (frustum pre-gate on
Building.PortalBounds) now runs for interior roots too; the root's
own doorway self-excludes via the seed eye-side test (the eye is on
its interior side).
- PortalVisibilityBuilder.BuildFromExterior/ConstructViewBuilding gain
seedRegion - the installed-view clip: interior-root look-ins seed
against the OutsideView polygons (a building not visible through the
doorway never floods); null = full screen (outdoor roots unchanged).
- RetailPViewRenderer.DrawBuildingLookIns: a landscape-stage sub-pass
(before ClearDepthForInterior + seals) - per building, punch ALL
apertures (new DrawLookInPortalPunch callback, always forceFarZ=true,
closing the ISSUES "forceFarZ keys on root kind, under-punches" gap),
then draw the flooded cells' shells + statics far->near. Look-in
frames are NEVER merged into the main frame: a merged cell would draw
post-clear and z-fail against the root's seal (the old ledger
portShape sketch was wrong on this point).
- Look-in cells join the Prepare + partition set so shells have batches
and statics route to ByCell (consumed only by the sub-pass; the main
cell-object pass iterates the main flood's cells).
Register: AP-33 added in the same commit - look-in statics draw WHOLE
(no per-part viewcone; over-include is the safe direction) and look-in
DYNAMICS are deferred (an NPC inside a far building stays invisible -
retail draws objects per overlapped cell in the landscape stage).
Pins: Issue124LookInSeedRegionTests on the real corner-building door -
a seed region containing the aperture floods (and never more than the
full-screen seed), a disjoint region floods NOTHING, and an
interior-side eye never seeds its own exit portal.
Suites: App 259+1skip / Core 1439+2skip / UI 420 / Net 294 green.
Awaiting the user gate: far-building interiors visible through their
apertures from inside; #130 re-gate (top-edge strip) rides the same
launch.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The user's re-gate refuted the scissor fix as THE strip (6c4b6d6 was a
real but sub-pixel under-coverage): the strip survived, screenshot at a
doorway, full width of the opening, top edge only, "very subtle".
Root cause (pinned by Issue130DoorwayStripTests.UnliftedGate_*): the
+0.02 m shell render lift. Cell shells DRAW 2 cm above the dat origin
(z-fight vs coplanar terrain); f35cb8b (the #119-residual fix,
2026-06-11) deliberately reverted the VISIBILITY graph to the physics
(unlifted) transform - but the OutsideView color gate (terrain/sky/
scissor through the doorway) and the seal/punch depth fans are
DRAW-space consumers and kept projecting the unlifted polygons. The
drawn lintel therefore sits one lift-projection above the gate's top
edge - measured 6.7 px at a 2.4 m doorway - and that band never
receives terrain/sky color while the seal also stamps 2 cm low.
A regression from f35cb8b, NOT from the W=0 clip port (987313a stays
exonerated). Vertical aperture edges are immune (the lift slides them
along themselves) - top edge only, exactly as reported; explains the
"also NOW" timing precisely.
Fix - draw space draws lifted, visibility stays physics (the f35cb8b
invariant, now symmetric):
- PortalVisibilityBuilder.Build gains drawLiftZ: the exit-portal branch
projects the OutsideView region with the lifted transform; flood
admission, side tests, and CellViews are untouched (default 0 keeps
every existing visibility test bit-identical).
- The seal/punch fans (DrawRetailPViewPortalDepthWrite) lift their
world verts to the drawn shell's space.
- One shared constant PortalVisibilityBuilder.ShellDrawLiftZ feeds the
shell registration (GameWindow:5604), the gate, and the fans.
Register: AP-32 ADDED - the +0.02 lift had NO row (a pre-register
deviation the 2026-06-12 sweep missed). The row records the split
invariant both ways: a draw-space consumer that forgets the lift
re-opens the #130 strip; a visibility consumer that picks the lifted
transform re-opens the #119-residual side-cull.
Pins: the lifted gate covers the drawn (lifted) aperture to 0.00 px
across the 147-combo sweep; the unlifted gate shows the 6.7 px strip
(sensitivity proof - if the lift is ever removed, this test says the
drawLiftZ plumbing can go too).
Suites: App 257+1skip / Core 1439+2skip / UI 420 / Net 294 green.
Awaiting the user re-gate at a doorway with the lintel on screen.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The user's "doors/doorways leak through terrain and houses over a
landblock" is the #117 mark-pass bias evaluated in the wrong space.
Mechanism (confirmed analytically, Issue129PunchBiasTests): the punch's
pass-A stencil mark biased the aperture fan toward the viewer by a
CONSTANT 0.0005 NDC. NDC depth is non-linear - a constant NDC bias b
spans ~= b*d^2*(f-n)/(f*n) meters of eye depth at eye distance d. With
retail's znear 0.1 (d4b5c71) that is 0.125 m at 5 m but ~190 m at one
landblock: every hill/house in front of a distant aperture passed the
LEQUAL mark and was far-Z punched -> door-shaped leak through the
occluder. This is exactly the risk AD-18's register row recorded
("an occluder within ~bias in front of a distant aperture gets punched
through") - the symptom-scan rule found it before instrumentation.
