From 89a9a7f2ac561b550e9feb2e71de45f280db0c56 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Erik Date: Sat, 5 Sep 2026 21:16:26 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] docs(overhaul): verify final lifecycle reconnect and R6 stability gates --- docs/ISSUES.md | 10 ++ ...-09-01-campaign-overhaul-world-solidity.md | 10 +- .../s5-consumers-material-closeout-packet.md | 21 +++ ...-final-lifecycle-stability-verification.md | 138 ++++++++++++++++++ 4 files changed, 177 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) create mode 100644 docs/research/2026-09-01-overhaul/s5-final-lifecycle-stability-verification.md diff --git a/docs/ISSUES.md b/docs/ISSUES.md index df40e22c7..3f7345b38 100644 --- a/docs/ISSUES.md +++ b/docs/ISSUES.md @@ -193,6 +193,16 @@ original-error propagation; corrected recipe10 smoke exit0/graceful, two PNGs inspected narrow PASS/provisional. Both clients closed. This adds future evidence, not a repair claim for the initiating AMD fault; #477 stays open. +Final eea83ac88 High-profile lifecycle, fresh reconnect and R6 runs complete: +16 checkpoints/15 PNGs, all three exit0/graceful with exact ACE disconnects. +No new GPU-loss/Application-crash/System4101 event reproduced. A distinct +WER1001/RADAR_PRE_LEAK_64 report appeared at18:59:10UTC, record713438, +report2bd9eaef-7666-4d86-b1f0-9f3f7d69a846; retain as an observation, not +proven leak or AMD cause. Canonical R6 retention passes with explicit +workload-change/cache-growth warnings. Exact evidence and limits: +`research/2026-09-01-overhaul/s5-final-lifecycle-stability-verification.md`. +Owner stability/G4 remains open; no FPS work or system/driver changes. + ## #476 — First post-resize graphical gate PNG is horizontally corrupted **Status:** IN-PROGRESS — capture and resize-boundary repairs integrated, diff --git a/docs/plans/2026-09-01-campaign-overhaul-world-solidity.md b/docs/plans/2026-09-01-campaign-overhaul-world-solidity.md index 1d643fc07..1d1a69060 100644 --- a/docs/plans/2026-09-01-campaign-overhaul-world-solidity.md +++ b/docs/plans/2026-09-01-campaign-overhaul-world-solidity.md @@ -700,8 +700,14 @@ nonpassing identities. Four wall tests pass after correcting an omitted package-path prerequisite, with the invalid first invocation retained. All92 official manifest entries verified; see `docs/research/2026-09-01-overhaul/c1a-integrated-verification.md`. -Final graphical lifecycle/reconnect/R6, remaining matrix and owner G4 -remain owed. Known retail leak unchanged, FPS/C2 deferred, no main merge. +Final graphical lifecycle/reconnect/R6 now PASS on the same eea83ac88 binary: +16 checkpoints/15 inspected PNGs, three exit0/graceful processes with exact +ACE disconnects. High preset retained; images provisional, not owner G4. +Existing R6 workload-change/cache-growth warnings and distinct Windows +RADAR_PRE_LEAK_64 observation are retained, not declared a leak or AMD cause. +See `docs/research/2026-09-01-overhaul/s5-final-lifecycle-stability-verification.md`. +Remaining matrix/adjacent-portal controls and owner G4 are still owed. +Known retail leak unchanged, FPS/C2 deferred, no main merge. ### Rollback ledger diff --git a/docs/research/2026-09-01-overhaul/s5-consumers-material-closeout-packet.md b/docs/research/2026-09-01-overhaul/s5-consumers-material-closeout-packet.md index d7c21eff0..f0bc2df2d 100644 --- a/docs/research/2026-09-01-overhaul/s5-consumers-material-closeout-packet.md +++ b/docs/research/2026-09-01-overhaul/s5-consumers-material-closeout-packet.md @@ -5274,3 +5274,24 @@ and graphical execution requirements are in c1a-integrated-verification.md. Known canonical nonpassing identities remain explicit; no entire-lane PASS. Final lifecycle/stability, graphical matrix and owner G4 are separate. No FPS work, known retail leakage change, authored-diagnostic rerun or main merge. + +## 69. Final lifecycle/reconnect/R6 checks — 2026-09-05 + +Clean-built eea83ac88, documentation-only launch HEAD cf1bc8403; all three +one-client runs terminated normally. Capped lifecycle6 checkpoints/5 PNGs, +fresh uncapped reconnect1/1 and capped R69/9 pass the canonical predicates, +unique route/ACK/status and observed-port ACE disconnect checks. Lead opened +all15 PNGs; visual scope remains provisional and does not replace owner G4. +No product edits/rebuilds between tests or beside a client. Saved High +preset retained, not an isolated retail-preset equivalence run. + +R6's existing workload-change/cache-growth warnings remain explicit. +Windows emitted one distinct RADAR_PRE_LEAK_64 report for acdream; no new +Application crash/LiveKernelEvent141/System4101 appeared in the scoped +18:57:33–19:14:11UTC interval. Do not infer a proven leak or AMD cause. +Runtime terminal status proves enforced ownership convergence; it is not a +raw post-disposal render-row dump. Exact paths, hashes, validator boundaries, +PNG names and remaining matrix: s5-final-lifecycle-stability-verification.md. +Next: exact adjacent-portal, cathedral/wall and ordinary-dungeon controls, +then the uncovered owner matrix. FPS/C2 deferred; known retail leak unchanged; +G4 unpassed, no main merge. diff --git a/docs/research/2026-09-01-overhaul/s5-final-lifecycle-stability-verification.md b/docs/research/2026-09-01-overhaul/s5-final-lifecycle-stability-verification.