The extended gate round (GF-1..16, R2/R3/R4 re-tests, fix batches A-G +
closeout + two re-test rounds) closed with the user's pass on build
1.0.2-cc.o. Plan status and ledger flipped; findings doc carries the
full round history.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Four visual residuals from the lead's own live-client captures of
1.0.2-cc.m, all root-caused via decomp + live-DAT evidence:
- R4-1: Skills credits value overlapped mid-caption again. Root cause
was a missing UiLayoutPolicy raw-edge reflow on UiButton's value-child
rect (the child is base-inherited across four sibling buttons of
differing widths, so its baked-in OriginalParentWidth diverges from
the actual 231px-wide Skills credits button) plus an HJustify.Right
value child mapped to Center instead of a real far-edge Right.
- R4-2: the single-sprite scrollbar thumb tiled (GL_REPEAT) instead of
drawing once — DrawTiled was reused for a small fixed marker graphic
whose native size is far smaller than the track-proportional thumb
rect. New DrawThumbMarker draws exactly one native-size instance.
- R4-3: the skills info-box formula line clipped past the surrounding
gold frame's own authored bottom edge (the pane's own raw box is 20px
taller than the frame that visually contains it) — clamp the pane's
Height to the frame's bottom (register AD-105, since retail's
ShowSkillsText has no code relationship to the frame to cite).
- R4-4: the Appearance help text started mid-sentence — the box was
never touched by its page controller, so it kept UiText's chat-style
PreserveEndOnLayout=true default; the scroll model's wasAtEnd check is
vacuously true on its first-ever overflow transition, pinning the
first render to the bottom. Set PreserveEndOnLayout=false (a static
top-oriented report, not a transcript) and wired the box's own nested
authored scrollbar, never wired before.
App suite live-DAT env 5372/3 -> 5379/3 (+7, zero regressions). Runtime
1735/0 unchanged. Full solution 14585/4 skips/1 failure (the documented
Core.Net NakEmission full-solution-only flake, confirmed standalone-pass).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
R3-8: dumped EVERY property present on 0x10000402 (not just P0x17) across
every state, cross-referenced against UIElement_Text::OnSetAttribute's
complete case list (no UIElement_TextInput class exists in retail — the
name field is a plain UIElement_Text/m_filter-bearing field). The full
recognized-property space has no placeholder/prompt mechanism independent
of P0x17. The BaseElement/prototype-inheritance hypothesis is also ruled
out — the existing regression test already probes the fully-merged
ElementInfo (post BaseElement resolution) and finds nothing. The only
StringInfo-kind property present, 0x49, resolves to "Your name can be 32
characters long and cannot contain numbers or symbols." — but 0x49 is
part of the same five-property tooltip family ISSUES #409/GF-16 already
document client-wide (0x48's own DID, 0x21000041, is the EXACT tooltip
popup LayoutDesc #409 cites) — a hover tooltip, not an in-field
placeholder. No code change, per this batch's own "do not invent a
placeholder" contract — third independent negative result on this
question via three different mechanisms. The lead should request a live
retail screenshot before any further investigation.
Also carries the shared live-DAT regression suite for R3-1 through R3-7
(CharacterCreationLiveDatTests.cs holds tests spanning multiple findings
in one file, so they land together) and the RE-TEST 2 findings-doc
closeout writeup for all eight items.
App suite live-DAT env 5358/3 -> 5372/3 (+14, zero regressions). Runtime
1735/0 unchanged (untouched this round). Full solution: 14578 tests / 4
skips / 0 failures.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Doc-only findings from the round review, plus the register rows the
three code commits' own bookkeeping notes reference:
- F3: AP-229 amended with the dialog-as-sibling z-order addendum — the
same flat-sibling-list mechanism that motivates AP-229's own screen-
layering row also covers RetailDialogFactory's open dialogs, which was
GF-15's actual root cause (now fixed, but the underlying divergence —
dialogs and screens sharing one z-order list at all — remains and
could reintroduce the same failure class via a future sibling's own
unconditional per-tick BringToFront).