Fix: cap the bias's EYE-SPACE span at 0.5 m -
biasNdc(d) = min(0.0005, capMeters * near / d^2)
in the mark-pass vertex shader (clipPos.w = eye depth), CPU-mirrored as
PortalDepthMaskRenderer.MarkBiasNdc for tests. Below the ~10 m
crossover the constant-NDC term is smaller and wins - bit-identical to
the T5-validated close-range behavior, so the #108 grass coverage that
justified the bias is untouched. Beyond it the punch can never reach an
occluder more than 0.5 m in front of the aperture plane.
Pins (Issue129PunchBiasTests): the old form spans >100 m of eye depth
at a landblock (the leak, kept as documentation of the refuted shape);
the capped form stays <= 0.5 m at every distance 1-400 m and matches
the validated constant bit-for-bit below 10 m.
AD-18 register row updated in the same commit (bias description + the
#129 closure + the residual risk note: door-hugging geometry beyond the
0.5 m cap at >10 m viewing range re-occludes - the cap constant is the
tuning knob if the gate shows residue).
Suites: App 256+1skip / Core 1439+2skip / UI 420 / Net 294 green.
Awaiting the user visual gate at the original spot (+ #108 cellar
re-check up close).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The user's "thin strip of background color along the TOP outer edge of a
doorway, looking out from inside" is the landscape-slice scissor box, not
the W=0 clip port.
Mechanism (pinned headlessly, Issue130DoorwayStripTests, 147 eye/gaze
combos at the real Holtburg A9B4 0x0170 exit door):
- BeginDoorwayScissor converted the slice NDC AABB to pixels as
Floor(origin) + Ceiling(size). The far edge floor(min)+ceil(max-min)
lands up to ONE PIXEL SHORT of the true top/right edge at unlucky
fractional alignments (captured: top edge y=0.7938 @1080p -> row 968
cut; right edge column 1296 @1920 cut).
- The scissor brackets the ENTIRE landscape slice (sky, terrain, outdoor
statics, weather). The exit-portal SEAL stamps the full raw aperture at
true depth and the shell wall ends at the aperture edge, so the cut row
never receives any color write -> clear color, flickering with eye
movement as the fractional alignment shifts.
- This violated AD-17's own invariant (over-inclusion is safe,
UNDER-inclusion is the bug class). No register change: the fix restores
the row's documented doctrine.
Lead 1 (987313a W=0 clip port regression) REFUTED by the same harness:
the CPU polygon pipeline (ProjectToClip -> ClipToRegion merges ->
ClipPlaneSet planes) is sub-pixel exact against the raw aperture
projection (worst 0.54 px, 0.00 px aligned). For an all-in-front doorway
polygon the port is bit-identical to the old 1e-4 path by construction.
The EyeInsidePortalOpening rescue stays deleted.
Fix: conservative outer bound floor(min)/ceil(max) extracted to
NdcScissorRect.ToPixels (GL-free; containment property proven in the
header comment); BeginDoorwayScissor delegates.
Pins:
- NdcScissorRectTests: center-inside containment across 251 fractional
alignments x 2 framebuffer sizes + both captured regression cases.
- Issue130DoorwayStripTests: production flood + assembler at the real
exit door; asserts the scissor never cuts a plane-admitted fragment
(worstScissorGap 0.00 px post-fix, was 10.8 px capped) and the CPU
pipeline stays sub-pixel exact (canary 1.2 px).
Suites: App 252+1skip / Core 1439+2skip / UI 420 / Net 294 green.
Awaiting the user visual gate at a cottage doorway.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The register's UN-2 row recorded a contradiction: the GetMaxSpeed XML doc
claimed the bare run rate was retail-correct (~5.9 m/s catch-up, calling
the xRunAnimSpeed multiply a misread), while the implementation multiplied
by RunAnimSpeed citing ACE. Settled against the binary, not the pseudo-C:
- BN pseudo-C (acclient_2013_pseudo_c.txt:305127) renders get_max_speed as
void with a bare `this->my_run_rate;` because it DROPS x87 instructions.
- Disassembling the PDB-matched v11.4186 binary at VA 0x00527cb0: all THREE
return paths end `fld <rate>; fmul dword ptr [0x007C8918]; ret`, and the
.rdata dword at 0x007C8918 is 4.0f. Sibling get_adjusted_max_speed
(0x00527d00) carries the same trailing fmul. Verifier committed at
tools/verify_un2_fmul.py (PE parse + byte decode, rerunnable).