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2dc8a0988 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/research/2026-09-01-overhaul/s5-final-lifecycle-stability-verification.md @@ -0,0 +1,138 @@ +# S5 final lifecycle/stability verification — 2026-09-05 + +Tested production is clean eea83ac884d0b0fd74d86a17a16d7d5d93f64d94. +Launch HEAD cf1bc8403 adds documentation only. No rebuild or product edit +between C1a's full Release gate and these graphical runs. App/Core/package +hashes and exact per-process prechecks are retained in +`logs/s5-final-live-eea83ac88/preflight.json`; C1a test details are in +`c1a-integrated-verification.md`. No main merge; G4 remains owner-unpassed. + +## Execution and validation + +Each command launched exactly one Release client through the existing +overhaul self-gate runner. All ACDREAM environment names were cleared in +the launch process first; explicit UI/frame-profiler/reveal-timing flags, +uncapped selection, recipe10 session and unique statusFile followed. +Both clients/debuggers absent and ACE UDP9000/PID13340 verified before each. +Local route copies preserve every canonical command, appending only +close-client: lifecycle54, reconnect9, R6178 original commands. + +The user's persisted `acdream.atmospheric`1.0.0/high preset was retained +(settings.json and every screenshot's own metadata agree), rather than +creating an isolated retail-preset profile. MSAA4/near4/far25,1280x720. +This is a High-profile lifecycle/stability test, not a retail-preset pixel +equivalence result or an FPS/C2 performance comparison. The runner's exact +framebuffer switch changes window chrome to borderless. Existing profiler +and reveal diagnostics were enabled; no new production instrumentation. + +Offline `logs/s5-final-live-eea83ac88/validate-live.ps1` loads canonical +validator function definitions via PowerShell AST; it never executes the +old multi-launch/force-kill wrappers. Lifecycle readiness, ownership, +same-location retention and screenshot metadata checks are unchanged. +R6's complete predicate body is unchanged; only its Process-typed parameter +is widened to consume the previously observed process ID postmortem. +Additional checks require ordered checkpoint identity, normal-world frames, +unique script completion/logout ACK, actual OS exit0, unique terminal +exited/code0/reason graceful, and the exact new ACE PacketHeader Disconnect +for the client's observed UDP port. Runner success alone is not accepted. + +| Run | Process / observed UDP | Terminal result | Evidence directory | +|---|---|---|---| +| Capped lifecycle |32608@18:57:33.4291729Z /58875|PASS:6 checkpoints,5 PNGs,exit0,graceful; ACE21:01:41+02 disconnect|logs/selfgate-20260905-205733-s5-final-lifecycle-eea83ac88/| +| Fresh uncapped reconnect |20332@19:02:37.6360241Z /54669|PASS:1 checkpoint,1 PNG,exit0,graceful; ACE21:03:45+02 disconnect|logs/selfgate-20260905-210237-s5-final-reconnect-eea83ac88/| +| Capped R6 nine-stop |17064@19:04:48.0813716Z /52133|PASS:9 checkpoints,9 PNGs,exit0,graceful; ACE21:13:27+02 disconnect|logs/selfgate-20260905-210447-s5-final-r6-eea83ac88/| + +The original fresh-context-recreation predicate passes for the two completed +processes. All ten streaming-backlog fields are present and zero at their +seven stable checkpoints, staged mesh bytes zero, render/resource world +counts from the same frame. Lifecycle reports51 expected world-edge missing +landblocks; reconnect has no warnings. No time-based sleep substitutes for +the required ACE disconnect observation before reconnect. + +R6 completed in518.101 seconds (8m38s), not a ten-minute free-movement gate. +Every canonical predicate passed without alteration; all nine stable +checkpoints have zero publication/retirement/upload/composite/class backlog. +Its existing workload-sensitive comparison reports warnings, not failures: +Caul return→plateau visible landblocks580→579, world entities21031→21029, +mesh atlases57→58, mesh-estimated bytes189687540→198076140, tracked GPU +bytes121555500→121559596 and textures461→462, particles4750→4741. +Those warnings are retained explicitly; do not claim identical workload or +zero cache growth. It also reports51 expected world-edge missing landblocks. +All three exact clients are terminal, each with matching status/ACK/ACE proof. + +Lead independently rehashed all79 files in +`logs/s5-final-live-eea83ac88/lifecycle-r6-SHA256SUMS.txt` after terminal +validation. Manifest SHA256 EC2B59F822B1D9A081479A07F00693888BA4B09C8313DB3F47DA15332C4F07BA. +Lifecycle