- F5/F6: AP-230 amended with the second narrow-honor addendum (the
LayoutImporter carve-out fix landed in the Group 3 code commit); the
findings doc's "CHAT INPUT" label corrected to "chat transcript" in
both places it appeared (0x2100006F/0x10000011 is the transcript
display, not the input textbox).
- F12: the AD section header recounted 77 -> 79 (a direct physical count
found it undercounted by 2); the AP section header's own "one high"
drift-direction note corrected to "one low" — verified against the
actual commit history (Batch A ended with 165 physical rows but a 164
header; Batch B's recount correctly landed on 164, the header was
never overcounting).
- F15: ISSUES.md #406 gains the crash-vs-incomplete-shutdown precedence
sentence — ReportExited's _runFailure check runs first and returns
immediately, so a crash always wins over a subsequently-failed
shutdown for the same session's reported reason.
- AP-231 filed (the Group 2 commit's own ComposeFormula connector-text
approximation — referenced in that commit's message but the register
row itself was missed until this pass; 161 active AP rows).
- Campaign CC plan ledger gains a "Gate round 1" row with the full
commit list for batches A-G plus this session's three closeout
commits, superseding the ledger's stale "sole remaining acceptance
step" framing (written before the connected gate ran and found the
GF-1..GF-16 / R2-1..R2-8 findings this whole round fixed).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
R2-4/review F1-F2 (gmCGSkillsPage): row click (and arrow click, matching
retail's own post-Increase/DecreaseSkillLevel re-select) now selects a
skill, highlights its row name, and writes the info panes' title (name +
score) and a level-gated bonus line; the description/formula halves stay
unported (SkillBase._description/_formula unreachable from this page's
current data surface, documented on RefreshInfoBox). The listbox's own
authored scrollbar link is wired to its Scroll model (live-DAT-confirmed
at 0x100003F8, matching the "+1 from the listbox" hypothesis). Cost text
now matches SetSkillText @0x00480600 exactly: Untrained's down-cost and
Specialized's up-cost are literal "0", unconditional, where the port
previously rendered blank; the 999-blank gate applies to the up-cost
only, never to a down-cost. Arrow Ghosted/Enabled state (0x1000001a/
0x1000001b) is now gated per branch, including bUntrainable/
bUnspecializable re-derived as "this row's own effective cost is
nonzero" — no new data needed since the page already resolves that cost.
R2-4b (the four-bucket sorted model) is NOT implemented — its Useable-
vs-Unuseable-Untrained split reads SkillBase.MinLevel, confirmed present
in the installed dat (SkillTable_MinLevelDistribution_NeverExceedsTrained)
but not threaded through ChargenOptions/ChargenHeritageOptions/
CharacterCreationRuntimeBindings. AP-213 row records the exact channel a
future fix needs. Also live-DAT-pinned: Templates[0]'s header-caption
child (0x100002f6) resolves as a UiButton, not UiText, in the real dat —
the same UIElement_Button-is-DynamicCast(0xc)-compatible-with-Text quirk
already ported for GF-4b's slider labels.
App suite (live-DAT env) 5321/3 -> 5328/3 (+7, zero regressions).
Runtime 1735/0 unchanged.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
R2-5: retail's gmCGAppearancePage::DoColorSpots/SetSelection/DoGradDisk
paint the nine color swatches and the gradient disc with a real,
computed representative color (PalSet-averaged for Hair/Nose+Mouth+
Skin/Headgear/Shirt/Trousers/Footwear at fixed sample indices
0xd0/0xb0/0x520; direct-Palette for Eyes at 0x103), not the static
authored art acdream showed before this batch.
