Apparatus only — no fix attempt. Per the systematic-debugging skill's
"3+ failures = question architecture" rule, the 6 hypotheses we
tested speculatively on the harness's airborne-at-tick-1 bug all
failed because we kept guessing what state the harness lacks. This
commit ships the evidence-driven path: capture the EXACT player
ResolveWithTransition call (every input + body-before + body-after +
result) into a JSON Lines fixture, then a comparison test loads the
fixture and replays it against the test engine. The first per-field
divergence pinpoints the missing apparatus state — no more guessing.
Adds:
- src/AcDream.Core/Physics/PhysicsResolveCapture.cs — new static module
with CapturePath (env var ACDREAM_CAPTURE_RESOLVE), PhysicsBodySnapshot
record, JSON Lines writer (thread-safe, flushes per record), process-
exit hook for clean shutdown.
- PhysicsEngine.ResolveWithTransition probe wiring: snapshot body at
method entry, snapshot again before return, refactor the two returns
into one path so the capture call site is single. Filtered to
IsPlayer mover flag so NPC/remote DR calls don't pollute.
- CellarUpTrajectoryReplayTests.cs:
• Capture_WritesJsonLinesRecordsWhenIsPlayerAndEnabled — drives 3
ticks with capture on, reads file back, verifies round-trip of
inputs + body-before/after snapshots.
• Capture_SkipsNonPlayerCalls — drives 3 NPC-style ticks (no
IsPlayer flag), confirms the file is not created.
Off by default. Set ACDREAM_CAPTURE_RESOLVE=<path> to a writable file
path; capture starts on the next player ResolveWithTransition call.
Test baseline: 1172 + 8 pre-existing failures + 2 new smoke tests
that pass = 1174 + 8. Verified by stashed-baseline comparison.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds the canonical pickup document
docs/research/2026-05-23-a6-p3-issue98-harness-handoff.md with:
- TL;DR + session arc (10 commits chronological)
- What the trajectory replay harness IS (committed apparatus)
- Bug 1 status: #98 cellar-up freeze (unfixed, 6 fix shapes failed)
- Bug 2 status: airborne-at-tick-1 (new, 6 hypotheses tested, root
cause not isolated)
- Exclusion list: DO NOT retry any of the 6+6 dead ends
- Apparatus inventory: probes, tests, fixtures, cdb captures
- Recommended next move: side-by-side comparison harness against
live PlayerMovementController state (evidence-first instead of
speculation-first)
- Alternative moves: pivot to other M1.5 issues or M2 prep
- Self-contained pickup prompt at the bottom of the handoff doc
Updates CLAUDE.md's "Current A6 phase" block to point at the new
handoff doc as the canonical resume artifact.
Updates ISSUES.md's #98 entry with the late-day extension findings,
the 6-hypothesis exclusion list, and a pointer to the handoff doc.
Test baseline maintained at 1172 + 8 pre-existing failures.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Multi-step investigation of the airborne-at-tick-1 bug per the
systematic-debugging skill. Several hypotheses tested via the
harness, each producing the same (0,1,0) hit normal at tick 1:
1. WalkablePolygon seeding ADDED to BuildInitialBody (was missing).
PhysicsEngine.cs:665-673 requires body.WalkablePolygonValid +
WalkableVertices to call SpherePath.SetWalkable. With seeded
walkable poly: walkPoly=True survives tick 1 (was False before).
BUT engine still reports hit=(0,1,0) and body goes airborne.
2. Initial Z lift removed (back to 0): same airborne behavior.
3. Synthetic stair GfxObj DISABLED: same (0,1,0) hit. Hit is not
from FindObjCollisions.
4. Stub landblock REMOVED: same (0,1,0). FindObjCollisions early-
returns without landblock context, FindEnvCollisions's outdoor
terrain returns null. Hit is not from terrain.
5. SYNTHETIC BSP attached to cell fixtures (Hydrate sets BSP=null
per its xmldoc; without BSP the indoor branch is skipped, falls
through to outdoor terrain). One-leaf BSP referencing every poly
in cell.Resolved. Indoor BSP path now runs. Same (0,1,0) hit.
Trace timeline at tick 1:
find-start: walkPoly=True, CP valid, oi=0x303 (Contact+OnWalkable)
after-adjust: req=(0,-0.1,0) adj=(0,-0.1,0) — no projection change
before-insert: check=(141.5, 9.4, 91.43)
stepdown-enter (Contact-recovery): stepDown=True, height=0.04
stepdown-after-offset: check=(141.5, 9.4, 91.39) — moved DOWN 0.04
stepdown-after-insert: state=OK, cp=n/a (no walkable found)
stepdown-reject
(second stepdown attempt — same outcome)
after-insert: state=Collided, hit=n/a, walkPoly=False
after-validate: state=OK, hit=(0,1,0), slide=(0,1,0)
oi=0x300 (Contact+OnWalkable CLEARED)
The (0,1,0) hit is set by ValidateTransition between after-insert
and after-validate. ValidateTransition's default-push-up code path
sets UnitZ=(0,0,1), NOT UnitY=(0,1,0). So something INSIDE
TransitionalInsert sets ci.CollisionNormal=(0,1,0) before
ValidateTransition runs (12 SetCollisionNormal call sites in
TransitionTypes.cs — root cause not isolated to one).
Per systematic-debugging skill: 5+ hypotheses tested without
convergence = "question architecture". The bug is hidden deeper
than a single misconfigured init field.
Next session pickup: build a side-by-side instrumentation harness
that mimics PlayerMovementController's EXACT call sequence
(PhysicsBody field state, ResolveWithTransition args, frame
ordering) and compare per-tick divergence against a live capture.
The harness is missing some piece of state production carries
across ticks — find what piece.
Apparatus progress (committed):
- Harness with synthetic stair GfxObj registration (Issue #98 ramp polygon now constructable programmatically)
- Synthetic cell-BSP attachment (AttachSyntheticBsp) — unlocks indoor
BSP collision path for hydrated cell fixtures
- WalkablePolygon seeding in BuildInitialBody (PhysicsBody seeding pattern documented)
- Three diagnostic dump tests for tick-by-tick traces
Test baseline: 1167 + 5 (harness) = 1172 + 8 pre-existing failures.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds two diagnostic-only tests:
- Harness_DiagnosticDump_FirstTenTicks: prints trajectory + resolve
probe lines for the seeded-body path
- Harness_DiagnosticDump_NoBodySeed: same but with body=null, isolating
whether the CP seed contributes to the airborne-at-tick-1 issue
Also adjusts InitialSphereWorld to lift the sphere by 0.05m above
cellar floor (sphere bottom at Z=91.00, not Z=90.95). The lift
should give the engine a clean step-down on tick 1 instead of an
exact-boundary contact.
Experimental finding: NEITHER the no-body-seed path NOR the 0.05m
lift changes the airborne-at-tick-1 behavior. With sphere center
at world Z=91.48 (0.05m + radius above cellar floor at 90.95):
- Tick 1: in=(141.5, 9.5, 91.48), out=(141.5, 9.5, 91.48) — Y move
rejected. hit=yes n=(0,0,1) walkable=False.
- Tick 2+: Y advances by 0.1/tick, Z stays put, onGround stays False.
The hit normal (0,0,1) at tick 1 means the engine treats the cellar
floor polygon as a NON-WALKABLE collision target when the sphere is
seeded grounded above it. The walkability classifier returns False
even though Normal.Z=1.0 > FloorZ=0.6642. This is a real engine bug
worth investigating in a future session — independent of the cellar-up
freeze.
The synthetic ramp polygon registered via RegisterStairRampGfxObj is
NOT reached because the sphere is now airborne and floats over the
cellar floor without contacting the ramp.
Next session pickup options:
1. Debug the airborne-at-tick-1 issue (likely in TransitionTypes
FindEnvCollisions indoor BSP path — why does a flat (0,0,1) hit
return walkable=False?). Once fixed, the harness should reproduce
cellar-up freeze.
2. Pivot to a different M1.5 issue with cleaner reproduction.
3. Use the harness mechanics elsewhere — the synthetic-GfxObj +
ShadowEntry pattern is reusable for any indoor-static-collision
test (corpse pickup boundaries, door swings, etc.).
Test baseline: 1167 + 5 (harness) = 1172 + 8 pre-existing failures.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Extends the trajectory replay harness with a programmatic mini-stair
piece, reconstructed from the live capture's polydump data
(docs/research/2026-05-21-a6-captures/scen4_cottage_cellar_polydump).
NEW finding: the cellar ramp polygon is NOT in cellStruct.PhysicsPolygons.
It lives in a separate GfxObjPhysics (the cellar's stair-piece static
building) registered via ShadowObjectRegistry, queried via
FindObjCollisions → engine.DataCache.GetGfxObj. CellDumpSerializer is
CORRECT — it captures the cell's physics polygons accurately. The
ramp polygon comes from a different data source entirely.
The polydump probe at BSPQuery.AdjustSphereToPlane:402 reports
"cell=0xA9B40147 polyId=0x0008 sides=Landblock" because the SPHERE
is in that cell at hit time — but the polygon's actual source is the
building's GfxObj. Inside the cellar fixture, polyId=0x0008 happens
to be a wall (Normal=(1,0,0)); inside the building's GfxObj, polyId
=0x0008 is the ramp (Normal=(0,-0.719,0.695) local). Same ID, different
collection.
The new RegisterStairRampGfxObj() in the harness constructs the
building's ramp polygon in WORLD coordinates (translated from
local building frame + 180° yaw), wraps it in a minimal one-leaf
PhysicsBSPTree, registers via cache.RegisterGfxObjForTest, and
attaches a ShadowEntry with cellScope=CellarId so the shadow is only
queried when the sphere is in the cellar cell (matches retail's
per-cell shadow scoping for interior statics — Issue #91 family).