- Retail paths: weenie null -> 1.0 x4; InqRunRate ok -> queried x4;
InqRunRate failed -> my_run_rate x4. ACE MotionInterp.cs:665-676 matches.
Changes:
- Doc-comment rewritten: the implementation is retail-correct; the catch-up
speed 2 x get_max_speed ~= 23.5 m/s at run 200 IS retail. The 1-Hz
remote-blip symptom the old comment attributed to this multiply is
therefore UNEXPLAINED by it (if it recurs: #41 family, not this).
- Weenie-null path aligned to retail's LITERAL 1.0 default (was MyRunRate).
- Tests re-pinned to the three retail paths (the old NoWeenie test pinned
the non-retail fallback).
- Register: UN-2 row deleted per the retire rule (6 -> 5 UN rows);
shortlist renumbered.
This is the 2nd confirmed instance of the BN x87-dropout artifact class
(memory: feedback_bn_decomp_field_names) deciding a register row.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Ports retail ACRender::polyClipFinish (0x006b6d00, pc:702749) near-eye
semantics into PortalProjection.ProjectToClip - the fundamental fix for
the in-plane portal clip family (climb strobes, tower-top roof/floor
flap while turning; live-corroborated this session: [viewer-diff]
0xAAB30108 strobing 27x mid-climb, whole interior dropping at the top).
Pseudocode: docs/research/2026-06-11-polyclipfinish-w0-clip-pseudocode.md.
Three legs, all decomp-driven:
1. ProjectToClip clips at w >= 0 EXACTLY (was EyePlaneW=1e-4), with
retail's any-negative-w gate. Boundary intersections land at w == 0
(homogeneous directions), so a portal the eye is CROSSING yields the
correct unbounded half-region that the bounded view-region clip cuts
to the screen. A w=0 vertex cannot survive a bounded region clip
into the divide (direction fails some edge of any bounded convex
region); the measure-zero corner case is guarded non-finite->empty.
2. CellView.CanonicalKey keys ALL-COLLINEAR (zero-area) views as their
snapped segment ("L:" + extremes) instead of rejecting them - retail
PROPAGATES degenerate views (ClipPortals decomp:433651-433711
forwards any count!=0 GetClip output, no area gate anywhere), keeping
the cell behind an exactly-in-plane portal in the draw list (cells
draw whole; onward floods die naturally). Rejection dropped the
whole chain for the frame - the parked-eye knife-edge band. Finite
key space unchanged -> dedup + strict-growth convergence intact.
3. The EyeInsidePortalOpening rescue is DELETED (the T2-documented
compensation for the 1e-4 divergence) along with EyeStandingPerpDist
+ PointInPoly2D. Empty clip = no flood, period (retail's rule).
CornerFloodReplay - the gate that REFUTED the previous deletion
attempt - passes WITHOUT the rescue under the W=0 port.
Harness criterion corrected to retail's rules (it codified the rescue):
cells fully BEHIND the camera are not required (all-behind portals clip
empty in retail); monotone area holds per root regime; the two
manufactured exact-on-plane steps assert root-only (boundary root pick
is ambiguous; the in-plane portal there is ~perpendicular to the gaze =
genuinely off-screen). Build_CollapsedInteriorPortalNearEye test
inverted to pin the retail empty-clip rule (it pinned the rescue).
New pins: eye-crossing portal -> w==0 boundary verts + half-region (not
sliver); gaze-along-plane degenerate view accepted + segment-key dedup;
non-finite guard. Replay harnesses (CornerFloodReplay, Issue120,
TowerAscent, HouseExit, Issue127) all green.
Suites: App 246+1skip / Core 1430+2skip / UI 420 / Net 294.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The users final broken-state session (user-session-capture2.log,
standing in front of broken stairs) reports meshMissing=0 and
entSeen==entDrawn: the staircase is DRAWN WRONG, not missing. The
handoff records the 8 verified fixes shipped today (none was this bug),
the ranked hypothesis space (H-A hydration-time MeshRef corruption via
SetupMesh.Flatten identity fallback - predicts the barrel IS the
collapsed staircase; H-B Tier-1 partial-batch cache; H-C draw compose),
the decisive one-launch probe design, the polyClipFinish/cdstW port
spec for the climb strobes + top flap (read done, constant pinned), the
apparatus inventory, and the paste-ready pickup prompt.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The users tower capture (tower-viewer-capture.log, 551 [viewer] lines)
decodes into three distinct issues:
- #126 (HIGH, #107/#111 family): an OUTDOOR spawn claim on the tower
roof (z=127.2) is grounded to TERRAIN z=112 - the player is warped
through the roof into the tower interior, outdoor-classified ->
the transparent-interior spawn. The snap outdoor branch must ground
to the nearest WALKABLE surface (roofs/GfxObj floors), not terrain.