Ports the full palette-to-RGB pipeline: a new pure Core resolver
(ChargenSwatchColorResolver + IChargenPaletteColorSource) backed by a
new ChargenAppearanceCatalog.TryGetColor reading real Palette dat
objects, pinned against the installed EoR dat. CharacterCreationAppearancePage
recomputes all nine swatches + the gradient disc's tint on every
refresh (part/color/heritage change) and paints them through a new
ChargenSwatchColorTile overlay child — a flat-color-fill approximation
of retail's actual recolored-sprite blit, since neither UiButton
(sealed) nor UiDatElement exposes a per-instance sprite tint today.
Two STOPPED items remain outside this batch's file contract before the
mechanism is visually live: (1) wiring PalSetSource/ClothingTableSource/
PaletteColorSource from CharacterCreationUiController.cs (mirrors the
existing PreviewControl seam); (2) a small additive Tint property on
UiButton/UiDatElement for a byte-true recolor instead of the flat fill.
Also ports Nose/Mouth/Skin's single non-interactive representative
swatch, beyond AP-216/AP-217's original six-part scope.
Register AP-216/AP-217 rewritten (not retired — the two STOPPED items
keep them open). Tests: 11 new Core, 6 new Content live-DAT, 8 new
App-layer fixture. App suite 5321/3 -> 5329/3, Runtime 1735/0
unchanged, zero regressions.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
R2-1/R2-6 (description-box text clipped left of the frame, regressed from
Batch C's frame un-consume): root cause was never the un-consume change
itself — the Heritage/Profession/Town/Summary description boxes
(0x100003C4/0x100003E0/0x10000409/0x10000404) all author retail's four
independent text-inset margins (dat properties 0x23-0x26,
UIElement_Text::OnSetAttribute cases 0xf-0x12: margL=9/margR=26/margU=15/
margD=15), which this codebase never read at all, before or after Batch C.
Un-consuming the gold-frame children just made the pre-existing missing-
margin bug visible for the first time (the frame's own left border now
draws around the same x=0 origin text always used). Fixed end to end:
ElementInfo.MarginLeft/Right/Top/Bottom (read in
ApplyCanonicalLegacyProjection, propagated in Merge), UiText.MarginLeft/
Right/Top/Bottom (additive with the pre-existing Padding), a new pure
UiText.ContentOffsetX static consumed by the multi-line draw path's
per-line placement, and matching wrap-width shrinkage in
DatRichText.Compose and BuildText's own authored-multiline path. Scoped to
the multi-line (non-OneLine) path only.
R2-2/R2-3 (Attribute\n Credits renders the literal backslash-n; the live
credit value overlaps mid-caption): two stacked gaps. (1) UiButton
captions never escape-normalized the DAT's literal "\n" — centralized the
normalize into DatWidgetFactory's ResolveAuthoredString (the one choke
point every P0x17 resolution already shares) plus a NormalizeEscapes
helper for the per-state caption loop, so every caller normalizes
identically. (2) UiButton.Label only ever drew one line — retail's
UIElement_Button IS a UIElement_Text with OneLine=false on these buttons,
so a caption should word-wrap/stack like any other Type-12 box. Added
UiButton.DrawBlockLabel + the pure, unit-tested WrapBlockLines. The
value-overlap itself: ValueBox was never wrong (live-DAT-measured correct
child rects) — the caption was drawing unconfined across the button's
full width ("Available Skill Credits" measures 193px in a 231px button
whose value box starts at x=116). Fixed by confining the caption's own
drawable width to stop before ValueBox.X whenever a ValueLabel coexists.
R2-7a (Summary overview listbox missing its scrollbar): pure wiring gap —
the listbox authors a linked scrollbar via dat property 0x72
(ScrollbarElementId=0x10000401) that CharacterCreationSummaryPage's
constructor never resolved, unlike every other UiTemplateListBox owner in
the codebase. Fixed with the same resolve-and-wire pattern.
