Blast-radius review of FA2 (1c401048, 369729f0, cced83b4, 12053e61)
along the axes the implementer did not traverse.
MF-1: GameRuntime.cs:716-725 -- CompletedTeardownStages case 9 claims
FellowshipDisposed one stage early (10 flags where the pre-FA2 case had
exactly 9, ending at CommunicationDisposed). Only observable on the
teardown failure path, which is precisely when the ledger must be
honest. No test pins intermediate stages, so nothing caught it.
MF-2: seeding RuntimeAllegianceState from 0x027C AllegianceInfoResponse
is a retail divergence with no register row. Retail's
CM_Allegiance::DispatchUI_AllegianceInfoResponseEvent @0x006a7470
unpacks into a STACK-LOCAL CAllegianceProfile and destroys it on return;
Handle_Allegiance__AllegianceInfoResponseEvent @0x0056a1d0 uses it only
as a read source for AddTextToScroll. 0x027C is text-only in retail; the
panel is fed exclusively by 0x0020. Concrete risk: 0x027C carries no
rank, so an @allegiance info before the first 0x0020 leaves the owner at
HasProfile=true with a fabricated Rank=0 for FA3's panel to render.
SHOULD-FIX: the seam doc still carries the false dispatcher claim FA2
disproved (only the plan ledger and a code comment were corrected);
no disposition recorded for the two deliberately-skipped dead events;
three count claims wrong (15 delegate holes -> 10; 12 Send wrappers ->
11; 11 S->C events -> 10); no test covers the router->owner plumb
including the one non-trivial lambda; ResetSession's disposal guard
diverges from the precedent it cites; allegiance reconnect-survival has
no register row; GetVassals allocates against the stated view contract.
Verified clean and enumerated exhaustively: every WireAll site (one
production, shared by both hosts), both bindings sites, every
IGameRuntimeCommands/IGameRuntimeView implementer (no bot-reachable
stub), zero auto-fire on all 11 new Send wrappers incl. 0x00A6/0x001F,
reset- and teardown-stage renumbering at every enumeration point, the
central accepting gate, host-adapter self-guid and owner-borrow
equivalence, the K-slice bot policies + trace recorder (21/21), the
@allegiance info live path (79/79), and the suite accounting -- measured
13,201/4/0 (13,205 total) with the +43 reconciled per test file.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
