# Campaign CC — retail character creation

**Status:** ACTIVE (started 2026-08-15)
**Goal (user-set):** the full retail creation flow against local ACE — Create
button through a new character entering the world, 3D preview live, rejections
showing retail's dialogs — then stop for the user gate.
**Branch:** `claude/acdream-launcher-credentials-4d2f7c`
**Process:** Campaign LA's, binding (Sonnet implements, Opus dual-lens reviews
per slice, retail decomp is the oracle, register rows with deviations,
build+test green per slice, commits tagged `Campaign CC`).

This plan embeds the 2026-08-15 recon facts (three parallel sweeps: retail
gmCG UI, chargen data+wire, acdream seams) so slices and future sessions need
no transcript access. `references/ACE` and `references/holtburger` are NOT in
this worktree (gitignored) — read them from the main checkout at
`C:\Users\erikn\source\repos\acdream\references\`.

## Retail ground truth (recon summary — cite these in code)

**Flow.** Create button (`0x100003A0`) → `QueueUIMode(0x1000000b)` →
`gmCharGenMainUI` (acclient.h:56232): ONE root layout, enum `0x10000039` via
GetDIDByEnum table 5 (our generic `RetailDataIdResolver` handles this), pages
as children. `ECGProgress`: Heritage=1 → Profession=2 → Skills=3 →
Appearance=4 → Town=5 → Summary=6. Nav dispatch
`gmCharGenMainUI::ListenToElementMessage@237025`: Back `0x100003c6` (at
Heritage → DoExit), Next `0x100003c7`, Finish `0x100003c8` (Summary only),
Help `0x100003c9`, Exit `0x100003ca` (→ `ID_CharGen_ExitWarning` confirm),
Random `0x100003cb` (on Summary → randomize warning first). Tab buttons
`0x100003ef..f4` jump pages freely (not validation-gated). Page roots:
Heritage `0x100003d1`, Profession `0x100003d2`, Skills `0x100003d3`,
Appearance `0x100003d4`, Town `0x100003d5`, Summary `0x100003d6`; progress
bar `0x100003ce`, master page `0x100003d0`. Per-page child ids are in the
recon-cited ctors: Heritage `InitializePage@143731` (13 race buttons + text
`0x100003c4`), Profession `@143010` (6 attribute sliders `0x100003e6..eb`,
avail/health/stam/mana `0x100003e2..e5`, template buttons resolved in
`UpdateProfession@142180`: Custom `0x100003d9`, Bowhunter/Swashbuckler/
Lifecaster/Warmage/Wayfarer/Soldier `0x100003da..df`), Skills `@141911`
(listbox `0x100003f7`, credits `0x100002f3`, info `0x100003fb/fc`),
Appearance `@140032` (gender `0x100003a7/a8`, spins hair/eyes/nose/mouth/skin
`0x100003af..b3`, headgear/shirt/trousers/footwear `0x100003b5..b8`, zoom
`0x10000325/26`, rotate `0x10000323/24`, color wheel family
`0x1000030e..0x10000321`, viewport `0x100003bb`), Town `@137120` (Sanamar
`0x1000040b`, Holtburg `0x1000040d`, Yaraq `0x1000040e`, Shoushi
`0x1000040f`), Summary `@136566` (list `0x10000400`, name text `0x10000402`
with NameInputFilter, viewport `0x10000406`).

**CharGenState** (acclient.h:40074): the model our Runtime owner mirrors —
heritage/gender, appearance strips+styles+colors+shades (f64 shades),
template + 6 attributes + credit budgets + per-attribute locks, 55-slot
skill advancement array + skill credits, name[33], startArea, setupID,
verificationState. Writers per page in the recon (SetHeritageGroup recomputes
budgets + ApplyTemplate + RandomizeStartArea; SetGender reapplies clothing
and UpdateTrueFacePal).

**Finish** (`DoFinish(this, arg2)@236864`): trim+set name → empty name →
`ID_CharGen_NoNameWarning`, abort. **CORRECTED at the CC3 review-fix round
(F3) — the original line here (`remainingAtrbCredits > 0` → abort, "retail
FORCES full spend") was WRONG; retail does NOT force a full spend.** The
real gate is `arg2 != 0 && remainingAtrbCredits > 0`: the ordinary
Finish-button click passes `arg2 = 1` (@0x004E9579), and on unspent
credits shows `MakeCreditWarningDialog` and returns WITHOUT sending
(@0x004E91F2-0x004E9210) — but that dialog's own confirm handler
re-invokes `DoFinish(this, 0)` (@0x004E98BB), which SKIPS the credit check
entirely (`arg2 == 0`) and sends with the credits still unspent. ACE
accepts this — `ValidateAttributeCredits` only rejects a total that
EXCEEDS the max, never an under-spend. Then: verification state must be
UNDEF (no double submit) → set PENDING → `Proto_UI::SendCharGenResult@0x00546A70`.

**Wire 0xF656** (`ACCharGenResult::CG_Pack@0x005C7200`, byte-identical to
ACE's `CharacterCreateInfo.Unpack`): account String16L FIRST (outside the
body), then u32 constant 1, u32 heritage, u32 gender, u32×3 eyes/nose/mouth
strips, u32×2 hairColor/eyeColor, u32 hairStyle, u32×2 headgearStyle/Color,
u32×2 shirt, u32×2 trousers, u32×2 footwear, f64×6 skin/hair/headgear/shirt/
trousers/footwear shades, u32 templateNum, u32×6 attributes
(str/end/coord/quick/focus/self), u32 slot, u32 classID, u32 numSkills +
numSkills×u32 advancement classes (MUST be exactly 55 — ACE TERMINATES the
session on mismatch), String16L name, u32 startArea, u32 isAdmin, u32
isEnvoy(=ACE IsSentinel), u32 trailing checksum = sum of
heritage+gender+strips(3)+hairColor+eyeColor+hairStyle+headgearStyle+
shirtStyle+trousersStyle+footwearStyle+template+6 attributes (ACE never
reads it; we send it for byte fidelity). holtburger cross-check:
`character/types.rs:236` (stops before the checksum).