R2-7b (how-to box scrollbar overlaps text, no thumb): traced to a
downstream symptom of R2-1, not an independent bug — UiScrollbar only
paints its thumb when the linked model has overflow, and the pre-fix wrap
width (un-inset) produced fewer/shorter lines than fit the view. Pinned
directly against the real installed strings/font (Aluvian's how-to text)
that the margin-correct width overflows. No UiScrollbar code changed.
R2-8 (name field should show "[ Name ]"): re-checked the one hypothesis
Batch A's GF-15 closure left open — an authored initial-text string on
the field's own P0x17. Confirmed absent on every state in the installed
DAT. No code change; Batch A's closure stands, now pinned as a live-DAT
regression test.
App suite 5334/3 (was 5321/3, +13, zero regressions). Runtime 1735/0
unchanged. Full solution Release build green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Retail's chargen 3D views (Appearance and Summary) are not black behind
the model: gmCG3DView::Update @0x004EE9D0 constructs a SECOND CPhysicsObj
from the current heritage's HeritageGroup_CG.environmentSetupID field
(acclient.h verbatim struct layout; the decompiler elides the actual field
read, but HeritageGroup_CG::GetSubDataIDs @0x005c05d0 explicitly walks
iconImage/setupID/environmentSetupID by name, confirming the identity) and
adds it to the SAME viewport's creature_mode_objects the player object
lives in, inserted BEFORE the player (whose own re-AddObject happens much
later, at ~0x004ef199, after the full clothing ObjDesc composes). The
backdrop gets no explicit position/orientation/scale — CPhysicsObj::
makeObject(eax_32, 0, 1) leaves it at the scene origin with identity
orientation, same as the player object's own placement. This id was
already parsed as ChargenHeritageOptions.EnvironmentSetupId
(ChargenTableReader.cs) but never consumed anywhere in production (GF-7/
GF-14).
Fixed by:
- ChargenPreviewEntityBuilder.TryBuildBackdrop: builds a plain, unposed
Setup mesh from the heritage's EnvironmentSetupId, returning null for
id 0/unset or an unresolvable Setup (retail's own INVALID_DID gate).
- PrivateEntityViewportRenderer: an optional second entity slot
(SetBackdrop), reserved via a backdropRenderId constructor parameter so
paperdoll and creature-appraisal — which never pass one — cannot
acquire a second entity even by accident (SetBackdrop throws without a
reserved slot). Per-entity mesh-reference/texture-owner lifetime is
factored into a private EntitySlot helper shared by both the main and
backdrop slots. Draw-entity assembly is a pure, directly-testable
helper (BuildDrawEntities) that puts the backdrop first, matching
retail's own AddObject insertion order.
- ChargenPreviewController.Rebuild: rebuilds the backdrop whenever the
HERITAGE changes (narrower than the existing camera-eye-reset gate,
since environmentSetupID is a pure function of heritage, never gender
or appearance selection).
Both Appearance and Summary get the fix from the same ChargenPreviewRenderer
facade — confirmed both pages call the identical gmCG3DView::Update on
their own gmCG3DView instance, so no page-specific code was needed.
Lighting was independently re-verified against the same function's
SetLight call (DISTANT_LIGHT, intensity 2.0, direction (0.3, 1.9, 0.65),
default white color) and found to already match byte-for-byte what CC6a
shipped.
Also files docs/ISSUES.md #409 for GF-16 (client-wide UI tooltip system),
investigated in the same root-cause pass but explicitly out of this
batch's scope, and marks it DEFERRED in the findings doc.
Tests: 11 new/extended (ChargenPreviewEntityBuilderTests.TryBuildBackdrop_*,
ChargenPreviewControllerTests backdrop rebuild/swap/absent/no-op cases,
PrivateEntityViewportRendererDrawOrderTests pinning the paperdoll/creature-
appraisal single-entity invariant). Live-DAT measurement: all 13 retail
heritages' EnvironmentSetupId resolve to a real, drawable installed Setup.