Verified: world plane n=(0,0.719,0.695), d=-69.5035 (matches live
cdb capture exactly to 4 sig figs). Ramp foot at world Y=8.745,
Z=90.955; ramp top at world Y=5.845, Z=93.955. 3.0 m vertical rise.
NEW blocker discovered: the sphere goes airborne at tick 1 (same
issue documented in the prior commit's Finding #2). Sphere FLOATS
at Z=91.43 over the cellar floor, never contacts the synthetic
ramp. The synthetic stair registration mechanics are validated (the
GfxObj is in the cache, the ShadowEntry is in the registry, the
BSP tree is well-formed) — but trajectory replay still blocked on
the seeded-grounded-state bug. Next session needs to diagnose
WHY the engine reports "hit=yes n=(0,0,1) walkable=False" on tick 1
for a sphere correctly seeded as grounded on the cellar floor.
Test baseline maintained: 1167 + 4 (harness) = 1171 + 8 pre-existing
failures.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds tests/AcDream.Core.Tests/Physics/CellarUpTrajectoryReplayTests.cs:
a deterministic harness that drives PhysicsEngine.ResolveWithTransition
through N ticks against pre-loaded cell fixtures, capturing per-tick
trajectory points. Pure indoor (no landblock registration needed),
runs 200 ticks in under 100 ms.
The harness MECHANICS work — engine constructs cleanly, DataCache
accepts test fixtures via RegisterCellStructForTest, PhysicsBody
carries ContactPlane state across ticks. 4/4 tests pass, baseline
maintained (1167 + 4 = 1171 + 8 pre-existing failures).
Two real findings surfaced during commissioning, both documented as
passing tests so they don't regress silently:
Finding 1 (Harness_FixtureLimitation_NoRampPolygon): the three
issue-#98 cell fixtures contain ONLY axis-aligned polygons. The
cellar fixture (0xA9B40147) has 37 polys: 8 floor (N=(0,0,1)), 7
ceiling (N=(0,0,-1)), 22 walls. The live capture's CELLAR RAMP
polygon (N ≈ (0, ±0.719, 0.695)) is NOT in any fixture. With no
ramp polygon, the harness can't reproduce the cellar-up climb —
the sphere would walk horizontally across the cellar floor without
ever encountering a slope. Re-capture needed; investigate whether
CellDumpSerializer is skipping polygons or whether the ramp lives
in a cell we didn't dump.
Finding 2 (Harness_Finding_SphereGoesAirborneAtTick1): at the
seeded grounded initial position (sphere center 0.48 m above cellar
floor, ContactPlane = (0,0,1,-90.95), OnWalkable bit set), the
engine reports `hit=yes n=(0,0,1) walkable=False` on tick 1 and
the body's IsOnGround flips to false. Subsequent ticks proceed as
airborne (Y advances, Z stays put — no gravity in the input offset).
Unclear whether this is an engine bug (floor contact classified
as non-walkable collision) or a fixture issue (cellar floor
polygon's containment test mis-firing at the seeded XY). Either
way, the harness now exposes it deterministically.
Net value of this commit: the harness CODE is ready. Once the
fixture issue is solved, fix attempts on #98 (or any trajectory-
dependent bug) iterate in <100 ms instead of 5-minute live-launch
cycles. The "why is this so hard" point #4 from the session-pause
handoff is addressed for everything except the missing-ramp gap.
Test baseline: 1171 (1167 + 4 new) + 8 pre-existing failures.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Updates ISSUES.md and CLAUDE.md to reflect the actual state of #98
after two days of work:
- The new [step-walk-adjust] probe (8a232a3) + capture + findings
(8daf7e7) prove AdjustOffset's slope projection is CORRECT. Sphere
Z climbs monotonically 90.95 -> 92.80 across the ramp at +0.045 m
mean zGain per call. The earlier "Fix targets 1-4" priority list
is OBSOLETE — AdjustOffset is not the bug.
- The climb caps at world Z ~= 92.80 because step-up's downward
step-down probe finds no walkable within stepDownHeight=0.6 m
below the proposed position. Cottage floor at Z=94 is ABOVE, not
below. 101 stepdown-reject hits in the capture vs 1 acceptance.
- Shape 1 fix attempted (0cb4c59): gated BSPQuery.AdjustSphereToPlane's
two SetContactPlane call sites by Normal.Z >= 0.99 to match retail's
cdb-observed flat-CP-only pattern. Reverted (402ec10) — gate broke
OnWalkable tracking. 74% of new capture in falling state. User
report: "can't get up the first step, jumped, stuck in falling
animation." Either retail synthesizes a flat CP from sloped
contacts (step_sphere_down:321203 path, unclear from BN decomp)
or our OnWalkable tracking is over-coupled to ContactPlaneValid.
Apparatus state: probe, findings, replay harness, plan, retail
cdb capture all committed and ready for next session.
Honest next-session moves (in order):
1. Build deterministic trajectory replay harness — 200ms inner loop
instead of 5-minute live test. Issue98 cell fixtures are half of
this already.
2. Pivot to less-coupled M1.5 issue while #98 awaits the harness.
3. Deeper named-decomp research on CEnvCell::find_env_collisions ->
BSPTREE::find_collisions indoor CP-setting chain. Prior passes
worked on the outdoor CLandCell path; indoor was never traced.
NO further #98 fix attempts until apparatus or research has
converged. Five+ failed attempts in the saga is the signal.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds PhysicsGlobals.ContactPlaneFlatThreshold = 0.99f and uses it at
both BSPQuery.AdjustSphereToPlane call sites that previously set CP
unconditionally on any walkable polygon found by FindWalkableInternal.
Backed by the retail cdb capture in cellar_up_capture_1: across 161
set_contact_plane writes during 5 seconds of cellar-up climbing,
EVERY write lands on a flat (Normal.Z = 1.0) plane — cellar floor at
world Z=90.95 or cottage floor at world Z=94. The cellar ramp
(Normal.Z = 0.695, walkable per FloorZ but sloped ~46 degrees) is
never set as CP in retail.
Acdream's prior behavior of setting CP=ramp caused two cascading
issues at the top of the ramp:
1. AdjustOffset's slope-projection produced +Z gain per call (correct
in isolation) but inflated step-up's responsibility to "find the
next walkable below the lifted check position".
2. step-up's downward step-down probe found no walkable within 0.6m
below the proposed check (cottage floor at Z=94 is ABOVE, not
below), so step-down rejected, sphere rolled back. Infinite freeze
at world Z ~= 92.80.
With CP only set on flat polygons, sloped surfaces drive collision
detection and walkable-poly tracking (via path.SetWalkable) but
don't override the resting CP. The sphere should now climb the ramp
via step-up over the ramp polygon, with CP staying on the flat
cellar floor until the sphere reaches the flat cottage floor.
Tests: 1167 + 8 baseline maintained. No regression. The Issue98
replay tests still pass — they document the failing-frame geometry
(sphere world Z=92.01 below cottage floor), which doesn't change;
the fix prevents the sphere from getting STUCK at that altitude in
the first place. Live visual verification required next.
If the live test shows new failure modes (sphere stuck somewhere
else, doesn't climb at all, climbs but slides off, etc), the
threshold (0.99) or the gating approach itself may need refining.
This is the conservative empirical version of Shape 1; the named-
decomp research did not conclusively prove the exact retail gate.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The diagnostic-first capture revealed the failure mode the plan's
four-branch decision tree (A/B/C/D) did not anticipate. AdjustOffset
is CORRECT: 145/146 calls use the into-plane branch, mean zGain
+0.045 m per call, sphere world Z climbs 90.95 -> 92.80 monotonically.
The climb caps at world Z 92.80 (cottage floor at 94.00 is still
1.20 m above). At the cap, the per-step CP reset at TransitionTypes.cs
723-725 clears ContactPlaneValid as designed; TransitionalInsert
should re-establish CP at the proposed position. Step-up logic fires
because the offset has +Z; step-up calls DoStepDown(stepDownHeight=
0.6, runPlacement=true). The downward probe finds NO walkable surface
within 0.6 m below the proposed position (cottage floor is ABOVE,
not below) -- 101 stepdown-reject hits in this capture vs 1 acceptance.
Conclusion: Target E (new). Three candidate fix shapes named in the
findings note. Each one researched against retail named-decomp before
any code lands. Test baseline 1167 + 8 maintained.
Findings: docs/research/2026-05-23-a6-stepwalkadjust-findings.md
Capture: docs/research/2026-05-23-a6-captures/stepwalkadjust/acdream.log
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds one log line per AdjustOffset call (gated by ACDREAM_PROBE_STEP_WALK)
naming the branch taken (no-cp / no-cp-slide / slide-degenerate /
slide-crease / into-plane / away-plane, optionally +safety-push) plus
zGain = output.Z - input.Z.
No math or control-flow changes — pure observability so the next capture
can disambiguate the three failure-mode hypotheses for the cellar-ramp
climb cap. Re-reading the existing capture (a6-issue98-negpoly-...log)
showed the sphere DOES climb 90.00 -> 92.79 (2.79 m gain), then caps,
contradicting the divergence comparison's "no altitude gain" framing.
The real question is what stops the climb at world Z ~= 92.79 with the
cottage floor still 1.21 m higher. Existing [step-walk] probes wrap
AdjustOffset; this new probe reveals which branch the projection takes.
Fix plan with the four-branch decision tree at
docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-23-a6-p3-issue98-cellar-up-fix.md.
Test baseline maintained: 1167 + 8.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Final step of the apparatus plan. Updates ISSUES.md issue #98 and
CLAUDE.md's M1.5 status to reflect:
- The apparatus completed (Steps 1-5 land in commits 35b37df →
28c282a).