- #127 (HIGH, the flap mechanism): per-building flood admissions are
BISTABLE per frame under the outdoor root - flood size oscillates
+-1-3 cells at millimetre eye deltas (45<->52 standing on the roof,
including a byte-static eye flip). Every oscillation = building
interiors dropping in/out -> the roof/edge flap; running past a
building = #123. Interior side shows the same family (flood 1<->3,
outPolys 0<->1 during the climb).
- #128: the staircase was invisible the WHOLE climb under a HEALTHY
interior root (0xAAB30107 FullScreen views - the cone cannot cull a
root-cell static), while the SAME build rendered it perfectly in a
different session (diag spawn + screenshot, meshMissing=0).
Session-sticky nondeterminism; the barrel tracks this bug (a
partial subset of staircase parts), NOT dat content (user axiom:
no barrel in retail). Needs a diag-instrumented repro of the users
session shape.
The [viewer] probe now logs the camera forward (fwd=) so the next
capture can be replayed headlessly - Build clip results depend on the
view-projection, not just the eye.
Suites: App 238+1skip, Core 1422+2skip, UI 420, Net 294.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
User verdict on the post-#120 build: "Barrel is gone and more stairs
exist" - the #120 fix partially cured the tower, and the earlier
"legit dat barrels on the landings" claim is RETRACTED (USER AXIOM: the
barrel is NOT in the tower in retail; what the user saw was itself a
render artifact of the corrupted floods, and what the 0x020005D8 cell
statics actually render as is unverified - do not assume barrel).
Remaining tower bugs, both PINNED by TowerAscentReplayTests (the #118
exit-walk pattern, vertical - a helix ascent with the gaze locked ON
the staircase, so a cull has no gaze excuse):
- steps 195-201 (eye z 126.9-127.3, the roof-lip band between the main
cell's ceiling at 126.8 and the roof aperture plane at ~127.2) resolve
OUTDOOR and the per-building exterior flood admits NOTHING (flood=1 =
the outdoor node alone): the eye is above every side aperture's useful
view and ON/INSIDE the roof aperture's plane, so BuildFromExterior's
seed side-test / in-plane reject refuses every exit portal. The tower
interior never floods -> the staircase (a 0x0107 static) cone-culls
while staying walkable (user symptom 1), and the roof-lip cell
geometry flaps as the live eye bobs across the band's edges (user
symptom 2). One mechanism, both symptoms.
- The pin is committed as a SKIPPED red test
(TowerAscent_StaircaseStaysConeVisible_EveryStep; the skip reason
carries the defect) so the suite stays green - un-skip with the fix.
- TowerAscent_RootDoesNotPingPong + the per-step diagnostic stay active.
Fix direction (oracle-first, next): determine which side diverges from
retail - (a) viewer-cell resolution (retail curr_cell may keep the eye
INTERIOR through the band: keep-curr above open-top cells / cell BSP
classifying the parapet bowl as inside 0x010A, where our resolution
demotes to outdoor), or (b) exterior seed admission (retail
ConstructView(CBldPortal) Sidedness with an in-plane eye). Grep the
named decomp for both before touching either layer.
Suites: App 238 + 1 skip (236+3 new, 1 pinned), Core 1419+2skip,
UI 420, Net 294.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The in-tower ACDREAM_WB_DIAG launch (the saved character spawns inside
the #119 tower - a free deterministic repro lever) produced the
mechanism evidence in one run (tower-wbdiag3.log):
1. [wb-error] upload of 0x0100321D died on a GL InvalidOperation in
ManagedGLTextureArray..ctor (new TextureAtlasManager) - caught,
returns null, and the drop is STICKY: _preparationTasks.TryRemove
runs BEFORE the upload, so a failed upload is never re-prepared.
Permanently invisible mesh, one log line. This failure class is the
likely #119 missing-stairs mechanism (dat + extraction +
registration + dispatcher all exonerated by read/test this session).
2. The SAME GL error then fired UNCAUGHT in Tick -> GenerateMipmaps ->
ProcessDirtyUpdatesInternal and killed the process. Both render-
thread - not thread affinity. Filed as #125 (HIGH) with the open
question of GL error attribution (a stale error queued by an earlier
unchecked call lands on WB's diligent glGetError checks).
Also fixed here: WbDrawDispatcher.MedianMicros crashed with
IndexOutOfRange on the first diag flush when exactly 1 sample was
recorded (copy[copy.Length - nz/2] with nz==1) - the same off-by-one
GameWindow's TerrainDiagMedianMicros twin fixed; same fix applied.
ACDREAM_WB_DIAG=1 is usable again.