App suite 5307/3 -> 5321/3 (+14, 0 regressions). Runtime 1735/0 unchanged.
Launcher.Core.Tests 337/0 and Launcher.Tests 67/0 unchanged (first build of
the merged tree carrying the #406 launcher merge). Full solution: 14508
total / 14504 passed / 4 skipped / 0 failed, dotnet test exit code 0.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Commit 3/3: Summary how-to text + Commit 2's owed scrollbar linkage +
bookkeeping sweep.
- Ports gmCGSummaryPage::SetHowToText @0x0047ae20 into the Summary
page's how-to box (0x10000404, HowToTextId was declared and unused
since CC5). Retail concatenates ID_CharGen_SummaryHowTo + a heritage/
gender-specific name-suggestion list (heritages 1-4 — Aluvian/
Gharundim/Sho/Viamontian — only; heritages 5-13's cases in the same
switch decompile to a vtable-slot artifact, the same decompiler-
mangled-symbol class the Heritage page's own BonusSkillsKeyByHeritage
table already documents, so no name-suggestion string exists for them
and none is invented) + ID_CharGen_SummaryHowToEnd, directly
concatenated (no separator literal) into ONE plain SetText call — no
per-run font/color argument, unlike Heritage's ...WithFont calls, so
this routes through DatRichText as a single DefaultColor segment.
- Wires the description boxes' linked scrollbar to actual text
scrolling — Commit 2 made the scrollbar child (0x100002e7) BUILD as a
real UiScrollbar; this binds scrollbar.Model = text.Scroll, the exact
pattern ChatWindowController already uses for the chat transcript.
Live-DAT-measured: only Heritage's description (0x100003c4) and
Summary's how-to box (0x10000404) actually author this child —
Profession/Town's shorter description boxes do not (a genuine retail
authoring fact, not something to "fix" further).
Register: AP-215/AP-216/AP-217 rewritten (Batch C's Commit 1 already
retired AP-218/AD-103) — no further changes needed this commit; ISSUES
#366 (chat's new-unseen-text indicator, 0x1000048C under the chat
transcript 0x10000011) NARROWED — its own pre-filed "fix shape"
recommendation (a UiText child carve-out mirroring UiMeter's) is
EXACTLY what Commit 2 shipped, confirmed by that commit's own
client-wide sweep; #366 stays open for the still-missing behavioral
half (no controller drives the indicator's visibility/click).
Findings doc updated: GF-2/GF-3/GF-4/GF-6/GF-11a/GF-12/GF-14's text
half all marked FIXED with their own root-cause notes; the two
remaining "suspected shared roots" (frames/labels, rich text) marked
CONFIRMED + CLOSED.
Full App suite (Debug and Release, live-DAT): 5307 passed / 0 failed /
3 skipped (up from 5304 after Commit 2). Runtime suite: 1735/0,
unaffected.
Campaign CC gate round 1 Batch C is CODE-COMPLETE across all three
commits — GF-2, GF-3, GF-4, GF-6, GF-11a, GF-12, and GF-14's text half
are fixed; AP-216/AP-217 partially closed (register-honest about what
shipped vs what needs a palette-to-RGB pipeline this batch didn't add).
Pending the user's visual gate, with chat + the main game UI flagged
for extra attention (Commit 2's client-wide blast radius).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
GF-1/GF-8: UiButton now recognizes retail's custom Unselected/Selected
radio-pair (0x10000016/0x10000017), bypassing the standard Normal/
Highlight machine that never admitted those state names — .Selected now
lights the heritage/template/gender/Face-Clothes rows it was always a
no-op for.
AP-222/GF-11b: per-state label color/outline (dat 0x1B/0x21) now applies
off the REQUESTED retail state id, not the art-gated committed
ActiveState — resolves the Appearance spins' current-part highlight
(text recolors even though no Highlight art exists on either client) and
the Town caption's Normal-to-white swap.