- The real divergence: retail's sphere is at world Z ≈ 94.48 (resting
on cottage floor) when find_walkable accepts; acdream's failing-
frame sphere is 2.47m lower at world Z ≈ 92.01.
- The four fix targets, in priority order. Fix plan is the NEXT plan,
scoped to Target 1 (step-up + ramp climb Z gain) or Target 2
(cottage-cell sphere reference).
- The replay harness (Issue98CellarUpReplayTests) is the test loop —
any fix that doesn't change the failing assertions is not the fix.
Today's commit graph on top of slice 5 (cf3deff):
35b37df triage — revert neg-poly + bldg-check experiments
f62a873 Step 2 — cell-dump probe + roundtrip test
3f56915 Step 2 capture — 3 real-geometry cell fixtures
856aa78 Step 3 — deterministic replay harness (7 tests)
6f666c1 Step 4 — retail cdb find_walkable capture script
28c282a Step 5 — replay vs retail divergence comparison
(this) Step 6 — ISSUES.md + CLAUDE.md handoff
Test baseline: 1167 + 8 (8 pre-existing failures, +19 new passing
tests across the apparatus). Build green throughout.
A6.P3 #98 is now in evidence-driven mode. Fix plan starts from the
divergence doc at
docs/research/2026-05-23-a6-p3-issue98-replay-comparison.md.
Pickup prompt for the fix-plan session is in §"Pickup prompt for the
fix plan" of that doc.
Closes the apparatus loop. Side-by-sides acdream's deterministic replay
(commit 856aa78) against retail's cdb capture taken via Step 4's
runner. The divergence target is named; the fix plan is the next plan.
Retail data (cellar_up_capture_1):
- 35,219 BP hits over ~5 seconds of motion
- BPE (set_contact_plane): 161 writes, ALL to one of two flat planes
(n=(0,0,1) d=-93.9998 = cottage floor @ Z=94, OR d=-90.95 = cellar
floor @ Z=90.95). Retail NEVER sets ContactPlane to the cellar ramp.
- BPC (find_crossed_edge): 1 hit in 35K. Retail barely uses this
predicate during cellar-up.
- BPA (find_walkable) sphere position at each cottage-floor
acceptance: sphere LOCAL Z = +0.48 to +0.63 (resting on top of the
floor plane). Sphere world Z ≈ 94.48.
acdream replay (Issue98CellarUpReplayTests):
- At the failing-frame sphere (world (141.7, 8.4, 92.0)), the cottage
cell 0xA9B40143's poly 0x0004 reports insideEdges=false AND
overlapsSphere=false. Sphere local Z = -0.69 (below the cottage
floor plane). 0xA9B40146 has no walkable candidate at all. Step-up
has nothing to step onto → stuck.
Sphere world Z delta: 2.47m. Retail's sphere is 2.5m higher than ours
at the decision point. The fix targets, in priority order:
1. (HIGHEST CONFIDENCE) Step-up + ramp climb doesn't gain enough Z per
tick. Retail climbs the ramp GRADUALLY across thousands of ticks;
ours oscillates at world Z ≈ 92 without altitude gain. Look at
Transition.AdjustOffset (slope projection) and Transition.DoStepUp
(does it reset WalkInterp like retail's step_sphere_up?).
2. Cottage-cell candidacy uses wrong sphere reference. Check what
sphere CheckOtherCells passes to BSPQuery.FindCollisions — is it
the step-lifted sphere or the pre-step sphere?
3. (SECONDARY) find_crossed_edge over-use. Our walkable test calls
FindCrossedEdge heavily; retail barely uses it. Possibly a
code-shape mismatch in step-up vs walkable-acceptance flow.
4. (LOW CONFIDENCE) Ramp polygon normal divergence. Verify via test
after any fix.
The apparatus that gets us here:
- tests/AcDream.Core.Tests/Fixtures/issue98/*.json (real cell geometry)
- Issue98CellarUpReplayTests (7 tests, <1ms each, deterministic bug
reproduction)
- tools/cdb/issue98-runner.ps1 (reusable for any future capture)
- docs/research/2026-05-23-a6-captures/cellar_up_capture_1/ (this
capture, checked in for future analyses)
Next plan: pick Target 1 or 2 from the comparison doc and write the
fix plan against it. The replay harness is the test loop; a fix that
doesn't change the failing assertions in Issue98CellarUpReplayTests is
not the fix.
Step 4 of the apparatus plan. Adds the cdb script + runner that pairs
with Issue98CellarUpReplayTests to compare retail's walkable-query
behavior against acdream's during the Holtburg cottage cellar ascent.
Breakpoints (all symbols verified against refs/acclient.pdb via grep
docs/research/named-retail/symbols.json):
- BPA: BSPLEAF::find_walkable — leaf-level walkable query
- BPB: CPolygon::walkable_hits_sphere — per-polygon overlap test
- BPC: CPolygon::find_crossed_edge — per-polygon edge containment
- BPD: CTransition::check_other_cells — outer dispatcher
- BPE: COLLISIONINFO::set_contact_plane — GOLD signal: retail accepted
this plane
- BPF: CPolygon::adjust_sphere_to_plane — per-polygon projection
Output format: 32-bit hex bits for all floats via dwo() + %08X (cdb's
%f handling is broken for dwo reads; see a6-probe.cdb v3→v4 history).
Decoder: tools/cdb/decode_retail_hex.py already handles _h=0x... fields.
Auto-detach threshold: 50000 hits across BPA/B/C/D/F. BPE is unbounded
(contact plane writes are rare, ~18 per ascent per slice 5 capture).
Runner: tools/cdb/issue98-runner.ps1
.\tools\cdb\issue98-runner.ps1 -ScenarioTag "cellar_up_attempt_1"
Prereqs (per CLAUDE.md retail debugger toolchain section):
- Retail acclient.exe v11.4186 running and in-world
- ACE running on 127.0.0.1:9000
- Character at the BOTTOM of a Holtburg cottage cellar stair
- cdb.exe present at the Windows Kits 10 path
Output:
docs\research\2026-05-23-a6-captures\<ScenarioTag>\retail.log
Reading the log:
- [BPE] lines tell you which plane retail accepted (the answer we need).
- Cross-reference [BPE]'s normal/d against the cell fixtures in
tests/AcDream.Core.Tests/Fixtures/issue98/*.json to identify which
cell + polyId retail picked.
- The divergence between retail's accepted polygon and our replay test's
"no walkable accepted" result IS the fix target.
The capture itself is a user action (cdb requires a live retail
process); this commit only ships the protocol. Step 5 (comparison doc)
follows after the capture lands.
Step 3 of the apparatus plan. Adds Issue98CellarUpReplayTests, a 7-test
harness that loads the three real-geometry cell fixtures captured in
commit 3f56915 and drives the failing-frame sphere through the same
nearest-walkable algorithm the live client uses in
Transition.LogNearestWalkableCandidate.
The tests reproduce the live failure deterministically in under 1ms
each — the issue #98 cellar-up bug is now visible to a unit-test run,
no client launch required.
Tests:
- Fixtures_AllThreeCellsLoadAndShareOrigin — sanity check the cells
loaded with the expected (130.5, 11.5, 94.0) origin.
- Cellar_HasMostPolygons_CottageNeighborBIsSparse — confirms the
surprising finding: 0xA9B40146 is too sparse to be a "cottage main
floor" cell (slice 5 handoff inference was wrong; 0xA9B40143 with 14
polys is the better candidate).
- FailingFrame_CellarPrimary_HasCellarRampAsNearestWalkable — the
ramp polygon IS reachable when the player is on top of it
(sanity: this should always be true).
- FailingFrame_CottageNeighborA_NearestWalkableIsOutsideSphereAndEdges
— at the failing-frame sphere position, the nearest walkable in
0xA9B40143 (poly 0x0004, the cottage floor triangle at world Z=94)
reports BOTH insideEdges=false AND overlapsSphere=false. The sphere
XY is beyond the triangle edge, and the sphere is too far below the
plane. THIS IS THE BUG'S SHAPE.
- FailingFrame_CottageNeighborB_HasNoWalkableCandidate — 0xA9B40146
has NO walkable polygon close enough to the failing-frame sphere.
- FailingFrame_NoCottageNeighbourYieldsAcceptedWalkable — composite:
across both cottage cells, no walkable passes both edge + sphere
tests → step-up has nothing to step onto → player stuck.
- FailingFrame_CottageNeighborA_Poly0x0004_HasExpectedShape — pins the
exact polygon shape so a future fixture re-capture failure is loud.
What this gives us:
1. The bug is now ALWAYS reproducible in test, no live client iteration.
2. Any fix to BSPQuery.FindCrossedEdge / polygon containment / the
cell transform will instantly show whether it changes the failing-
frame outcome.
3. Step 4 (retail cdb capture) will tell us what retail finds at the
same sphere position; Step 5 (comparison doc) will name the
divergence; the eventual fix is then evidence-driven, not a guess.
The tests document the CURRENT (failing) behavior. They WILL pass
after the fix — at which point they need to flip to assert the
retail-correct behavior. This intentional brittleness is the point:
the test is the bug's gravestone, and a fix that doesn't match retail
should not satisfy the test.
Verification:
- dotnet build: green, 0 errors.
- dotnet test: 1167 passed + 8 pre-existing failed (was 1160+8 before
this commit; +7 from the replay tests). Same pre-existing failures,
no new regressions.
- Each Issue98 test runs in under 1ms; loads JSON, calls one internal
predicate per polygon, asserts.
Next: tools/cdb/issue98-cellar-up-find-walkable.cdb (Step 4).