Suites: App 236, Core 1419+2skip, UI 420, Net 294.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Fix: dynamics' ATTACHED emitters (portal swirls on server-spawned portal
entities, creature effects) fell through EVERY particle filter under the
unified pview path - the landscape slice filter carries outdoor statics
(+ the #118 outside-stage dynamics), the per-cell callback carries cell
statics, and T4 deleted the clipRoot==null global pass from normal
frames. T5 never checked portals; the user's re-gate caught it ("all
portals that were previously showing are now gone"). DrawDynamicsLast
now hands its cone-surviving dynamics (minus outside-stage entities,
whose emitters already drew in the landscape slice - alpha particles
must not double-draw) to a new DrawDynamicsParticles callback;
GameWindow draws Scene-pass emitters filtered to those owner ids,
mirroring DrawRetailPViewCellParticles. Retail shape: emitters draw
with their owner object.
Re-gate ledger (user verdicts are axioms):
- #117 CLOSED ("Yes solved"), #118 CLOSED ("Yes solved" + NPC-through-
door "Yes fixed").
- #108 REOPENED narrowed: cellar-ascent eye-below-grade window only
(grass covers the exit door until the head pops over ground level);
fix belongs on the membership/viewer side - the depth-gated punch
stays (DO-NOT-RETRY).
- #119 user split: phantom walkable stairs at the hill cottage (#113
family), tower missing stairs + barrel (#119 proper), hill-house
transparent-on-entry (#112 - re-check after the #120 fix; the
ping-pong fired at exactly A9B3 0103/010F).
- #120 FIXED pending re-gate (dede7e4).
- NEW #122 window oscillation on entry (re-check after #120 first),
NEW #123 buildings transiently disappear running close past,
NEW #124 far-building back walls missing through openings (lead:
per-building look-in floods run only for outdoor roots -
NearbyBuildingCells is null for interior roots; retail runs the
look-in inside LScape::draw for ANY root).
Suites: App 236, Core 1419+2skip, UI 420, Net 294.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Issue119UpNullGfxObjDumpTests pins the dat truth: 0x010002B4 = 9 polys,
ALL NoPos, all surfaces Base1Solid; 0x010008A8 = 1 poly, NoPos,
Base1Solid|Translucent. Retail's skipNoTexture never draws either model
(the BR-1 build-time-skip <=> draw-time-skip equivalence), so
ObjectMeshManager's empty render-data cache is the CORRECT terminal state
- the only defect was the alarming "permanently invisible" log line,
reworded into an honest tripwire pointing at the dump test.
Second fact, same test (ShellModel_NoTexturedPolyIsDropped): on the
hall/tower shell 0x010014C3, ZERO textured polys are dropped by the
extraction gates (137/149 draw; the 12 dropped are the known #113
no-draw orphans) - the per-poly GfxObj extraction is exonerated for
building shells, kept green as a regression pin.
Net for #119: the missing tower-stair parts are NOT the up-null pair and
NOT a per-poly extraction drop. Remaining hypothesis space (interior
stair-cell flood admission, or a different model than assumed) needs the
re-gate to identify the exact tower; then the cell set + flood replay
headlessly like #118. ISSUES.md updated.
Suites: App 232, Core 1419+2skip (1416+3 new), UI 420, Net 294.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Root cause (pinned by the new deterministic exit-walk harness, NOT guessed):
under an interior render root, the exit-portal SEAL stamps the door fan at
TRUE depth after the gated full depth clear, and T1's "ALL dynamics last"
pass then drew the outdoor-classified player depth-tested - every fragment
beyond the door plane z-failed against the seal across the whole aperture.
Harness measured the full window: from the moment the sphere center crosses
the plane until the eye follows (~2.6 m of camera lag, ~2.2 s at walk speed)
the player is invisible; while straddling, the beyond-plane body half clips
at the plane. The handoff's three cone-level candidates are all EXONERATED:
the cone walk passes every step; (eye, ViewerCellId) come from the same
SweepEye call with camera-update-before-visibility-read in the same frame;
the side-test window is sub-epsilon under healthy resolution.
Retail oracle (grep-named-first): PView::DrawCells 0x005a4840 runs
LScape::draw FIRST (pc:432719), then the gated depth clear (pc:432731-32)
and the exit-portal seals (pc:432785-86); outdoor cell objects draw inside
the landscape stage (DrawBlock 0x005a17c0 -> DrawSortCell pc:430124), and
an object draws once per overlapped shadow cell (pc:430056-64) - the
straddling body composes from both stages, neither half clips.
Fix: RetailPViewRenderer assigns dynamics to the OUTSIDE stage under an
interior root when outdoor-classified OR sphere-straddling an exit-portal
plane of their flood-visible cell (DynamicDrawsInOutsideStage - pure, the
harness drives it as the ordering contract); they ride the landscape slice
draw (pre-clear, seal-protected) with the same per-slice cone test as
outdoor statics. Indoor dynamics keep the last pass (retail loop C);
straddlers draw in both (retail shadow dual-draw). Outdoor roots keep
all-dynamics-last - the BR-2 punch-after-dynamics lesson (88be519) stands.