**Response 0xF643** (shared opcode with restore — LA7a's conditional parse is
reusable): codes Undef=0 Ok=1 Pending=2 NameInUse=3 NameBanned=4 Corrupt=5
DatabaseDown=6 AdminPrivilegeDenied=7. On Ok the payload is a
CharacterIdentity (guid, String16L name, u32 secondsGreyedOut) and NOBODY
sends a fresh CharacterList — retail appends the identity to its local
roster (`Handle_CharGenVerificationResponse@0x0055E8B0` case 1 →
`CharacterSet::AddIdentity`) and `gmCharGenMainUI::Update@236161` then
watches the set and calls `CPlayerSystem::LogOnCharacter` DIRECTLY when the
new name appears (logs straight in; only falls back to char management if it
never appears). Error dialogs: NameInUse→`ID_Character_Err_NameReserved`,
NameBanned→`ID_Character_Err_NameBanned`, Corrupt/DatabaseDown→
`ID_Character_Err_NameDBDown`, AdminPrivilegeDenied→
`ID_Character_Err_NameAdminDenied`, Pending/Undef→silent state reset (ACE
sends Pending for a disabled-Olthoi rejection — retail swallows it; port
as-is, register-note the quirk).

**Chargen DAT table** `0x0E000002`: readable TODAY via the
Chorizite.DatReaderWriter package (`dats.Get<CharGen>`) — zero in-tree
readers exist. ACE loaders (`ACE.DatLoader.FileTypes.CharGen` +
`HeritageGroupCG/SexCG/TemplateCG`) and retail serializers
(`ACCharGenData::Serialize@0x005C36D0`, `HeritageGroup_CG@0x005C2100`,
`Sex_CG@0x005C1600`, `Template_CG@0x005C0450`) define the shape: per
heritage → name/icon/setup/EnvironmentSetup/attribute+skill credits/start
areas/skills(costs)/templates(attrs+skills)/genders; per sex → scale, setup,
base palette, skin palset, base ObjDesc, and the option LISTS (hair styles/
colors, eye colors, eye/nose/mouth strips, headgear/shirt/pants/footwear,
clothing colors).

**3D preview** (`gmCG3DView`, Appearance `0x100003bb` + Summary `0x10000406`
ONLY — the other four pages have no viewport): preview body
`CPhysicsObj::makeObject(setupId)` (fallback HUMAN_SETUP_ID), rebuild on
change via ObjDesc (`ClothingTable::BuildObjDesc` per clothing slot + strips
+ PalSet skin/hair/eye subpalettes) applied with
`DoObjDescChangesFromDefault@242308`, one DISTANT_LIGHT (intensity 2.0),
idle animation loop at 30fps (`set_sequence_animation`), rest-pose freeze on
zoom-in, BUTTON-toggled continuous rotation (`DoRotation@137337`, 3.0
s/revolution, per-frame global-message-3 tick), zoom tween between
per-heritage camera positions (`Update@138974` hard-codes Olthoi vs
human-form camera offsets).

## acdream seams (build on these, do not reinvent)

- Layout mount: `RetailDataIdResolver.Resolve(dats, 0x10000039, 5)` +
  `LayoutImporter` — fully generic. `DatWidgetFactory` already maps dat type
  0xD → `UiViewport`. The char-management controller REFUSES viewports by
  local policy (:212) — chargen gets its OWN controller; clone
  `CharacterManagementUiMountCoordinator` + the bindings-record pattern.
- Fixed canvas: chargen is the same 800×600 flow screen — mount at authored
  extent, `UiRoot.FixedCanvasSize` on activate (AD-98), dialogs center on
  `EffectiveCanvasSize`. Live-DAT probe tests sweep ALL media ids
  (`CharacterManagementLiveDatTests` pattern) and pin authored
  justify/anchors.
- Preview pipeline: `PrivateEntityViewportRenderer` (offscreen target →
  texture table → `UiViewport` sprite) is proven by paperdoll + appraisal;
  cameras there are FIXED — chargen needs a heading-capable camera. NOTE:
  `GlGpuDevice.RegisterExternalColorTexture` is a DELETED API that survives
  only in stale doc comments — do not cite it. Appearance building:
  `DollEntityBuilder.Build` is index-agnostic and pure (setup + resolved
  palette/part ids), but the only existing factory reads a LIVE entity —
  chargen needs a new index→dat→ObjDesc factory (SexCG.BaseObjDesc + strip
  overlays + PalSet.GetPaletteID hues). Pose: paperdoll holds a static final
  frame; retail chargen plays a live idle loop — see slice CC6 for the
  staged approach.
- Runtime owner: mirror `RuntimeCharacterSelectionState` exactly (lifecycle/
  snapshot/delta records, borrow-only view, generation-gated commands, one
  mutable owner, no App types). Command family lands beside
  `IGameRuntimeCommands.CharacterSelection`. Enter-after-create hooks the
  existing `LiveSessionController.BeginEnter/CompleteEnter`.
- Wire plumbing: `WorldSession`'s dispatch chain routes EVERY 0xF643 through
  `CharacterRestore.Parse` today with no request correlation — the KNOWN
  LANDMINE. Creation requires an awaiting-request latch (create vs restore)
  BEFORE its response arm lands. Outbound mirrors
  `SendRestoreCharacter@2223`. Status writer: add `characterCreated` /
  `creationFailed` events (update the pinned §LA1 contract text + the
  Launcher.Core tailer + tests in lockstep).