report8BB92899E114262B79D7A467FF3EC4980EC4CBC5A632006113E7BB3201F4FC1A; +reconnect50D916E8D34D27CE98FAF6496E6C806ECEA53DED72DA75E660E0E965B79544BB; +R6A825D2E72D780A9BED87874718C559F8AB2308F0B8F677B3327E6FBCD52C6D93. +The manifest includes all three run folders, terminal status/validation and +preflight files, route copies and original canonical route/validator sources. + +## PNG inspection and scope + +Lead opened the actual PNGs, not just filenames or success markers. Paths +below are relative to each run's `artifacts/screenshots/` directory above. +All visual PASS entries are provisional until the owner looks. + +| Run | PNG paths | Visual result / limit | +|---|---|---| +| Lifecycle |capped_login.png; aerlinthe_first.png; facility_hub.png; holtburg_after_dungeon.png; aerlinthe_revisit.png|PASS/provisional for revealed world geometry at these frames. Login has close-camera local-body fading; it does not prove whole-body occlusion. Facility shows lit corridor walls; Holtburg buildings are intact.| +| Reconnect |uncapped_reconnect.png|PASS/provisional for a revealed nonempty world in a new process; not a full camera-seam or movement gate.| +| R6 |caul-baseline.png; sawato-baseline.png; rynthid.png; aerlinthe.png; sawato-return.png; holtburg.png; caul-return.png; sawato-plateau.png; caul-plateau.png|PASS/provisional for these nine revealed-world frames; all opened. Buildings/terrain/actors are present; changing foliage/camera/weather/population means return frames are not pixel-identical. Not a full owner matrix.| + +Canonical historical labels are retained verbatim for comparison; exact +cell IDs and commands are authoritative. A route label is not independent +proof of the geographical name or the owner's Tusker combat scenario. +Combat-mode toggles are not casting/combat/particle-retirement proof. + +## Terminal ownership evidence boundary + +`GameWindow.ReportExited` emits graceful only after lifetime Complete and +with no captured Run failure. `GameWindowLifetime.DisposeGameRuntime` +is a hard teardown operation: it calls Dispose then requires Runtime's +IsConverged. Physics ownership includes zero landblocks and zero retained +logical shadow registrations. RuntimePhysicsState.Dispose calls Engine.Clear; +ShadowObjectRegistry.Clear unconditionally clears all retained part arrays, +CELLARRAYs, routes, per-cell part entries and attachment maps. + +The full Release suite includes the previously-nonempty terminal Runtime +disposal test. Separate Core tests directly check per-owner and landblock +retail CELLARRAY/part-row withdrawal, including render-only statics. +This supports invariant-backed cleanup, but these runs do NOT contain a +raw post-disposal snapshot of every render/membership row. Pre-close +checkpoints must never be represented as that missing terminal measurement. + +## Windows reporting observation + +The interval beginning18:57:33UTC has one relevant Application1001 record +at18:59:10.4998957UTC, record713438: RADAR_PRE_LEAK_64, AcDream.App.exe, +report2bd9eaef-7666-4d86-b1f0-9f3f7d69a846, StorePath NULL. This is not the +old AMD LiveKernelEvent141 report. At19:09:33UTC no new Application crash/ +LiveKernelEvent141 or System4101 was found by the scoped query. Full small +field capture: `logs/s5-final-live-eea83ac88/windows-observation.json`. + +Do not call this a proven leak or dismiss it as harmless. Existing R6 +managed-memory readings fell from809.3MiB at the fourth checkpoint to +535.1MiB at the fifth; that does not prove all native/driver memory is free +of leaks. Microsoft's [memory-leak investigation guidance](https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/drivers/debugger/determining-whether-a-leak-exists) +also distinguishes time-series suspicion from locating a leak. No driver, +TDR/ACL/system-setting change, upload, FPS repair or new diagnostic framework. +The final post-run check at19:14:11.9744073UTC finds the same single +record713438 and no new Application crash/LiveKernelEvent141 or System4101. +Both clients/debuggers absent, ACE9000/PID13340 up. No new GPU failure +reproduced; #477's initiating cause remains unknown. + +## Still owed + +Current-binary cathedral/wall/dungeon/adjacent-portal visual controls, +the final owner matrix and acceptance. Existing narrow routes are +route-g3.txt, route-482-cathedral-wall.txt, route-478-dungeon-controls.txt and +route-474-portal-reveal.txt under tools/overhaul-selfgate; route-464-run.txt +adds actual moving cathedral-stair images. These are not broader gates by +themselves. Exterior-ramp standing has no pinned pose; two-client wall +occlusion, complete Facility stair circuit, Nanto continuous rotation, +ordinary-dungeon traversal/camera seams, real Tusker combat/casting and +ten minutes' free movement remain owner checks. Wall acceptance is +functional block/escape, not exact equality to retail's x48.48 settlement. +The known retail cathedral slab leak remains unchanged. FPS/C2 stays deferred.