Apparatus: HouseExitWalkReplayTests - dat-backed corner-building exit walk
driving the production stack headlessly (RetailChaseCamera damping ->
healthy-sweep viewer resolution -> PortalVisibilityBuilder.Build ->
ClipFrameAssembler -> ViewconeCuller -> the DrawDynamicsLast predicate +
a CPU seal-depth model). 5 tests: cone pin, seal-depth pin, straddle
dual-draw pin, per-step table, stale-root window quantifier (#118 cand 2).
Suites: App 232 (227+5), Core 1416+2skip, UI 420, Net 294.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
docs/research/2026-06-11-t6-br7-shipped-t5-gate-post-t5-handoff.md:
the 9-commit ledger with decomp anchors, the per-cell shadow
architecture summary, the T5 gate verdict (collision half 100% passed;
#117-#120 filed), the #117 fix detail (depth-gated punch - re-gate
pending), the #118 narrowing + exit-walk harness design, the #119
up-null lead, the #120 armed tripwire, watchouts/DO-NOT-RETRY
additions, new apparatus inventory, the next-session work order, and
the paste-ready prompt.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Read-level exonerations: the local player routes to Dynamics correctly
(ServerGuid set), and its entity ParentCellId syncs per tick from the
controller - neither is the vanish mechanism. Live candidates are the
doorway-crossing decision stack: (a) eye/cell incoherence under camera
damping (the verified #115/BR-8a divergence - we damp from our own
damped eye while the root comes from the swept cell), (b) the
exit-portal side test culling the OutsideView when the eye is
epsilon-outside while the root is still interior (retail's
AdjustPosition demotes the viewer cell the same moment), (c) the
aperture-cone tightness for an outdoor player with an indoor viewer.
Next step is the deterministic exit-walk harness (all-CPU drive of the
production decision stack over the corner-building cells); designed in
the issue entry, queued for a focused session.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Investigation: retail's growth propagation RECURSES natively too
(AddViewToPortals -> FixCellList -> AdjustCellView -> AddViewToPortals,
Ghidra 0x005a52d0/0x005a5250/0x005a5770, no depth guard) - the in-place
recursion shape is faithful; retail's safety is fast convergence. Our
depth-128 firing means slow/non-saturating growth (each lap of a portal
cycle nests one recursion level), not necessarily a true infinite loop.
Two dat-backed sweeps over the corner-building cell set could NOT
reproduce the T5 firing:
- PortalPlaneCrossings_InPlacePropagationConverges: +/-6cm eye sweep
across every portal plane, seeded from both sides.
- InCellDirectionSweep_InPlacePropagationConverges: 3024 builds, in-cell
eye grid x 8 yaw x 3 pitch (the walking-and-turning regime).
Both pass with 0 firings -> production-only ingredients suspected (full
lookup graph - one T5 firing was 0x0162, another building - and/or the
real camera path).
Armed: PortalVisibilityBuilder.ConvergenceTripwireCount (test
observable, both Build + look-in sites) + DumpPropagationChain - on the
next firing the log carries root cell, eye, per-cell frequency summary,
and the 24-entry chain tail, so the cycle's structure (A<->B ping-pong
vs 3-cycle laps) reads directly off the output. Both sweeps stay as
regression pins.
App tests: 227 green (was 225; +2 pins).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The A6.P4 port, fused into one installment per the BR-2 half-port lesson
(registration and query are co-dependent: flood-registering shells under
the old radial query would re-open #98 through the vestibule).
REGISTRATION (ShadowObjectRegistry rewritten):
- Register/RegisterMultiPart/UpdatePosition compute the cell set via
CellTransit.BuildShadowCellSet (the C2 find_cell_list flood) seeded by
the entity's m_position cell id; the private 24m XY-grid rectangle and
its single-landblock clamp are deleted. Flood spheres follow retail's
CylSphere rule (base point + cyl radius, cap 10; BSP bounding-sphere
fallback - Ghidra 0x0052b9f0). Statics flood with the do_not_load
prune; dynamics (server spawns, isStatic:false) without.
- Keep-when-empty (SetPositionInternal num_cells gate, pc:283540): a
failed flood leaves the previous registration in place.
- RefloodLandblock: streaming-race hook re-runs the flood when a
landblock's cells hydrate (retail init_objects -> recalc_cross_cells,
Ghidra 0x0052b420/0x00515a30); wired at GameWindow's hydration tail.
- GameWindow sites pass the server position's full cell id as the seed
(spawn + UpdatePosition); the five static sites pass ParentCellId.