## Slices

| Slice | Deliverable | Depends |
|---|---|---|
| CC1 | Chargen data layer: `CharGen` table reader → typed options model (heritages/sexes/appearance lists/templates/skills+costs/budgets/towns), Content/Core, live-DAT probes | — |
| CC2 | Wire: `CharacterCreate` 0xF656 builder (byte-exact incl. checksum), shared verification-response type (refactor from `CharacterRestore`), WorldSession request-correlation for 0xF643, send seam, status events + contract/tailer update | — |
| CC3 | `RuntimeCharacterCreationState`: full CharGenState mirror, per-page commands, retail client gates (full-spend, name, 55-slot invariant, client-side slot cap), verification latch, Ok → roster append + retail log-straight-in | CC1, CC2 |
| CC4 | Screen shell + form pages (App): mount (enum 0x10000039), master nav/tabs/progress, dialogs, Heritage + Profession + Skills + Town pages | CC1, CC3 |
| CC5 | Summary page: name input (NameInputFilter, `ID_CharGen_NameTooLong`), summary listbox, static summary viewport, Finish gates + full response/dialog handling | CC3, CC4 |
| CC6 | Appearance page + preview: index→ObjDesc factory, chargen preview renderer (offscreen, heading camera, rotate/zoom buttons), spin controls + color wheels; **staged:** CC6a static-pose preview (paperdoll-style held frame, register row for the missing idle loop), CC6b idle animation + zoom rest-freeze (retire the row) | CC1, CC4 |
| CC7 | End-to-end: Create button un-ghosts, full flow vs ACE shapes in tests, launcher payload cycle, connected checklist doc | all |

Parallelism: CC1 ∥ CC2 (disjoint: Content/Core vs Core.Net; separate
worktrees). CC4 ∥ CC6a after CC3. CC5 last before CC7.

## Risks / open items (from recon Unknowns)

1. 0xF643 create/restore correlation (CC2's first job; the restore doc
   comment already warns).
2. 55-slot skill array: ACE terminates the session on mismatch — CC2/CC3
   must make it structurally impossible to send anything else.
3. Slot cap is client-enforced only (ACE never checks on create) — honor
   `slotCount` like retail's UI did.
4. Color-wheel/gradient widgets (`tagColorWheel`, GradCircle `0x1000030e`,
   shade scroll) may need new widget types in `DatWidgetFactory` — CC6
   scouts the authored layout first.
5. Retail unknowns to resolve during slices, never guess: the chargen
   please-wait dialog context (decompiler-mislabeled field), the
   AppearancePage gender-flip-on-init oddity (@140355 — verify live before
   porting), `Method_CG` enums are empty in the header, ZoomIn tween
   duration constant is decompiler-garbled (measure against retail if it
   matters).
6. Viewport inside the fixed canvas: the offscreen target's pixel size vs
   the canvas-scaled on-screen rect (render at scaled size for crispness or
   authored size for fidelity) — decide in CC6a with the user gate as
   arbiter.
7. `references/*` absent in worktrees (except WorldBuilder, uninitialized
   submodule) — agents read ACE/holtburger from the MAIN checkout path.
8. **CC7 landmine (found in the CC1 review fix round, 2026-08-15):** ACE's
   `PlayerFactory.CreatePlayer` heritage-override branch
   (references/ACE/Source/ACE.Server/Factories/PlayerFactory.cs:184-211)
   over-deducts skill credits when specializing a skill the active
   heritage's own list prices. For a skill priced ONLY by the global
   SkillTable, ACE correctly computes the incremental specialize cost via
   `SkillBase.UpgradeCostFromTrainedToSpecialized` (= `SpecializedCost -
   TrainedCost`) and charges `TrainSkill(trainedCost) +
   SpecializeSkill(incrementalCost)` = the field's TOTAL, matching retail.
   But when the heritage's own list has an entry, ACE sets
   `specializedCost = skillGroup.PrimaryCost` directly — `PrimaryCost` is
   already the TOTAL cost to reach Specialized (acdream's own
   `ChargenSkillCost.PrimaryCost` convention, confirmed against retail) —
   and then still charges `TrainSkill(NormalCost) +
   SpecializeSkill(PrimaryCost)`, over-deducting by an extra `NormalCost`
   credits versus what retail's client computed and what the player agreed
   to spend. Practical impact for CC7's connected gate: a retail-legal
   character build that specializes a skill the ACTIVE HERITAGE prices
   (every one of the 13 installed heritages has exactly one such skill —
   see `ChargenTableReaderInstalledDatTests.InstalledHeritages_SkillCostFallbackCoversTheKnownUncostableSkillSet`)
   may be REJECTED by local ACE with `FailedToSpecializeSkill` even though
   acdream sent the byte-correct 0xF656 body. If CC7's gate hits this,
   it is an ACE-side bug reproduced from its own source, NOT an acdream
   wire or math defect — do not "fix" acdream's cost math to match ACE's
   over-deduction. **MEASURED 2026-08-15 (user-prompted — downgrades this
   landmine to LATENT):** dumping the installed EoR DAT shows every one of
   the 13 heritages' single override is skill 14 (Arcane Lore) at
   NormalCost=0 / PrimaryCost=2, versus global TrainedCost=4 /
   SpecializedCost=6. ACE's over-deduction equals NormalCost — which is
   ZERO for the only heritage-priced skill — so ACE charges 0+2=2 and
   retail's client computes 2: they AGREE, and no character build can
   trigger the rejection with end-of-retail data. The formula bug in ACE's
   heritage-override branch is real but unfireable here; it only matters
   if a custom server ships a DAT whose heritage override has a nonzero
   NormalCost. The earlier "may be REJECTED" inference was made from code
   without measuring the data — the C4 closeout's observe-don't-infer
   lesson, again. Register: file an AD row if CC7 needs a documented
   workaround (e.g. picking a Specialized skill combination that avoids
   the heritage-priced skill for the connected gate) rather than silently
   adjusting acdream's send.

## Review protocol

Per slice: implement → Opus dual-lens (architectural + retail fidelity — this
campaign is retail-heavy everywhere) → fixes → narrow re-review → DONE in
ledger. CC2's review adds wire-byte scrutiny (the LA7a precedent: the
reviewer decodes the binary); CC6's adds the visual-fidelity lens ahead of
the user gate.