Step 2 capture step. Launched the live client with
ACDREAM_DUMP_CELLS=0xA9B40143,0xA9B40146,0xA9B40147 and walked into a
Holtburg cottage cellar. The probe fired on first-cache of each cell
and emitted JSON dumps to tests/AcDream.Core.Tests/Fixtures/issue98/.
Cell contents (resolved polygons + portals):
- 0xA9B40143: 14 polys + 4 portals (~18.7 KB)
- 0xA9B40146: 4 polys + 2 portals (~7.0 KB)
- 0xA9B40147: 37 polys + 2 portals (~45.7 KB) — cellar, biggest
All three share worldOrigin=(130.5, 11.5, 94.0) with 180° yaw rotation
(M11=M22=-1), matching the failing-frame's local-to-world projection.
Reproduction during capture: spawn at (141.6, 8.4, 91.5) @ 0xA9B40147
— almost exactly the slice 7 handoff's failing-frame position. User
tried to walk up the cellar stair and got stuck (issue #98 reproduction
confirmed).
Surprise: 0xA9B40146 with only 4 polys + 2 portals is too sparse to be
the "cottage main floor cell" that the slice 5 handoff inferred — that
designation was a guess, not verified. 0xA9B40143 (14 polys) is the
better candidate. Step 3 (replay harness) will confirm by inspecting
the actual polygon geometry against the failing-frame sphere position.
Cells are real geometry from client_cell_1.dat, not synthetic fixtures.
The replay harness can now drive the leaf-level walkable predicates on
this exact data without launching a window.
Next: Issue98CellarUpReplayTests (Step 3).
Step 2 of the apparatus plan at
C:\Users\erikn\.claude\plans\i-did-some-work-sharded-acorn.md. Adds a
one-shot cell-dump probe so the issue #98 replay harness can load real
cellar / cottage geometry as JSON fixtures, eliminating live-client
iteration from every fix attempt.
Probe gate:
ACDREAM_DUMP_CELLS=0xA9B40143,0xA9B40146,0xA9B40147
ACDREAM_DUMP_CELLS_DIR=tests/AcDream.Core.Tests/Fixtures/issue98 (default)
When set, the first time PhysicsDataCache.CacheCellStruct sees a matching
envCellId, it serializes the resulting CellPhysics to
<dir>/0x<cellid>.json and prints one [cell-dump] line. Zero cost when
unset (gate is a static-readonly IReadOnlySet<uint>.Count check).
DTOs (CellDump.cs):
- CellDump: top-level record holding cell id, WorldTransform,
InverseWorldTransform, resolved polygons, portal polygons, portal
infos, visible cell ids.
- PolygonDump / PortalDump / Vector3Dto / PlaneDto / Matrix4x4Dto:
System.Text.Json-friendly records with explicit From / To converters.
What is intentionally NOT dumped: the DAT-native PhysicsBSPTree and
CellBSPTree trees. The replay harness drives the leaf-level walkable
predicates (WalkableHitsSphere, FindCrossedEdge, PolygonHitsSpherePrecise)
directly on the resolved polygon list, which is enough to expose the
issue #98 rejection (poly 0x0004 in 0xA9B40143 reports
insideEdges=False / overlapsSphere=False at the failing-frame sphere).
If a future replay needs BSP traversal we can extend the DTO + Hydrate
together without breaking fixtures.
Tests (CellDumpRoundTripTests):
- Capture → Hydrate preserves WorldTransform / InverseWorldTransform /
every polygon's plane + vertices + NumPoints + SidesType.
- Capture → Hydrate preserves portal list + visible cell ids.
- Write to disk → Read back → Hydrate preserves content.
- Hydrate leaves BSP / CellBSP null by design (replay uses leaf-level
predicates).
Verification:
- dotnet build: green, 0 errors.
- dotnet test: 1160 passed + 8 pre-existing failed (was 1156 + 8 before
this commit; +4 from CellDumpRoundTripTests). Same 8 pre-existing
failures, no new regressions.
Next: capture the three cells from the live client (Step 2 acceptance),
then build the replay harness against the fixtures (Step 3).
Triage step from the plan at C:\Users\erikn\.claude\plans\
i-did-some-work-sharded-acorn.md. Four sessions on issue #98 left the
worktree dirty with ~1352 LOC of mixed work. This commit splits the
work into "keep" (defensible + diagnostic) and "drop" (failed
experiments), then commits the keep set with the drops removed.
Plan asked for three commits (diag / fix / revert); consolidated to one
because the diagnostic emits in TransitionTypes.cs are tightly
interleaved with the multi-sphere CellTransit calls and the CellId
switch. Hunk-level splitting in those files for marginal bisect
granularity didn't justify the misclick risk.
Reverted entirely (failed experiments per slice 7 handoff):
- src/AcDream.Core/Physics/PhysicsDataCache.cs — neg-poly storage
fields (Stippling, PosSurface, NegSurface, HasNegativeSide,
IsNegativeSide, NegativeSide).
- src/AcDream.Core/Physics/ShadowObjectRegistry.cs — isBuilding flag
propagation through Register / ShadowEntry.
- tests/AcDream.Core.Tests/Physics/BSPQueryTests.cs — 165 lines of
PolygonWithNegativeSide_* tests.
- tests/AcDream.Core.Tests/Physics/ShadowObjectRegistryTests.cs —
isBuilding propagation tests.
- src/AcDream.Core/World/WorldEntity.cs — IsLandblockBuilding field
(no consumer once ShadowObjectRegistry.isBuilding is gone).
- src/AcDream.Core/World/LandblockLoader.cs — IsLandblockBuilding=true
setter on building entities (kept BuildBuildingTerrainCells).
- src/AcDream.App/Rendering/GameWindow.cs — isBuilding: arg passed to
ShadowObjects.Register.
- src/AcDream.Core/Physics/BSPQuery.cs — TryAdjustWalkableSide /
IsWalkableAt helpers, their callers, the Path 5 / Path 6 neg-poly
branch split, the BldgCheck-tied clearCell conditional, and the
neg-poly ResolveCellPolygons writes.
- src/AcDream.Core/Physics/PhysicsDiagnostics.cs — neg-poly fields
in the poly-dump format.
- src/AcDream.Core/Physics/TransitionTypes.cs — SpherePath.BldgCheck +
SpherePath.HitsInteriorCell fields and every consumer, the
savedBldgCheck try/finally around FindCollisions, and the neg-poly
format additions to the dump-on-error helper.
- src/AcDream.Core/Physics/CellTransit.cs — FindCellSet overloads
with hitsInteriorCell out-param and the BuildCellSetAndPickContaining
out-param threading.
Kept (defensible correctness fixes + diagnostic infrastructure):
- src/AcDream.App/Rendering/GameWindow.cs — render-vs-physics cell
origin split: the 0.02m render lift no longer leaks into physics
BSP caching. lb.BuildingTerrainCells threaded into LandblockMesh.Build.
- src/AcDream.Core/World/LoadedLandblock.cs — BuildingTerrainCells
record field.
- src/AcDream.Core/World/LandblockLoader.cs — BuildBuildingTerrainCells
(cy*8+cx from LandBlockInfo.Buildings).
- src/AcDream.Core/Terrain/LandblockMesh.cs — hiddenTerrainCells
param that collapses owned-cell triangles to a zero-area degenerate.
- src/AcDream.App/Streaming/{GpuWorldState,LandblockStreamer}.cs —
mechanical BuildingTerrainCells threading through LoadedLandblock
reconstructions.
- src/AcDream.Core/Physics/CellTransit.cs — multi-sphere
FindTransitCellsSphere variant + multi-sphere AddAllOutsideCells +
FindCellSet(IReadOnlyList<Sphere>, …) overload + the
BSPQuery.SphereIntersectsCellBsp call for loaded neighbours. Matches
retail CObjCell::find_cell_list / CEnvCell::find_transit_cells.
- src/AcDream.Core/Physics/TransitionTypes.cs — multi-sphere FindCellSet
call site, retail-faithful CellId switch after CheckOtherCells, the
outdoor-landcell terrain-walkable fallback in CheckOtherCells, and
the full diagnostic suite ([step-walk], [walkable-nearest],
[issue98-walkable-detail], [cell-set-summary], LastBspHitPoly
emits).
- src/AcDream.Core/Physics/PhysicsDiagnostics.cs — ProbeStepWalkEnabled
gate (ACDREAM_PROBE_STEP_WALK=1) + LogStepWalk helper + FormatVector
/ FormatPlane utilities. All emit-gated.
- src/AcDream.Core/Physics/BSPQuery.cs — diagnostic emits to
LastBspHitPoly at four sites in SphereIntersectsPolyInternal /
the placement adjustment path.
- Test files for the kept work: CellTransitFindCellSetTests,
CellTransitFindTransitCellsSphereTests, PhysicsDiagnosticsTests,
TransitionCheckOtherCellsTests, LandblockMeshTests,
LandblockLoaderTests.
Verification:
- dotnet build: green, 0 errors, 3 pre-existing warnings.
- dotnet test: 1156 passed + 8 failed (baseline was 1148 + 8 pre-
existing; the +8 passing are the new tests for the kept defensible
work). Same 8 pre-existing failures, no new regressions.
Backup of pre-triage worktree state in stash@{0}.
A6.P3 #98 is still open; this is the apparatus-prep step, not a fix.
Next: cell-dump probe (Step 2 of the plan).
Tonight's slice 6 session attempted 6 variations of placement-insert
bypass in Transition.FindEnvCollisions + Transition.DoStepUp. None
unstuck the player at the cellar ramp top despite mechanically firing
the bypass up to 72 times per session. Reverted all variants; nothing
shipped tonight beyond this handoff.