BUILDING CHANNEL (CSortCell.building shape):
- Building SHELLS are not shadow objects in retail (only caller of
find_building_collisions is CSortCell::find_collisions 0x005340aa;
one building per origin landcell, init_buildings 0x0052fd80 verified
verbatim + ACE cross-ref). IsBuildingShell entities skip the registry;
Transition.FindBuildingCollisions runs the shell part-0 BSP off
cache.GetBuilding(cellId) with bldg_check set around it
(find_building_collisions 0x006b5300), CollidedWithEnvironment on
non-Contact non-OK. BuildingPhysics.ModelId = pre-resolved part-0
GfxObj (0x02 Setups resolved at the CacheBuilding site).
- Placement/ethereal weakening: BSPQuery Path 1 passes center_solid=0
when BldgCheck && HitsInteriorCell (BSPTREE::find_collisions 0x0053a82e
+ placement_insert 0x005399d8) so doorway crossings don't hard-fail
against shell solids. SpherePath gains both retail fields;
HitsInteriorCell is rebuilt at every cell-array build
(build_cell_array reset 0x00509ef2 + find_cell_list/check_building_
transit set sites).
QUERY (retail per-cell order, transitional_insert 0x0050b6f0):
- TransitionalInsert per attempt: env -> building (LandCell only) ->
objects on the PRIMARY cell, then on OK the check_other_cells pass
(env -> building -> objects per OTHER overlapped cell) + the
carried-cell advance - the advance now happens AFTER all per-cell
object passes (the WF1 ordering divergence), with Adjusted/Slid
feeding the retry exactly like retail's OK_TS case.
- FindObjCollisionsInCell = CObjCell::find_obj_collisions (0x0052b750):
iterate ONLY the asked cell's list. DELETED: the radial 9-landblock
sweep, the +5m query pad, the b3ce505 indoor-primary gate, and the
isViewer exemption (the camera is bounded by interior cell-BSP env
collision - retail's own channel; CameraCornerSealReplayTests pins it
against real dat, and the new building-channel camera test pins the
outdoor stop).
TESTS: Core 1416/0/2 (was 1398 + 4 pre-existing #99-era fails + 1 skip),
App 225, UI 420, Net 294 - all green.
- 3 of the 4 #99-era reds flipped green as designed: the door apparatus
(Apparatus_Grounded_50cmOffCenter_FrontApproach_Blocks) and tick-13558
(indoor walkthrough) now assert the door BLOCKS; tick-22760 pins the
outdoor blocking invariant.
- The 4th (BSPStepUp D4) + 22760's lateral-slide delta are NOT cell-set
problems (probes prove the door is found + BSP-only dispatched;
BR-7 left both byte-identical) - filed as issue #116 (slide-response
family), D4 skipped with the issue reference.
- FindEnvCollisionsMultiCellTests migrated to the public entry (the A4
multi-cell halt now lives at the retail call site).
- New registry pins: per-cell query surface, outdoor-footprint-never-
indoor (#98 architectural), door-outdoor-cell membership, reflood.
- CameraCollisionIndoorTests rewritten against the building channel
(the isViewer-exemption pins died with the exemption).
Closes#99 (doors block both ways via registration-time cell membership
+ the straddle-spanning player cell array). #97 likely closed (the +5m
radial pad that produced phantom-collision candidates is gone) - verify
at T5. #98 stays closed ARCHITECTURALLY (outdoor footprints structurally
cannot reach interior cells; the cellar harness stays green).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Doc-and-reality sync before the session handoff: the plan's phase
sections read future-tense while T1-T4 landed them. The render digest
carries the authoritative ledger; this stamp points there and names the
4 pre-existing #99-era Core failures as BR-7's built-in acceptance
signal.
'I don't care if it is non-playable... I want everything ported, then we
test.' Per-phase playability + per-phase visual gates DROPPED. BR-2..BR-6
execute as ONE continuous port with build+tests green per commit and a
single comprehensive visual pass at the end (T5). Replaces the
playability rule with: every installment must be a COMPLETE retail
behavior, never half of one (the BR-2 punch-without-ordering lesson,
88be519).
The BR-2 punch/seal gate proved #108 (cellar grass-sweep) is a membership
flip (player classified outdoor mid-cellar), not a render depth bug. The
punch only masked it on outdoor-root frames. Move #108 to the membership
track; the interior depth seal is a separate mechanism that does not fix it.
The plan's BR-1 ('implement the skipNoTexture draw-time surface gate')
died on its pre-check: acdream ALREADY suppresses every portal fill.
ReplicateProductionEmission_OnPortalFills replicates the exact emission
conditions of the production extractors on the hall/cottage fills:
pos=False neg=False for every one (Stippling.NoPos skips the positive
side at ObjectMeshManager.PrepareGfxObjMeshData:1046,
PrepareCellStructMeshData:1394, CellMesh.Build:44, GfxObjMesh.Build:71;
the fills have no negative surface). There is nothing to gate.