## Ledger

| Slice | Status | Commits | Review | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CC1 | REVIEW-CLOSED 2026-08-15 | `04450041`, `cb4703e8` | CLOSED (fix round + narrow re-review; every citation independently re-derived) | Core model (no Chorizite leak) + Content projector; 31 math units + 6 installed-DAT gates (13 heritages). FINDING for CC3: each human heritage's "Adventurer" template IS retail's Custom entry point — attributes at the 10-floor (60/330), a real TemplateCG row, not a UI special case. **Review fix round (`cb4703e8`):** F1 doc corrected — Custom IS template index 0 (the Adventurer row), per `gmCGProfessionPage::UpdateProfession @ 0x004821b0` (case 0 → button 0x100003d9 / `ID_CharGen_CustomText`) and `CharGenState::SetTemplate @ 0x005C5A60` (commits via `CharGenState::ApplyTemplate @ 0x005C5080`, i.e. selecting Custom resets sliders to the floor spread, it does not bypass templates); F2 two-tier skill-cost fallback implemented (`ChargenOptions.GlobalSkillCostsBySkillId` from portal.dat 0x0E000004, `ChargenSkillCreditMath` checks heritage list then global list) + installed-DAT completeness assertion recording reality: the global SkillTable prices 38/54 advancement skill ids, every one of the 13 heritages ships EXACTLY one heritage-specific override (always also present in the global table), and 16 skill ids are genuinely uncostable in both tiers (retail's -1 case) — see `ChargenTableReaderInstalledDatTests.InstalledHeritages_SkillCostFallbackCoversTheKnownUncostableSkillSet`; F3 every `ChargenTableReader` collection is now frozen at projection (`ToFrozenDictionary`/`ToArray`, matching `MagicCatalog`'s pattern) including both `ChargenOptions.Empty` dictionaries; F4 a reflection guard test (`ChargenNoChoriziteLeakTests`) pins the no-Chorizite-leak contract by walking every public `AcDream.Core.CharGen` member; F5 `HasAnyAppearanceOptions`'s doc reworded to state precisely what it proves (an OR across eight lists, omitting the three color lists) + a new installed-DAT gate records per-list reality — found COMPLETE, every gender of every heritage has non-empty lists across all eight plus the three color lists, even the sparse Gear Knight/Olthoi variants; F6 `TryGetHeritage`/`TryGetStarterArea` annotated `[MaybeNullWhen(false)]` (matching the house `EmptyDatReaderWriter` pattern), all affected call sites (more than the originally estimated five) fixed across both test projects. Filed CC7 risk item 8: ACE's `PlayerFactory` heritage-override branch over-deducts skill credits when specializing a heritage-priced skill (references/ACE/Source/ACE.Server/Factories/PlayerFactory.cs:184-211) — a retail-legal build may be rejected by local ACE at the CC7 connected gate; this is an ACE bug, not an acdream defect. **Narrow re-review CLOSED:** the reviewer retro-graded F2 to HIGH (under the base commit 37 of 38 costable skills were charged zero) and confirmed the SkillBase.SpecializedCost->PrimaryCost mapping dodged the UpgradeCostFromTrainedToSpecialized trap. Residuals: R1 retail refunds +1 credit on a both-tier miss (port charges 0; unreachable via retail’s own skills listbox — NOTE FOR CC3 if any path ever exposes the 16 uncostable ids); R2 list downcast-mutability and R3 field-walking in the leak guard CLOSED at the merge-closeout commit (Array.AsReadOnly at every projection seam; GetFields walk added). Decomp fact for CC4: ApplyTemplate force-sets template_=0 for heritage 0xc/0xd — both Olthoi variants are hard-locked to Custom/template 0. |
| CC2 | REVIEW-CLOSED, MERGED 2026-08-15 (`55fc51ed`) | `5eaad2c8`, `e77ebf10`, `95e95bb6` | PASS then CLOSED (fix round: F1 latch-scope narrowing + overwrite pin test, F2 register AD-100, F3 ACE double-NameInUse note, F4 creationFailed{code,reason,name}, F5 pointer, retail-discriminator citations) | Byte-exact 0xF656 (19-term checksum vs CG_Pack accumulator), shared 0xF643 type, correlation latch, status events + contract amendment. Core.Net 993 / Runtime 1667 / Launcher.Core 323, Windows+WSL |
| CC3 | REVIEW-CLOSED 2026-08-15 | `9a84230c`, `397ccd62`, + the R1 closeout commit | CLOSED (dual-lens: retail fidelity PASS, architectural FAIL → F1-F16 fix round `397ccd62` → narrow re-review CLOSED, both lenses PASS. Re-review residual R1 — the cached wire count is stale by creates-since-last-CharacterList, so a SECOND create after a rejected enter got wire slot N instead of N+1 — fixed in the closeout commit: `LiveSessionController._createsSinceCharacterList` (reset on every fresh wire CharacterList apply + generation reset; applied only to the cached-wire branch — the display-roster fallback already counts prior appends), regression test `SecondCreate_AfterRejectedEnter_GetsTheNextWireSlot` drives create→Ok→rejected guid-enter→ReturnToSelection→second create and pins slots 0/1/2/3. R2: fix-round sha recorded here.) | `RuntimeCharacterCreationState` (new, `src/AcDream.Runtime/Session/`): full CharGenState mirror (heritage/gender/appearance/template/six attributes+locks/55-slot skill set/name/startArea/slot/verification state), mirroring `RuntimeCharacterSelectionState`'s exact pattern (snapshot/delta/event-stream/borrow-only view, generation-gated `Try*` internals). Ports `SetHeritageGroup`, `SetGender`, `SetTemplate`/`ApplyTemplate` (Custom = template 0, Olthoi force-lock), the six attribute setters + `GetAbsRemainingCredits` + `BalanceAttributes` (retail's literal str/end/coord/quick/focus/self round-robin order, cursor-based fairness), `SetSkillLevel` + `ResetSkillLevels`' three-way free-skill baseline (both two-tier cost lookups reuse CC1's `ChargenSkillCreditMath`/`ChargenSkillCost` verbatim — no duplicated math), `RandomizeStartArea`, and `DoFinish`'s complete gate sequence (empty name / unspent attribute credits [see F3 below] / already-Pending / client-side roster-vs-slotCount cap). `LiveSessionController` gained a sibling `IRuntimeCharacterCreationCommands` implementation (command family lands beside `IRuntimeCharacterSelectionCommands`, `IGameRuntimeCommands.CharacterCreation` added with the same default-throw shape as `CharacterSelection`), a `CharacterCreationState` property, `ILiveSessionOperations.CreateCharacter` (default method → `WorldSession.SendCharacterCreation`), and a `HandleCharacterCreationResponse` wire handler subscribed to `WorldSession.CharacterCreateResponseReceived` alongside the existing character-selection bindings. `ILiveSessionLifecycleHost` gained `ApplyCharacterCreated`/`ApplyCreationFailed` as DEFAULT interface methods (no-op) so `AcDream.App`'s existing host implementations keep compiling unchanged — wiring them to `SessionStatusWriter.CharacterCreated`/`CreationFailed` is left to CC4 (Runtime calls the hooks; the App-side forward is a future host-construction change; **F14: zero production call sites exist for these hooks until then — a headless bot cannot observe a create yet**). **Review fix round (this commit):** F1 (HIGH, blocking) the post-create log-straight-in no longer enters by roster INDEX — `WorldSession` gained a guid-based `EnterWorld(uint characterGuid, string accountName, TimeSpan?)` overload (refactored to share `EnterWorldCore` with the index-based overload) plus `ILiveSessionOperations.EnterWorldByGuid` (default method); `LiveSessionController` factored `EnterSelectedCore`/the new `EnterCreatedCharacterCore` through a shared `EnterHighlightedCore(sendEnterWorld)` — the cached wire `CharacterList` is stale for a just-created character by ACE design (ACE appends server-side and replies Ok with no CharacterList resend — `references/ACE/.../CharacterHandler.cs:170-172`), so an index-derived enter could throw (0 pre-existing characters) or enter the WRONG character (N pre-existing, display order ≠ wire order). F2 (HIGH, blocking) the post-create roster append no longer round-trips through `ApplyRoster` (which re-derives EVERY entry's `ActiveIndex` — a wire contract ACE indexes for delete, `CharacterHandler.cs:297` — from display/name-sort order); `RuntimeCharacterSelectionState` gained a real `AppendCreatedCharacter(characterId, name, wireIndex)` primitive that preserves every existing entry's `ActiveIndex` untouched and assigns the new entry's from the pre-create wire `CharacterList.Characters.Count` (0-based, read from the same cached source the index-enter path uses). F3 (MEDIUM-HIGH, blocking) the credit gate was NOT retail — `DoFinish(this, arg2)`'s real gate is `arg2 != 0 && remainingAtrbCredits > 0`: the ordinary click (`arg2=1`) warns-and-refuses, but the warning dialog's own confirm re-invokes `DoFinish(this, 0)`, which skips the check and sends with credits unspent (ACE accepts this). `TryBeginFinish`/`LiveSessionController.Finish`/`IRuntimeCharacterCreationCommands.Finish` gained a `confirmedUnspentCredits`/`confirmUnspentCredits` parameter (default `false` = retail's `arg2=1`) — the plan doc's own "retail FORCES full spend" line above (§Retail ground truth, Finish) was corrected in the same round. F4 (MEDIUM, blocking) a stale out-of-range template index surviving a heritage switch to a heritage with fewer templates now clears to `TemplateUnset` in `ApplyTemplateLocked`, mirroring `ConstrainAllByHeritage @ 0x005C65CC`'s `template_ >= count → template_ = 0xffffffff` clamp (previously it just returned, leaving the stale index to reach the wire). F5 (MEDIUM) AP-207's anchor was wrong (`SetAttribValue` never calls `FitTemplateToCharacter`) — corrected to the four real call sites, including a fourth the original filing also missed (`UpdateToDefaultAttributes @ 0x00482860`). F6 (MEDIUM) `ApplyCreationResponse`'s Pending/Undef branch no longer publishes from inside `lock(_gate)` — every branch now sets `kind` and a single `Publish` runs after the lock releases, matching every sibling method. F7 (MEDIUM) two new tests pin `BalanceAttributes`' persistent cursor: successive overspends absorb from different attributes, and the Self→Strength wrap. F8 (LOW) `ResetSkillLevels`' doc corrected — retail's real gate is BOTH costs `>= 0` (not "either tier"); the dictionary-presence equivalence is a CC1-established, installed-DAT-gated invariant, cited precisely. F9 (LOW) the `Slot` doc corrected — retail DOES assign it (`gmCharacterManagementUI::SelectCharacter @ 0x004EC160` → `SetSlot(GetSlot(...))`), just semantically stale (the last-selected PRE-EXISTING character's slot); conclusion (send 0) unchanged. F10 (LOW) AP-209's `classID` citation completed with the three heritage-dependent branch ids (ordinary/Olthoi/OlthoiAcid) plus admin variants. F11 the integration test fixture no longer stubs `EnterWorld` to a bare counter — it captures guid-based calls and the fixture now has two pre-existing characters whose wire order deliberately differs from alphabetical order, so the roster-preservation assertion actually exercises F2 instead of coinciding with it by accident. F12 filed register row AP-211 for the client-side `RosterFull` slot-cap refusal (acdream-side gate, no retail `DoFinish`-layer counterpart — same-commit rule). F13 `LiveSessionController.Finish`'s bare `catch {}` narrowed to `InvalidOperationException`/`SocketException` and `_scope` bound to a local after validation. F15 `RandomizeStartAreaLocked` now leaves `_startArea` unchanged on an empty list (matching retail's `if (var_9c > 0)` guard) instead of forcing `-1`. Filed register rows AP-207 (FitTemplateToCharacter's FPU-unrecoverable auto-detect skipped — ACE only reads `TemplateOption` for title text; anchor corrected this round), AP-208 (per-style color-count approximated by the shared gender-wide `ClothingColors` list — CC1's model has no per-style palette data), AP-209 (`classID` sent as a placeholder `0` — DAT DID lookup unavailable in Core, ACE ignores the field; branch table added this