The hard finding: the placement-insert path is a SYMPTOM, not the
cause. Bypassing it (in 6 ways) doesn't make the sphere climb the
cellar ramp. The first-order question — why doesn't the sphere
progress UP the ramp via normal slope-walking? — wasn't addressed.
User's most actionable clue (not yet investigated): "outside ground
covers only the open path down into the cellar" → suggests a missing
hole in the outdoor terrain mesh over the cellar entry. That's a
terrain-generation bug, completely separate from BSPQuery.FindCollisions.
Handoff doc captures:
- The 3-session diagnosis evolution (each previous session's
confident diagnosis was wrong)
- All 6 slice-6 bypass variants tried and why each failed
- What we KNOW (data-confirmed) vs what we DON'T KNOW (open
questions)
- Specific next-step investigation order with terrain-mesh as #1
- Pickup prompt with strong "don't re-attempt placement-insert
bypass" guard
Test baseline 1148 + 8 unchanged. Slice 5 probe (cf3deff) remains
committed as the durable diagnostic infrastructure.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Add ACDREAM_PROBE_PLACEMENT_FAIL gate + LogPlacementFail emitter +
side-channel polygon attribution in PhysicsDiagnostics. Wire into
BSPQuery.FindCollisions Path 1 (Placement/Ethereal) on Collided
returns; wire into Transition.DoStepDown after the placement_insert
TransitionalInsert(1) call; wire into Transition.FindObjCollisions
to emit per-static-object [place-fail-obj] lines.
Run scen4 cellar-up with the probe → 168 [place-fail] events. 80 of
81 BSPQuery Path 1 placement rejections cite polygon 0x0020 in
cellar cell 0xA9B40147's BSP: n=(0,0,-1) d=-0.2, world Z=93.82 —
the cellar ceiling (underside of cottage main floor thickness layer).
0 [place-fail-obj] lines, confirming the failure source is the cell
BSP not a static object.
The probe-driven evidence INVALIDATES the 2026-05-22 morning
handoff's "Path 5 vs Path 6 in BSPQuery.FindCollisions" diagnosis.
Retail's BP4 trace shows every find_collisions hit has collide=0 —
retail enters the same Contact branch we do, no outer-dispatcher
divergence. Retail's BP5 fires 17+ times on the cellar ramp polygon,
not "30 hits all on flat planes" as morning claimed.
The actual divergence is downstream in cell-promotion: retail's
check_cell transitions to cottage cell 0xA9B40146 during the ascent
(BP7 sets ContactPlane to the cottage main floor poly, which lives
in cottage cell's BSP not cellar's). Ours stays at cellar 0xA9B40147,
where the ceiling poly 0x0020 correctly rejects the lifted sphere.
No fix attempted this session per CLAUDE.md discipline check
(3+ failed fixes = handoff). Full slice 5 evidence + concrete
next-session pickup steps at docs/research/2026-05-22-a6-p3-slice5-handoff.md.
ISSUES.md #98 updated with the corrected diagnosis.
Test baseline: 1148 + 8 pre-existing fail. Maintained.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Updates issue #98 with the sharp diagnosis from the retail cellar cdb
trace (commit 134c9b8):
The bug isn't cell-resolver, isn't walk_interp, isn't dat-fidelity.
It's BSP path-selection: our dispatcher picks Path 5 (Contact step_up)
for the cellar ramp polygon when retail picks Path 6 (find_walkable
land). The ramp is walkable (N.Z=0.695 > FloorZ=0.6642) so Path 6 is
the correct choice. Investigation continues in next session at
BSPQuery.FindCollisions path-selection logic.
Also documents failed fix attempts this session as informational so
next session doesn't re-attempt the same dead ends.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
User walked retail UP the same Holtburg cottage cellar that acdream
gets stuck on. cdb captured retail's BSP behavior for paired
comparison against the acdream polydump trace (0b44996).
Retail (successful walk):
BP1 transitional_insert: 2,651
BP2 step_up: 29 (incl. 1 hit on the ramp slope, n.z=0.6950)
BP4 find_collisions: 4,032
BP5 adjust_sphere: 30 (ALL on FLAT planes; ZERO on the ramp)
BP6 check_walkable: 25
BP7 set_contact_plane: 18 (ALL set the SAME flat plane:
(0,0,1) d=-93.9998 = world Z=94 =
cottage main floor)
Acdream (stuck — from scen4_cottage_cellar_polydump):
cp-write: 229,300
push-back: ~1000 (270 on the RAMP slope poly 0x0008)
step_up_slide: 159
THE DIVERGENCE — pinpointed:
Retail's BSP path-selection for the cellar ramp picks Path 6 (find_walkable
land) — the ramp is treated as a walkable floor to LAND ON. Result:
BP7 sets the contact plane to the cottage main floor (Z=94). No push-back
needed on the ramp.
Our BSP picks Path 5 (Contact → step_up → adjust_sphere push-back) for the
SAME ramp polygon. Result: 270 push-backs against the ramp slope; step_up
keeps failing → step_up_slide loop → player stuck.
NEXT STEP (new session): trace why our BSP picks Path 5 instead of Path 6
for the ramp. Likely in BSPQuery.FindCollisions dispatcher's
path-selection logic. The ramp is walkable (N.Z=0.695 > FloorZ=0.6642) so
Path 6 should fire. Maybe a wrong ObjectInfo state flag, or a sub-step
order issue, or the ramp polygon's BSP-side classification is wrong.
This capture + the polydump capture give a complete picture for the next
investigation session. No more guess-fixes today — the data is now sharp.
Test suite: 1148 + 8 (unchanged this commit).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Hypothesis-driven fix for issue #98 (cellar ascent stuck at top step).
Symptom (from polydump trace at scen4_cottage_cellar_polydump):
- Player walks up cellar ramp (real 46-degree slope per dat verification)
- Hits ramp polygon 0x0008 in cellar cell 0xA9B40147 270 times
- Each hit: sphere center lifted 0.75m onto ramp surface, all walk_interp
consumed (winterp 1.0 -> 0.0)
- Step_up_slide fires 159+ times trying to recover
- Player physically stuck — never advances forward
Bug hypothesis: in DoStepDown, after the primary TransitionalInsert(5)
probe consumes WalkInterp down to 0 (the 0.75m lift), the placement_insert
call runs with WalkInterp=0. AdjustSphereToPlane's interp check
(`interp >= path.WalkInterp` where interp=0) then rejects any push-back
needed for the placement validation -> placement fails -> step_up returns
failure -> step_up_slide loop -> player stuck.
Fix: reset WalkInterp = 1.0 before the placement_insert call (mirrors
retail step_down's walk_interp = 1 reset at function entry, which is what
the placement_insert runs after in retail's flow).
Test suite: 1148 + 8 (baseline maintained).
Visual verification: pending user re-test of cellar-up walk.
If this fixes cellar-up, also likely improves other step-up-onto-slope
scenarios. If it doesn't fix cellar-up, the bug is elsewhere in the
step-up/step-down flow (separate investigation needed).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Slice 3 v2 (point-in stickiness) closed the cell-resolver ping-pong
(data confirmed: scen4_cottage_cellar_slice3v2 capture shows 1 cell-
transit vs 20+ pre-fix). BUT user verification revealed: cellar-up
symptom transitioned from "stuck-at-top-ping-pong" (pre-slice-3) to
"never-reach-top-stuck-in-cellar" (post-slice-3). Stickiness was
holding player in cellar cell so aggressively that the legitimate
transition to the cottage main floor cell at the ramp top never
fired.
Reverting the stickiness check entirely. Trade-off:
- Inn doorway ping-pong returns (existed pre-slice-3; lesser evil)
- Player can again reach the top of the cellar ramp (per pre-slice-3
user observation)
- Issue #98 cellar-up remains open — but with sharper diagnosis: it's
not the cell resolver at all, it's deeper (BSP step-physics or
AdjustOffset slope-projection at the cottage main floor boundary,
per slice 4 polydump trace showing repeated push-back on the
46-degree ramp polygon)
The slice 3 stickiness premise was correct but the implementation
shape was wrong. A future attempt needs either:
- A "near boundary" gate (only stick when sphere is deep inside cell)
- A retail-faithful per-cell hysteresis matching CObjCell::find_cell_list
Position-variant (acclient_2013_pseudo_c.txt:308742-308783) more
exactly than point-in
- OR address the underlying BSP step-physics bug first; then ping-pong
may not even need a stickiness fix
Test suite: 1148 + 8 (baseline maintained).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Extends the existing [cell-cache] probe (gated by ACDREAM_PROBE_CELL_CACHE=1)
to also dump the list of portal targets per cell: which other cells
each portal connects to, the portal polygon id, and the flags.
Output format (appended to existing [cell-cache] line):
portalTargets=[(cell=0xNNNN,poly=0xNNNN,flags=0xNNNN),...]
Purpose: investigating issue #98 (cellar-up stuck at top of ramp).
We now know the polygon geometry is correct (per slice 4 polydump
capture: the cellar is a real 46° ramp). Question is whether the
cellar cell has a portal to the cottage main floor cell, and where
that portal is. If portalTargets shows no connection to the expected
upstairs cell, that's the bug.
Test suite: unaffected (probe is gated off by default).
Build: green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds a polygon-geometry dump probe that fires alongside [push-back]
whenever AdjustSphereToPlane lands a push-back. Gated by
ACDREAM_PROBE_POLY_DUMP=1.