What ships instead: StipplingSurfaceEquivalenceTests - 2,607 polys across
13 building models + 13 environments, ZERO violations both directions:
NoPos <=> untextured-surface. Our build-time skip is proven equivalent to
retail's draw-time skipNoTexture rule (Ghidra 0x0059d4a4, default on
@0x00820e30) on this content. The pin fails loudly if future content
breaks the invariant - the cue to implement the draw-time gate then.
Corrections folded into the plan + comparison docs:
- The #113 phantom residual CANNOT be GfxObj fills (they never reach a
vertex buffer). Plausible true sites are cell-side: flood-admitted
cells drawn with the pass-all NoClipSlice when slot-less
(RetailPViewRenderer.cs:71), and/or cell statics drawn unclipped +
un-viewcone'd (object-lists-skip-portal-view-gate, confirmed).
BR-2 opens with the probe that pins which.
- The e46d3d9 user-gate observations (filter removed phantom/doors) were
confounded - the filter was a provable mesh no-op on shells AND doors.
- Ledger rows solid-surface-skip-missing + the acdream half of
portal-polys-baked-unconditional re-marked REFUTED-for-fills; the
retail mechanism descriptions and the un-consumed PortalIndex->
CBldPortal pairing (BR-4) stand.
Suites: Core 1398 green (1392 baseline + 6 new facts) + the 4 pre-existing
#99-era failures + 1 skip. No production code.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Names the boundary of what BR-1..BR-8 delivers, so the gaps are written
down rather than silently assumed (the very thing that breeds whack-a-mole):
FU-1 transparency/sorting (BR-9 candidate, area unmapped), FU-2 dungeon
visibility scaling #95 (plausibly helped by BR-4/BR-6 but NOT guaranteed -
re-measure after), FU-3 LOD/degrades, FU-4 picking, FU-5 the ~30 open
questions (in the comparison doc $6), FU-6 verification top-up before
BR-8b lighting. None blocks BR-1..BR-8; each becomes its own item.
The #95 dungeon-scaling follow-up was previously raised only verbally -
now tracked in the plan. Sections 4/5 renumbered to 5/6.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Deliverable 1: docs/research/2026-06-11-building-render-acdream-vs-retail-
comparison.md - the acdream-vs-retail architecture comparison synthesized
from two ultracode mapping fan-outs (11/12 areas, ~90 agents, every retail
claim Ghidra/pc-cited, every acdream claim file:line, 40/76 divergences
adversarially verified so far; raw per-area evidence committed under
docs/research/2026-06-11-holistic-map/).
Headline findings: (1) retail flattens GfxObjs/cells at load exactly like
us (ConstructMesh + RemoveNonPortalNodes) - the MDI pipeline survives;
(2) the phantom/door mechanism is the skipNoTexture draw-time surface gate
(dat-confirmed); (3) retail never geometrically clips world geometry -
aperture exactness is a DEPTH discipline (punch maxZ1 / seal maxZ2 / gated
clear + far-to-near whole-mesh draws) - reframes #114; (4) flood admission
is already faithful, the trigger/depth/multi-view/cone-culling layers are
missing; (5) #115 root cause verified (boom damping severed from the
published collided viewer); collision A6.P4 design verified with
corrections (signed other_portal_id >= 0 gate).
Deliverable 2: docs/plans/2026-06-11-building-render-port-plan.md - the
phased port plan (BR-1 surface gate, BR-2 depth punch/seal, BR-3 delete
the shell chop, BR-4 draw-driven floods, BR-5 viewconeCheck, BR-6 one
gate, BR-7 collision A6.P4, BR-8 camera/lighting/LOD) with per-phase
acceptance criteria, bug closures, keep-list, and a playable-after-every-
phase migration order. AWAITING USER APPROVAL - no implementation.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
User mandate: stop bug-by-bug; map acdream-vs-retail for building draw,
interiors, interior collision, dynamics, clipping, culling; plan the port
of retails drawing discipline once and for all. The handoff carries the
branch state (124c6cb, nothing on main), the full evidence inventory from
this session (orphan no-draw polys, door-vanish mystery, draw-side clip
status, straddle gate), the gap map, tooling (Ghidra MCP 8081 correct
PDB, live cdb protocol, dat dump + flood harnesses), the investigation
charter (workflow fan-out per subsystem, adversarial verification), and
the paste-ready new-session prompt. #113 marked REOPENED and folded in.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
#113 moved to Recently closed: the phantom staircase was the Holtburg
meeting hall (AAB3, not A9B3) interior stair cells drawn unclipped from
outside - the PView shell clip was routed but never GL-enabled (927fd8f).
Misplaced-cell hypothesis refuted with dat evidence. #112 residual
paragraph updated: retail straddle gate live-binary verified + ported
(414c3de); at-doorway demote is retail-faithful, deep gaps now keep-curr.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