round), AP-210 (`ApplyTemplate`'s per-attribute guarded sequential set approximated as one atomic replace), AP-211 (this round — the `RosterFull` client-side slot-cap refusal). Tests: `tests/AcDream.Runtime.Tests/CharGen/RuntimeCharacterCreationStateTests.cs` (34 cases — every Finish gate including the F3 confirmed-credits path, the F4 stale-template clamp, the F7 cursor-advance/wrap pair, Ok/each-rejection-code response mapping, duplicate-NameInUse tolerance, Olthoi template lock, attribute-lock/balance interaction, uncostable-skill rejection, generation reset) + `.../Session/LiveSessionControllerCharacterCreationTests.cs` (5 cases — wire-send exactly 55 skill slots via a REAL `WorldSession` + `GameMessageCapture`, decoded byte-for-byte; the full Ok round trip via `WorldSession.ProcessDatagram` reflection asserting F1's guid-based enter + F2's ActiveIndex-preserving roster append + `ApplyCharacterCreated`; the NameInUse round trip asserting `ApplyCreationFailed` + no roster/enter side effect; the local-refusal-never-touches-the-wire gate; the F3 confirmed-unspent-credits send). Runtime 1706/0 (was 1701, was 1667), Core.Net unchanged at 994/0, full solution Release build green. OPEN for CC4+: `RuntimeCharacterCreationState`'s `ChargenOptions` currently defaults to `ChargenOptions.Empty` — threading the installed DAT's loaded options through `GameRuntime`/App startup is unresolved; the `Slot` field's real assignment source (which caller picks the target roster slot) has no decomp citation (ACE ignores it, non-load-bearing); `classID`'s real DAT-DID resolution (AP-209) if a non-ACE server ever needs it; the F14 zero-call-site status hooks. |
| CC4 | CODE-COMPLETE 2026-08-15 | original + fix-round, both "this commit" | Dual-lens review returned architectural FAIL (F1, F6) + retail-fidelity PASS-with-reservations (F2, F3, F4) + LOW findings F5/F7-F12 (F13 is a merge-mechanics note for the orchestrator, not an acdream defect). Fix round applied same-session (see the "Review fix round" paragraph at the end of this row); re-review status owed to the orchestrator. | Screen shell + form pages (App layer). **Mount:** `CharacterCreationUiController`/`CharacterCreationUiMountCoordinator` (`src/AcDream.App/UI/Layout/`) clone `CharacterManagementUiController`'s recipe — enum `0x10000039` via `RetailDataIdResolver.Resolve(dats, ..., 5u)`, root `0x100003CC` (decomp-verified: `gmCharGenMainUI::gmCharGenMainUI @ 0x004e7eb0`, NOT the plan doc's earlier `0x100003cc`-adjacent guesses — confirmed live against the installed DAT, `[CC4-DAT] enum=0x10000039 -> DID=0x21000038`), fixed-canvas AD-98 treatment shared with char-management. **CORRECTED at the review fix round (2026-08-15, F1) — the original claim above was FALSE**: `CharacterManagementUiController` does NOT do a per-tick set; it writes `UiRoot.FixedCanvasSize` ONCE on its own activation edge and NULLS it in both `Deactivate()` and `Dispose()`. This controller now matches that exact shape: `Open()` sets the canvas once, `Close()`/`Deactivate()`/`Dispose()` null it symmetrically. The un-nulled canvas was a real bug: `RuntimeCharacterCreationState` had no `CompleteEnter()` analogue to `RuntimeCharacterSelectionState`'s (added this round, wired at both `LiveSessionController` in-world edges), so the chargen view reported `IsActive=true` for an entire in-world session, and since `RetailUiRuntime.Tick` ticks char-management BEFORE chargen, chargen's un-nulled canvas would silently re-pin an 800x600 scale over the in-world UI forever once the screen had ever been opened (dormant at defaults, armed under `ACDREAM_OPEN_CHARGEN=1`). **Master shell:** progress bar `0x100003ce`, master page `0x100003d0` (state `0x10000025+page-1`), 6 page roots, 6 free-navigation tabs (`0x100003ef..f4`), nav buttons `0x100003c6..cb` — full decomp port of `gmCharGenMainUI::ListenToElementMessage @ 0x004e9450` (Back-at-Heritage→DoExit, Next capped at Summary, Finish Summary-only) and `SetProgressState @ 0x004e7a10` (the Olthoi Profession/Skills/Town tab-hide + forward/backward page redirect, keyed off the LIVE snapshot heritage id every call). Exit confirmation via `RetailDialogFactory.MakeConfirmation` + `ID_CharGen_ExitWarning` (table `0x23000002`, matching `DoExit @ 0x004e8650`); on confirm the screen just closes (visibility only — see AD-99's sibling precedent) rather than porting `gmEpilogueUI`. **Heritage page** (`CharacterCreationHeritagePage.cs`, decomp `InitializePage @ 0x00483a10` + the EXACT button-id→heritage-id map read off `ListenToElementMessage @ 0x00483860`, which is NOT numeric-order — e.g. `0x100005e8`→Tumerok(7)): all 13 buttons, composed description text (`ID_CharGen_Heritage_StartingSkills_Header/Body`, `ID_CharGen_Heritage_BonusSkills_Trained_Header` + per-heritage body — Shadowbound/Penumbraen share one string per the decomp's `case 5: case 0xa:`; Lugian/Olthoi/OlthoiAcid have no bonus-skills string in the retail table at all, confirmed by string-key absence, not guessed). Selecting a heritage ALSO auto-selects its lowest gender key (AD-101 — Appearance's real gender buttons are CC6b's). **Profession page** (`CharacterCreationProfessionPage.cs`, `InitializePage @ 0x00482d50` + `UpdateProfession @ 0x004821b0`'s template map, cited already on `ChargenTemplate`): 7 template buttons (Custom=index 0, the six presets NOT in id order), 6 attribute sliders with the exact e6/e7/e9/e8/ea/eb id↔attribute-id mapping (the documented 3/4 swap), avail/health/stamina/mana. Live-DAT probe found TWO widget-mapping surprises the decomp's `DynamicCast` calls don't predict: the slider's value display (`0x100002ef`) imports as `UiField` not `UiText` (retail's `NumberInputFilter`, `@0x00482e36`) — wired for direct numeric entry via `OnSubmit`, not just display; and all four avail/health/stamina/mana containers (and the Skills credits meter) author as `UIElement_Button` whose