Output format:
[poly-dump] cell=0xA9B40147 polyId=0x0042 numPts=4 sides=Single
n=(0.000,-0.719,0.695) d=-0.1007
verts=[(x1,y1,z1),(x2,y2,z2),(x3,y3,z3),(x4,y4,z4)]
Purpose: investigate #98 (cellar-up stuck at top step). The push-back
trace shows the player hitting a sloped surface n=(0,-0.719,0.695) at
the cellar stair top. Two possibilities:
1. The polygon really IS sloped 44° in the dat (genuine geometry).
2. Our dat-read produces wrong vertices → wrong normal → wrong plane.
The dump lets us:
- Identify which dat polygon was hit (cell + poly ID)
- Compare our extracted vertices against WorldBuilder's straight-from-
dat read for the same poly
- Or spawn the cell in ACViewer to visually verify the geometry
Changes:
- Added `ushort Id` property to ResolvedPolygon (defaults to 0 for test
fixtures that don't care; production code in PhysicsDataCache.cs +
BSPQuery.cs sets it from the dictionary key).
- Added ProbePolyDumpEnabled + LogPolyDump in PhysicsDiagnostics.
- Wired the dump into AdjustSphereToPlane's apply-branch (after the
existing push-back log; same gating pattern).
Test suite: 1148 pass + 8 pre-existing fail (baseline maintained).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Slice 3 v2 (3e140cf) added point-in cell-stickiness in
ResolveCellId's indoor branch. User verification + slice3v2 capture
confirms: cell-resolver ping-pong is FULLY CLOSED.
Data:
- scen2_v2 capture (pre-slice-3): 20+ cell-transit events with
rampant ping-pong (0xA9B4014B ↔ 0xA9B4014A ↔ 0xA9B4013F at the
cellar boundary, Z stable ~96.4 — same tick re-classification)
- slice3v2 capture (post-fix): 1 cell-transit event (login teleport
only) — ping-pong fully eliminated
Findings:
- A6.P2 Finding 3 (cell-resolver sling-out family) CLOSED.
- Issue #90 (sphere-overlap stickiness workaround in same function)
now redundant; can be removed in A6.P4 after broader visual
verification.
- Issue #97 (phantom collisions + fall-through on 2nd floor) hypothesis
pending: same instability family, likely closed as side-effect of
this fix. Re-test on next happy-test session.
- Issue #98 (cellar-up stuck) PERSISTS but with NEW DIAGNOSIS.
Originally filed as cell-resolver ping-pong (which was true and now
fixed), but user verification shows the cellar-up symptom remains
with a DIFFERENT root cause: BSP step-physics at the cellar stair
TOP. Push-back trace from slice3v2 capture:
n=(0, -0.719, 0.695) sloped face (walkable per FloorZ=0.664)
delta=(0, 0, 0.75) step-down probe lifts sphere by 0.75m
winterp=1.0->0.0 entire walk-interp consumed per tick
Player progresses up most of the stairs but blocks at top step
where the cellar transitions to the cottage main floor. #98 issue
updated with this re-diagnosis.
Includes:
- scen4_cottage_cellar_slice3 acdream.log (slice 3 v1 evidence;
ping-pong already closed by v1's sphere-overlap stickiness, but
v1 over-corrected by holding player in cellar during legitimate
transitions)
- scen4_cottage_cellar_slice3v2 acdream.log (slice 3 v2 evidence;
point-in stickiness fixes the over-correction; cellar-up reveals
the deeper BSP step-physics bug)
Docs updated:
- ISSUES.md — #98 re-diagnosed
- docs/plans/2026-04-11-roadmap.md — A6.P3 slice 3 marked SHIPPED;
slice 4 (or A6.P4) scoped for #98 step-physics investigation
- CLAUDE.md — Currently-working-toward block updated
Test suite: 1148 pass + 8 pre-existing fail (baseline maintained).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Slice 3 v1 (8898166) used SphereIntersectsCellBsp for the stickiness
check. User verification showed: ping-pong WAS closed (3 cell-transit
events vs 20+ pre-fix) but user still couldn't walk up out of cellar
because the stickiness was OVER-CORRECTED — the sphere still partially
overlapped the cellar cell at the top of stairs, so stickiness held the
player in the cellar even when the center had transitioned to the
cottage main floor cell.
Fix: switch the stickiness check from SphereIntersectsCellBsp (sphere
overlap) to PointInsideCellBsp (center-in). Matches FindCellList's
own semantics for "which cell are you in." Player stays in fallback
only while center is still inside fallback's BSP volume.
Trade-off:
- More permissive transitions (good — cellar-up works)
- Less aggressive stickiness, so some boundary ping-ponging may return
IF the sphere center oscillates across the boundary (rare; would
require sub-mm Z drift across the boundary line)
If the trade-off bites (ping-pong returns somewhere), the fix is a
small geometric margin around the point-in check — but verify before
adding.
Test suite: 1148 pass + 8 pre-existing fail (baseline maintained).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Closes A6.P2 Finding 3 (cell-resolver instability) + issue #98 (cellar
ascent stuck at last step) + likely closes#97 (phantom collisions +
fall-through on 2nd floor; same instability family).
Adds a cell-stickiness check at the top of ResolveCellId's indoor
branch: before re-resolving via FindCellList, check if the fallback
(previous-tick) CellId's BSP still validly contains the sphere. If
yes, return fallbackCellId immediately — preserves cell membership
when the sphere is at a boundary where multiple cells overlap.
The bug: at cell boundaries (cellar last step, indoor doorways,
between two adjacent indoor cells), the sphere overlaps multiple
cells geometrically. FindCellList's candidate-iteration order
(HashSet, implementation-defined) determines which cell wins. That
order may shift tick-to-tick → CellId ping-pong → AdjustOffset
operates against a different cell's geometry each tick → player
can't accumulate forward motion → stuck.
Evidence: scen3_inn_2nd_floor_slice2v2 capture shows the ping-pong
chain at the cellar boundary:
0xA9B4014B → 0xA9B4014A → 0xA9B4013F → 0xA9B4014A → 0xA9B4014B
(Z stable ~96.4; CellId oscillates every tick; reason=resolver)
Retail oracle: cell-array hysteresis pattern from
CObjCell::find_cell_list Position-variant at
acclient_2013_pseudo_c.txt:308742-308783. Retail preserves cell
membership when sphere is close to (but slightly past) cell
boundaries.
Implementation: 9 lines added (sphere-overlap check against
fallbackCellId's CellBSP before falling through to FindCellList).
Existing #90 workaround at line 299-300 (post-FindCellList sphere-
overlap check) is now redundant in the common case but kept for
safety; deferred to A6.P4 removal after visual verification.
Test suite: 1148 pass + 8 pre-existing fail (baseline maintained).
Visual verification: pending — user happy-test will confirm cellar-
up walk succeeds + no ping-pong in cell-transit log.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Slice 2 v1 (`892019b`) attempted to close issue #96 by removing the
PhysicsEngine.cs L622 per-tick CP seed. v1 build/test green, CP-write
count dropped 91% in scen3 re-capture, BUT user happy-test surfaced
a regression: BSP step_up at the last step of stairs failed because
sub-step 1's AdjustOffset had no ContactPlane to compute the lift
direction.
Slice 2 v2 (`f8d669b`) reverted the seed removal + added a no-op-if-
unchanged guard inside CollisionInfo.SetContactPlane. The guard
early-returns when called with values matching current ci state.
Outcome:
- #96 PARTIALLY ADDRESSED, scope updated in ISSUES.md to "accepted as
documented retail divergence." The seed is load-bearing for step_up;
closing #96 fully would require deeper refactor (AdjustOffset
fallback to body.ContactPlane). Guard is benign improvement.
- Slice 2 v2 verification capture (scen3_inn_2nd_floor_slice2v2/
acdream.log) committed as evidence — 226,464 cp-writes from L624
seed confirms guard doesn't trigger for fresh-ci-per-tick pattern.
- Slice 2 v1 verification capture (scen3_inn_2nd_floor_slice2/
acdream.log) also committed — confirms v1 actually reduced cp-writes
(2,690 total) but the step_up regression made it unshippable.
NEW M1.5 BLOCKER FILED — issue #98: cellar ascent stuck at last step.
Evidence in slice2v2 capture's cell-transit chain:
0xA9B4014B → 0xA9B4014A → 0xA9B4013F → 0xA9B4014A → 0xA9B4014B → ...
(Z stable ~96.4; CellId ping-pongs every tick)
This is Finding 3 family (cell-resolver hysteresis missing) — same
root cause as #90 workaround + scen4 sling-out. Retail oracle:
CObjCell::find_cell_list Position-variant at
acclient_2013_pseudo_c.txt:308742-308783.
NEXT — A6.P3 slice 3:
- Port retail's cell-array hysteresis into ResolveCellId +
CheckBuildingTransit.
- Closes#98 (cellar-up), possibly #97 (phantom collisions same
instability family), enables #90 workaround removal.
Documents updated:
- ISSUES.md — #96 scope updated, #98 filed
- docs/plans/2026-04-11-roadmap.md — A6.P3 slice 2 marked SHIPPED,
slice 3 scope added
- CLAUDE.md — Currently-working-toward block updated to slice 3
Test suite: 1148 pass + 8 pre-existing fail (baseline maintained).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
First slice 2 attempt at commit 892019b removed PhysicsEngine.cs L622
per-tick CP seed entirely. User happy-test surfaced a regression: BSP
step_up at the last step of stairs failed because sub-step 1's
AdjustOffset had no ContactPlane to compute the lift direction (the
seed was load-bearing for step_up correctness).
Revert + better fix:
1. Re-add the L622 seed (PhysicsEngine.cs:620-626).
2. Add no-op-if-unchanged guard inside CollisionInfo.SetContactPlane
(TransitionTypes.cs:259-279). When called with values identical
to current state, early-return without incrementing
ContactPlaneWriteCount or rewriting fields.
When the player stands on the same plane tick after tick, the L622
seed re-calls SetContactPlane with identical args — these now no-op
instead of inflating the counter and re-writing the same values.
Only actual state changes (e.g. landing on a new step's plane, cell
crossing) increment the counter.