GF-11c: UiButton.LabelBox lets a lifted caption with its own authored
rect draw there instead of the face-relative offset that's only correct
when the label is authored directly on the button (heritage/template
family, unchanged).
GF-9: wires the real nine companion overlay elements (SetColor's
SetVisible mechanism) that swatch clicks were always meant to drive,
retiring AP-215 item 1 (the swatch.Selected substitution was a permanent
no-op — swatches author no Highlight media at all).
GF-10: zoom buttons now set the retail-mirrored mutual-exclusive
Highlight/Normal pair on click; InitializePage carries no initial
SetState for either button, so both stay at "Normal" until first click.
Register: AP-222 retired (mechanism identified and ported), AP-215
narrowed (item 1 retired, item 2 unrelated and unchanged), row count
recount corrected 164 (was already one high before this batch).
App suite 5282/3 (was 5266/3), Runtime 1735/0 unchanged. Fixture + live-
DAT tests only — no graphical client launch.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
GF-15 (the gate blocker): the Summary name field and Finish button were
NOT structurally broken — live repro over the project's own local ACE
test server showed clicks correctly focus the field and land characters.
The real bug only surfaces after the first dialog opens: pressing Finish
empty successfully creates the NoName RetailMessageDialogView (visible,
correct 400x95 geometry) but it renders nothing and silently absorbs
every click across the whole canvas. Root cause: CharacterCreationUiController.Tick
and CharacterManagementUiController.Tick both call UiRoot.BringToFront(Root)
unconditionally every frame (needed so chargen stays above the occluded
management screen, AP-229); a dialog root is a direct sibling under the
same UiRoot, and RetailWindowManager.BringToFront is "highest ZOrder among
siblings + 1" — whichever BringToFront runs last in a frame wins.
RetailDialogFactory.Tick never re-asserted its own dialogs' z-order, so
the next frame's screen Tick buried the dialog behind the screen's opaque
backdrop while it stayed the registered Modal with exclusive input
priority. Fixed by having RetailDialogFactory.Tick re-raise every open
dialog (in open-order) each tick, matching retail's always-on-top dialog
behavior. Live-verified the complete user sequence end to end: click
field, type, press Finish empty, dialog now visibly renders, OK dismisses
cleanly, field still typable afterward. The "[ Name" prefill question is
closed as a non-bug: neither CharGenState::RandomizeCharacter nor
gmCGSummaryPage::InitializePage write text into the field in the decomp;
retail's field is genuinely empty on open, matching acdream already.
GF-5: CharacterCreationSkillsPage.RebuildRows resolved the wrong listbox
template (Templates[0], retail's own 3-child bucket-header row) and
required the root to be a UiButton (it's a plain container). Byte-traced
gmCGSkillsPage::DoSkillRecords + tagSkillRecord's copy-ctor field order
to map every child id in the real row (Templates[1]): name, level/cost
text, and the two real per-row up/down arrow buttons. Wired the arrows to
retail's own plain-click dispatch, retiring (narrowing) AP-213's
click-to-advance/double-click-retreat single-button substitution.
GF-13: dat property 0x3B (Invisible) was never read by the importer.
Elements 0x10000403/0x10000494 ("Non-Admin"/"Non-Envoy") author it true.
A blast-radius sweep found 1,083 elements client-wide author the same
flag, so this fix stays chargen-scoped only (ElementInfo.Invisible /
UiElement.AuthoredInvisible are pure data additions; only
CharacterCreationUiController acts on them, by the authored flag, not a
hardcoded id list). General importer-wide honor filed as ISSUES.md #408;
register row AP-230 records the split.
Gates: solution build green; App 5266/3 skips/0 failed; Runtime 1735/0;
full-solution run 0 failures anywhere. Register: AP-230 filed, AP-213
narrowed. ISSUES: #408 filed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