Type-12 value child is swallowed by `UiButton.ConsumesDatChildren` before ever becoming an addressable widget — substituted with the button's own `.Label` (AD-103). Health/Stamina/Mana formulas ported from `UpdateAttributeValues @ 0x00482450`: Health=Endurance/2 (int truncation — the decompiler elides the FPU divide at `_ftol2 @0x0048262b`, so the exact MSVC rounding mode is UNVERIFIED beyond well-established AC convention; flagged, not guessed-and-hidden), Stamina=Endurance, Mana=Self; Available=`RemainingAttributeCredits` directly (`UpdateCreditsMeter`-style, no formula). **Skills page** (`CharacterCreationSkillsPage.cs`, `InitializePage @ 0x00481dd0`): ONE flat listbox (AP-213, retail's four-bucket sorted `InsertEntrySorted`/`UpdateSkillEntry` model not ported) driven by CC3's `TrainSkill`/`SpecializeSkill`/`UntrainSkill` + the SAME two-tier `TryGetSkillCost` presence gate `RuntimeCharacterCreationState` uses (16 uncostable ids never listed, matching retail); credits meter via the AD-103 button-Label substitution; info panes `0x100003fb/fc` unbound (no info-pane content source this round). **Town page** (`CharacterCreationTownPage.cs`, `InitializePage @ 0x0047c6d0` + `SetTown @ 0x0047c360`'s literal index map): the four buttons map to LITERAL `startArea` indices (Sanamar→3, Holtburg→0, Yaraq→2, Shoushi→1 — not id order), composed "How To" + per-town description text. **Random** (`0x100003cb`, `DoRandom @ 0x004e7d70`): Heritage/Profession/Town approximated with a uniform pick over every valid option (AP-212 — no `RandomizeHeritageGroup`/`RandomizeTemplate` primitives exist); disabled outright on Skills (no `RandomizeSkills` primitive), Appearance (placeholder), Summary (CC5's warning dialog). **Options threading:** `RuntimeCharacterCreationState.InstallOptions(ChargenOptions)` (new, mirrors `RuntimeCharacterState.InstallSpellMetadata`→`Spellbook.InstallMetadata`'s "install immutable DAT metadata after construction, throw if already active" pattern) called from `ContentEffectsAudioCompositionPhase.Compose` (new `ChargenOptionsInstalled` composition point, right after `SpellMetadataInstalled`) via `IContentEffectsAudioCompositionFactory.LoadChargenOptions`/`InstallChargenOptions` — `ChargenTableReader.Load(dats)` threaded through the SAME DAT-open composition sequence spell metadata uses, always well before any session's `Begin()`. **CORRECTED at the review fix round (2026-08-15, F6)**: the original claim that headless was unaffected left a dead end — `HeadlessSessionHost` wired the `CharacterCreated`/`CreationFailed` status hooks (closing CC3's F14) but never installed `ChargenOptions`, so a content-bearing headless host could observe a create but never actually issue one (every chargen command silently refused against `ChargenOptions.Empty`). Fixed by installing options directly beside the existing `InstallSpellMetadata` call, off the same `HeadlessProcessContentLease.Dats`, whenever `contentLease` is non-null; a content-less headless host (a validated-legal configuration — see the R9 note near `_contentLease`'s other reads) still cannot issue chargen commands, matching its existing inability to resolve spell/collision data either. **Status hooks:** `LiveSessionLifecycleBindings` gained optional `CharacterCreated`/`CreationFailed` delegates (default `null` — every pre-CC4 construction site keeps compiling); `LiveSessionLifecycleHost` now overrides both `ILiveSessionLifecycleHost` methods to forward them; `LiveSessionHostBindings` gained matching optional fields threaded through `LiveSessionHost`'s constructor; both `LiveSessionRuntimeFactory.Create` (App/graphical) and `HeadlessSessionHost` wire them to `SessionStatusWriter.CharacterCreated`/`CreationFailed`, closing CC3's F14 (zero call sites). **Deferred command seam:** `IGameRuntimeView.CharacterCreation` (new default-throw member, mirrors `CharacterSelection`), `GameRuntime.CharacterCreation` (passthrough to `Session.CharacterCreation`), `CurrentGameRuntimeAdapter`'s new `CharacterCreationProjection` (IsActive-gated view+command wrapper, mirrors `CharacterSelectionProjection`), `DeferredGameRuntimeStateCommands`'s new `CharacterCreation` view getter + 9 generation-capturing wrapper methods, and `CharacterCreationRuntimeBindings` wired in `InteractionRetainedUiComposition.cs` (`CharacterCreation:` sibling of `CharacterSelection:`, `ResolveText` backed by a `DatStringResolver` cached once per composition (`characterCreationStrings`, review fix round F12 — a fresh resolver per call was allocating + re-locking on every Heritage/Town description lookup, several times per page switch) and locked under `d.DatLock` only around each `.Resolve` call, `OpenOnStart` from the new `RuntimeOptions.OpenCharacterCreationOnStart` / `ACDREAM_OPEN_CHARGEN=1` env flag — the interim open seam since Create stays ghosted). **Widget types added to `DatWidgetFactory`: NONE** — every id resolves through EXISTING factory mappings (Button=1, Text/Field=12, Scrollbar=11, ListBox=5); the two "new" findings (editable-Field slider value, button-consumed credits/vitals children) are AUTHORED-DATA-DRIVEN outcomes of the existing factory logic, not new widget classes. **Register rows filed (same commit):** AD-101 (Heritage-page auto-gender-select interim default), AD-102 (Viamontian/Sanamar ToD-account-ownership gate omitted — acdream has no account/DLC signal), AD-103 (avail/health/stamina/mana/credits-meter UiButton-Label substitution for retail's swallowed Text-child overlays), AP-212 (Random button's uniform-pick approximation), AP-213 (Skills page flat-listbox simplification), TS-82 (Appearance/Summary placeholder pages, reachable via free tab nav, content-inert pending CC5/CC6a/CC6b). **Tests:** `tests/AcDream.App.Tests/UI/Layout/CharacterCreationLiveDatTests.cs` (7 cases, `ACDREAM_PROBE_LIVE_MOUNT=1`-gated — sweeps every master-shell/page id against