Verification (post-rebuild, pre-this-commit slice 2 first attempt):
- scen3 walk produced 2,690 cp-writes (down from 30,420 = 91%
reduction from L622-seed presence)
- BUT user could not pass the last step of stairs — step_up regression
- Test suite: 1148 + 8 pre-existing fail baseline maintained but
physical behavior broke
Post-this-commit expectations:
- Test suite: 1148 + 8 (unchanged, no behavioral change in fixtures
because the seed value is what the fixtures already expect)
- Stair-walking: works (seed restored)
- CP-write count: significantly reduced (most seeds are no-ops because
body.CP doesn't change tick-over-tick on stable footing)
- Issues #96 / #97: re-test in re-capture; #96 should be largely
closed via the guard; #97 (fall-through + stuck-in-falling) was
observed pre-slice-2 too, so unrelated to the seed
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Closes issue #96 (per-tick PhysicsEngine.ResolveWithTransition CP seed
contributing 99.3% of post-slice-1 CP writes). Matches retail's
CTransition::init at acclient_2013_pseudo_c.txt:271954 which explicitly
clears contact_plane_valid = 0 at transition start.
Cross-tick CP retention now flows entirely via retail-faithful
mechanisms:
- Mechanism A: BSPQuery.FindCollisions Path-6 land write
- Mechanism B: Transition.ValidateTransition LKCP restore (slice 1)
- Body persist at transition end (already existed)
Cost (deliberate): AdjustOffset on sub-step 1 of each tick takes the
'no contact plane' path. Slope-snap loss is imperceptible (sub-steps
are small, sub-steps 2+ pick up CP normally).
Likely closes issue #97 (phantom collisions + fall-through) as
side-effect — hypothesis was stale-CP slope-snap from body.ContactPlane
of a previous cell. To be verified post-commit via re-capture + user
happy-test.
Verification this commit:
- Test suite: 1148 pass + 8 pre-existing fail (baseline maintained)
- scen3 re-capture pending (separate commit)
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Unexpected slice 1 win: the synthesis-strip + Mechanism B (LKCP
restore) fix didn't just close Finding 2 (CP-write blowup) — it also
unblocked stair-walking, which A6.P2 had categorized as Finding 1+3
territory expected to need separate fixes. User reports walking up
and down the inn stairs multiple times in acdream post-fix.
Shape shift in tag distribution:
Tag Pre-fix (FAIL) Post-fix (SUCCESS) Signal
---- ------------- ------------------ ------
indoor-walkable 859 0 synthesis gone
push-back-cell 1478 879 (-40%) multi-cell relaxed
push-back 51 345 (+577%) real step-up firing
push-back-disp 4156 6055 (+46%) real traversal
cp-write 33969 57846 L622 seed (slice 2)
Pre-fix: synthesis firing while physics hammers BSP trying to resolve
stair-step (failure mode). Post-fix: real BSP queries succeeding, real
step-up + step-down landing. Same shape as retail's stair-climb
(retail scen2: BP2 step_up=188, push-back-disp dominates).
A6.P2 Finding 1 (dispatcher entry frequency mismatch) hypothesis was
"likely secondary effect of Finding 2 — may close as side effect of
the fix." Confirmed empirically: dispatcher activity now matches
retail-like shape without explicit Finding 1 work.
Remaining (slice 2 territory):
- L622 per-tick PhysicsEngine.ResolveWithTransition seed fires 99.3%
of remaining cp-writes; retail's equivalent fires zero times on
flat-floor walks. Gate this seed to close the remaining CP-write
gap.
- Phantom collisions + occasional fall-through on 2nd floor reported
by user during happy-testing. New issue to file.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Code-review suggestion (non-blocking) on commit 39fc037: the
BuildCellWithFloor XmlDoc referenced the TryFindIndoorWalkablePlane
→ FindWalkableSphere → FindWalkableInternal call chain that this
slice just removed from FindEnvCollisions. The test still needs the
BSP bounding sphere centered correctly, but for the primary indoor
BSP query (BSPQuery.FindCollisions), not for the deleted synthesis
path. Updated the doc to reflect the actual code path.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Code-review feedback on commit 5f7722a: the test was gamed —
placing the sphere exactly on the floor (worldPosZ = floorZ) made it
pass regardless of whether synthesis was present. With sphere center at
Z=0.48 (= floorZ + SphereRadius), PolygonHitsSpherePrecise's distance
guard fires immediately (|dist|=0.48 > rad=0.478) and
TryFindIndoorWalkablePlane returns false even WITH synthesis code. The
test would have passed even if the strip were reverted.
Redesign: restore worldPosZ = floorZ - 0.05f (sphere center at Z=0.43).
Now |dist|=0.43 < rad=0.478 → the guard passes → TryFindIndoorWalkablePlane
finds the floor polygon → synthesis would fire → CP writes every frame.
Path 5 (Contact branch) is not a concern: the loop moves only in X so
movement = (0.001, 0, 0), Dot(movement, floor_normal=(0,0,1)) = 0 ≥ 0 →
PosHitsSphere front-face cull rejects the floor hit even with sphere
center below the floor. Path 5 returns OK with zero CP writes. Contact
flag is left set to keep the test on the realistic grounded-mover path.
Validated locally by temporarily re-introducing the synthesis call —
test fails with 60 writes (1 per frame) pre-strip, passes with 0
additional writes post-strip. Now a real regression sentinel.
1148 pass + 8 pre-existing fail baseline maintained.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Closes A6.P2 Finding 2 (ContactPlane resynthesis blowup, 250x to ∞x
more CP writes than retail). Indoor branch of Transition.FindEnvCollisions
now matches retail's CEnvCell::find_env_collisions tiny shape (decomp
line 309573): call BSPTREE::find_collisions, return OK. No synthesis,
no per-frame ValidateWalkable call, no per-frame ContactPlane write.
Cross-frame CP retention now flows via:
- Mechanism A: BSPQuery.FindCollisions Path-3 step-down write on
grounded movers (retail-faithful: BSPTREE::step_sphere_down at
acclient_2013_pseudo_c.txt:323711 always writes contact_plane when
it finds a walkable surface — only fires if sphere penetrates floor).
- Mechanism B: per-transition LKCP restore in ValidateTransition
(added in 5aba071) for the Collided/Adjusted/Slid result cases.
- PhysicsEngine.RunTransitionResolve body persist (unchanged).
TryFindIndoorWalkablePlane definition retained for now; deleted in
A6.P4 alongside the #90 sphere-overlap workaround.
Test fix: IndoorContactPlaneRetentionTests sphere position corrected
from 5 cm below the floor (pre-fix arrangement to trigger synthesis)
to exactly on the floor (worldPosZ = floorZ). A grounded sphere at
its natural position does not penetrate the floor polygon, so BSP
Path 5 finds no intersection and returns OK immediately — zero
additional CP writes in 60 frames. Previously the below-floor position
was causing Path 5 → StepSphereUp → DoStepDown → SetContactPlane
every frame (60 writes), not the synthesis path.
Verification:
- IndoorContactPlaneRetentionTests: PASS (was the 9th expected fail;
back to 1148 pass + 8 pre-existing fail).
- Full suite: 1148+420 pass, 8 fail (baseline maintained +1 pass).
- Re-capture verification (scen1/3/5) deferred to Task 6.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Restores CollisionInfo.ContactPlane from LastKnownContactPlane when:
- LKCP is valid
- the sphere's current center is geometrically close to the LKCP
plane (|dot(global_curr_center, N) + d| <= radius + EPSILON)
Matches retail's validate_transition LKCP-restore at
acclient_2013_pseudo_c.txt:272577 (CTransition::validate_transition,
address 0050aa70, lines 272565-272582). Slice 1 step 1 of the
A6.P3 indoor CP retention fix. Step 2 (Task 5) strips the
TryFindIndoorWalkablePlane synthesis from FindEnvCollisions.
Also fixes the proximity-check sphere: was using
sp.GlobalSphere[0].Origin (start sphere); now uses
sp.GlobalCurrCenter[0].Origin (current center) per retail
(acclient_2013_pseudo_c.txt:272568).
Tests: 1147 pass, 9 fail (8 pre-existing + 1 IndoorContactPlaneRetention
from T3 — expected; T5 lands the actual synthesis-strip fix).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Code-review feedback on commit 36975ef:
- Remove redundant SetCheckPos call in BuildGroundedTransition
(InitPath already set CheckPos to begin; the second call was a
no-op that misled readers into thinking it was load-bearing).
- Correct the class-level fixture-pattern attribution: pattern is
a blend of FindEnvCollisionsMultiCellTests (engine+DataCache
setup) and IndoorWalkablePlaneTests (sphere radius 0.48f +
BuildCellWithFloor pattern). Comment was misleading by naming
only the first.
Test still fails today with 'got 60. Finding 2 fix not complete.'
No functional change.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Test asserts 60 frames of indoor flat-floor walking should produce
≤5 ContactPlane writes. Fails today (broken code: ~60 writes).
Will pass after Task 4 + Task 5 strip the per-frame synthesis path.
Fixture: synthetic CellPhysics with flat floor (±10m XY, floorZ=0),
CellBSP=null so ResolveCellId keeps the indoor classification, BSP
bounding sphere centered at the global sphere center (worldPosZ +
sphereRadius = 0.43) so NodeIntersects passes in FindWalkableInternal.
worldPosZ = -0.05 places sphere bottom 0.05m below floor so
ValidateWalkable's below-surface branch fires (dist = -0.05 < -ε).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Internal test-only counter incremented by SetContactPlane. Required
by IndoorContactPlaneRetentionTests to assert CP retention works
post-Finding-2 fix (A6.P2).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Code-review feedback on commit 6b4be7f:
- Section 1: strip stale [309NNN] inline annotations (off by 2-8
lines from actual file content; the 0052c1xx address comments
are the reliable anchor); address comments already present in the
decomp output are now used as inline anchors instead
- Section 2: validate_transition function header is at file line
272547 (was: 272538, inside the preceding check_collisions
function). Address 0050aa70 + LKCP-block range 272565-272583
were already correct. References section updated to match.