the installed DAT and pins the two widget-mapping surprises above) + `CharacterCreationUiControllerTests.cs` (16 cases — hand-built layout fixture, no DAT: page switching, Olthoi tab-hide+redirect, Back/Exit/Random gating, exit-confirm/cancel, per-page command dispatch including the slider/field/skill-row/town-button paths) + `tests/AcDream.Runtime.Tests/CharGen/RuntimeCharacterCreationStateTests.cs` (+4 `InstallOptions` cases) + `tests/AcDream.Runtime.Tests/Session/LiveSessionLifecycleHostTests.cs` (+2 status-hook forwarding cases). Runtime 1713/0 (was 1707), App 5117/13 skips (was 5101/6, +16 new +7 gated-skip), Headless 165/0 unaffected, full solution Release build green. **OPEN for CC5/CC6a/CC6b:** the real Appearance-page gender buttons must retire AD-101's auto-select; Summary's Finish gate, name input, and randomize-warning dialog (currently Finish/Random both hard-disabled); Skills page info-panes `0x100003fb/fc` have no content source wired yet; the four-bucket sorted skill list (AP-213) and retail's exact Random algorithms (AP-212) remain unported if a future gate demands byte-exact parity; the Health/Stamina/Mana rounding-mode residual (see above) would need a live cdb byte trace to fully pin. **Review fix round (this commit, 2026-08-15):** F1 (HIGH, blocking, architectural) — see the corrected FixedCanvasSize paragraph above; added `RuntimeCharacterCreationState.CompleteEnter()` (mirrors `RuntimeCharacterSelectionState`'s own, wired at both `LiveSessionController` in-world edges: `StartCore` and the shared `EnterHighlightedCore`) and made `CharacterCreationUiController.Open`/`Close`/`Deactivate`/`Dispose` set/null `UiRoot.FixedCanvasSize` symmetrically with `CharacterManagementUiController`'s real (not per-tick) shape; added FixedCanvasSize coverage to `CharacterCreationUiControllerTests`. F2 (MEDIUM-HIGH, blocking, fidelity) — the attribute-slider scalar mapping was NOT retail's: fixed the display scalar to `value/100f` (`UpdateAttributeValues @ 0x0048251d`) and the drag inverse to `Math.Max(10, (int)(scalar*100f))` — truncate, clamp low only, no rescale (`ListenToElementMessage @ 0x004829c0`'s scrollbar-drag case, independently re-derived against the decomp and confirmed byte-for-byte); added tests at scalar 0.5 and 0.0 (the previous single scalar=1f test coincidentally agreed with both the old wrong formula and the new correct one). F3 (MEDIUM, blocking, fidelity) — ported `ListenToElementMessage @ 0x004e9450`'s heritage-button tab-restore arm (independently re-derived from the decomp: SHOW ids `0x100003bf/c1/c2/c3/10000590/91/100005a9/bf/c4/e8`, HIDE ids `0x100005c7/c8`, with Lugian `0x100005f1` genuinely absent from both switch cases — a real retail quirk, reproduced faithfully) as `CharacterCreationUiController.ApplyHeritageTabRestore`, invoked synchronously from a new `CharacterCreationHeritagePage` ctor callback on every button click; added restore-after-Olthoi-hide and Lugian-no-restore tests. F4 (MEDIUM, fidelity, blocks the user gate) — `gmCGTownPage::SetTown @ 0x0047c360` also sets the TOWN PAGE's own retail state (a separate literal map from the master page's per-page-index cycling: Holtburg->0x10000034, Shoushi->0x10000037, Yaraq->0x10000036, Sanamar->0x10000035, re-asserted directly at the Sanamar-click site `@0x0047c518`) — independently re-derived from the decomp's tail-merged-branch pattern and ported to `CharacterCreationTownPage.Refresh` via the existing `IUiDatStateful.TrySetRetailState` seam; added a test. F5 (MEDIUM) — AD-103's "composited pixel result unchanged" claim was asserted, not measured; softened to state the equivalence is unverified rather than building a rect/justify comparison probe this round. F6 (MEDIUM, blocking, architectural) — **decision: install `ChargenOptions` in the headless content path (option (a) of the two offered), not the deferred/out-of-scope alternative** — `HeadlessSessionHost` now calls `RuntimeCharacterCreationState.InstallOptions(ChargenTableReader.Load(content.Dats))` beside the existing `InstallSpellMetadata` call whenever `contentLease` is non-null, closing the gap where CC3's F14 status hooks were wired but no content-bearing headless host could ever produce a create to observe. F7 (LOW-MEDIUM) — AP-213 already named the label format and the click/double-click substitution explicitly on inspection; no row edit needed. F8 (LOW) — AP-212 now names all SIX of `DoRandom`'s decompiled primitives (added the three the original row omitted: `RandomizeAppearance @ 0x005c4f10`, `RandomizeClothing @ 0x005c6770`, `RandomizeCharacter @ 0x005c6d80`, independently verified against the decomp alongside the three already-cited ones) and states the known landing site (Runtime, beside CC3's `CharGenState` ports). F9 (LOW) — AD-101's retirement condition corrected: must happen before CC5's Finish un-ghosts, not merely "at CC6b" (CC5 precedes CC6b in the slice order; shipping Finish first would let a create complete on an implicit gender default). F10 (LOW) — merged `ItemAppraisalTextFormatter.SkillName`'s two consecutive `<summary>` blocks into one. F11 (LOW) — TS-82's "see AP-211's sibling gate" cross-reference was wrong (AP-211 is the unrelated roster-slot-cap refusal); corrected to point at TS-82's own CC5 dependency. F12 (LOW) — cached the chargen `DatStringResolver` once per composition (`characterCreationStrings` in `InteractionRetainedUiComposition.CreateRetainedUi`) instead of constructing + DAT-locking fresh on every `ResolveText` call; the `LinesProvider` per-Refresh closure allocation already matched the house pattern used throughout `CharacterStatController.cs` and elsewhere, so it was left as-is. F13 is a merge-mechanics note (TS-82 collides with campaign-cc6a's TS-82/83) for the orchestrator at merge time — no acdream-side action taken. |
| CC5 | — | | | |
| CC6a | — | | | |
| CC6b | — | | | |
| CC7 | — | | | |