- Section 5: add note that SetContactPlane re-latches LKCP fields
(no-op when LKCP is the source, but non-obvious side effect)
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Pre-fix research note grounding the indoor CP-retention refactor in
retail's exact LKCP-restore pattern (acclient_2013_pseudo_c.txt:272565-272582)
and CEnvCell::find_env_collisions tiny shape (line 309573).
Key findings:
- find_env_collisions writes NO ContactPlane — only BSP Path 6 does (Mech A)
- validate_transition Collided/Slid/Adjusted branch calls set_contact_plane
from LKCP when proximity guard passes (global_curr_center, not global_sphere)
- Our ValidateTransition is missing the SetContactPlane call in that branch
(sets Contact/OnWalkable flags only) — this is the gap Task 4 closes
- Proximity sphere should be GlobalCurrCenter[0] not GlobalSphere[0]
- Exact insertion point: TransitionTypes.cs ~line 2849, inside the
'radius + EPSILON > |angle|' proximity-guard branch
Output of this note drives the per-transition Mechanism B insertion
point selection in Task 4 + the slice-1 acceptance shape.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
A6.P1 (cdb probe spike) + A6.P2 (analysis report) both SHIPPED this
session. Updated:
docs/plans/2026-04-11-roadmap.md — M1.5 phase block now shows A6.P1
+ A6.P2 SHIPPED with commit refs; A6.P3 entry expanded with the
Finding-2-first sequencing recommendation from A6.P2; A6.P4 entry
notes the original "Holtburg Sewer end-to-end" acceptance walk is
unreachable (sewer doesn't exist).
docs/plans/2026-05-12-milestones.md — M1.5 demo scenario split into
building/cellar half (achievable post-A6.P3) + dungeon half (blocked
on issue #95 visibility blowup; promote to post-M1.5 if #95 isn't
fixed in scope). Issue list updated: added #95 + indoor sling-out
(new from scen4); marked stairs/2nd-floor/cellar as characterized by
A6.P2 Finding 2 family.
CLAUDE.md — Currently-working-toward block now points at A6.P3 as
the active phase. A6.P1 + A6.P2 ship noted with the findings doc
pointer. Demo-scenario note updated to reflect the sewer + #95
reality. Issues-in-scope updated.
Also includes a 1-line trailing-prompt addition to scen3 + scen4
retail.log files (cdb wrote one more `0:000>` after the kill that
landed after the original capture commits).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Replaces the A6.P1 stub with the analysis pass over 5 paired captures
(scen1-5). Scen6-9 (sewer-specific) cancelled because the Holtburg Sewer
doesn't exist on this ACE server and any substitute dungeon hits issue
#95 (portal-graph visibility blowup) on entry.
Four findings ready for A6.P3 sequencing:
Finding 1 — Dispatcher entry frequency mismatch (4x to 281x fewer in
acdream). Likely secondary effect; may close as side-effect
of Finding 2 fix.
Finding 2 — ContactPlane resynthesis blowup. 250x to INFINITE more CP
writes in acdream. Strongest single signal; scen3 shows
retail wrote CP zero times during a flat 2nd-floor walk
while acdream wrote 86,748 field updates. Primary M1.5
root cause. HIGH severity.
Finding 3 — Indoor cell-resolver sling-out (scen4). Resolver flings
+Acdream across landblock boundary; CheckBuildingTransit
fires 5,495 times during the sling while indoor BSP is
barely queried. Same family as the M1.5 cell-tracking
ping-pong hypothesis. HIGH severity.
Finding 4 — Portal-graph visibility blowup (scen5 incidental). Filed
as issue #95; not strictly A6 scope but documented here so
A6.P3 sequencing knows about it.
Tables 1+2 (per-site push-back delta + path-frequency diff) deferred to
A6.P1.5: the v4 cdb probe captures function entry only, not exit values.
Adding paired exit BPs is ~1 hour of cdb scripting work but not needed
unless A6.P3 fixes fail to close the symptoms.
Table 3 (CP lifecycle) fully populated — geometric mean CP-write ratio
across 4 finite scenarios is ~1,470x; median ~2,200x.
Table 4 (sub-step state mutations) partially populated with proxy
metrics (per-tag firing rates).
M1.5 symptom coverage matrix: every in-scope physics symptom maps to
at least one finding. Acceptance per spec §4.7 met.
A6.P3 sequencing recommendation: Finding 2 first (highest-confidence
single-cause; may close Finding 1 as side effect), re-run captures, then
Finding 3. Issue #95 handled separately outside A6.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Filed during A6.P1 scen5 capture (Town Network as substitute for the
nonexistent Holtburg Sewer). After portal teleport, visibleCells per
cell explodes from ~4 to 135-145, with cells from multiple disconnected
landblocks loaded simultaneously — direct cause of the user-observed
"see through walls / other dungeons rendering" failure across all
portal-accessed dungeons.
This is what "dungeons are broken" means as a coherent failure mode.
Scen6-9 (sewer corridor/chamber/stair) as originally scripted couldn't
have produced clean physics-only captures because the dungeon would
have been visually unusable from the moment of portal entry. The A6.P1
scenario script was written before the visibility bug was characterized.
Evidence is in scen5's acdream.log (already committed at 35d5c58).
Scen6-9 are not captured — the visibility bug blocks the scenarios.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Substituted "Holtburg Sewer" portal with Town Network Portal — no
sewer entry exists in this world (user-verified). Town Network is
also an outdoor->indoor portal transition with the same physics
signature.
Both clients walked to the portal, entered, walked 2 m inside.
Retail: clean traversal. Acdream: also clean (no failure mode).
Retail (decoded, 23,890 raw / 9,769 BP lines):
BP1 transitional_insert: 13,863
BP4 find_collisions: 9,552
BP5 adjust_sphere: 97
BP6 check_walkable: 55
BP7 set_contact_plane: 65 (moderate, portal threshold + indoor)
BP2 step_up: 1
Acdream (31,914 lines, no failure):
[cp-write]: 20,956 (vs retail BP7 = 65 — ~322x ratio)
[cell-cache]: 9,642 (Holtburg landblock streaming)
[check-bldg]: 740
[push-back-disp]: 34 (flat-ground walking)
[push-back]: 1
[cell-transit]: 12 (CLEAN traversal, no thrashing)
cell-transit event chain — captures the portal entry signature:
0x00000000 -> 0xA9B30030 (login teleport)
0xA9B30030 -> 0xA9B40029 -> 0xA9B40021 -> 0xA9B40019 ->
0xA9B40011 -> 0xA9B40012 -> 0xA9B4000A -> 0xA9B4000B ->
0xA9B40003 (walked across Holtburg, all reason=resolver)
0xA9B40003 -> 0x00070143 reason=teleport (PORTAL ENTRY)
scen5 is the "control" — both clients reached their target, no
visible failure. The CP-write blowup persists as the only A6.P2
divergence. Useful baseline for separating "indoor physics broken
during walking" (scen2, scen3, scen4) from "indoor physics okay
when portal-delivered" (scen5).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Asymmetric pair (scenario-level, not protocol-failure):
- Retail: user walked UP out of the cellar (ascent of 2 cellar
steps + exit through doorway) — captures ascent + indoor-to-
outdoor transition.
- Acdream: user teleported INTO the cellar, walked a few meters,
the resolver flung +Acdream OUTSIDE the cottage entirely
(landblock prefix changed A9B4 -> A9B3 mid-walk) — captures
a real indoor physics failure that's not a stair issue per se.
Both traces are valuable to A6.P2 even though they don't match
walk-for-walk.
Retail (decoded, 22,536 raw / 12,875 decoded BP lines):
BP1 transitional_insert: 9,402
BP4 find_collisions: 12,596 (ended in mem-access error
@ hit#12596 - cdb hit a null
transition arg, dropped to
interactive prompt; worth a
note for A6.P2 retail edge)
BP5 adjust_sphere: 136
BP6 check_walkable: 128
BP2 step_up: 13 (2-step cellar = 13 vs scen2
4-step inn = 188; non-linear)
BP7 set_contact_plane: 3 (Finding 2 holds)
Acdream (42,001 lines, ended with sling-out):
[cp-write]: 35,624
[check-bldg]: 5,495 (CheckBuildingTransit fired
constantly trying to re-resolve
which building +Acdream was in)
[cell-cache]: 540
[push-back-disp]: 82 (very few dispatcher hits)
[push-back]: 1 (almost no sphere-adjustment)
[indoor-bsp]: 2 (indoor BSP barely queried!)
[cell-transit]: 3 (3 transit events captured the sling:
0xA9B40148 -> 0xA9B40029 -> 0xA9B30030
all reason=resolver)
Sling-out signature: indoor BSP never engaged (only 2 indoor-bsp
hits), but the cell resolver fired 3 transit events crossing a
landblock boundary, with check-bldg thrashing in between. This is
distinct from scen2's stair-attempt pattern (which hammered the
BSP); scen4 shows the resolver pushing the character out of indoor
space entirely without triggering the indoor BSP collision path.
A6.P2 fix surface: investigate why ResolveCellId / CheckBuildingTransit
push a player from indoor cell 0xA9B40148 to outdoor cell 0xA9B30030
through routine walking. Likely the same family as the M1.5 hypothesis:
indoor cell membership isn't sticky (the ping-pong bug from the
2026-05-20 A4 handoff in a different guise).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
