docs(overhaul): record graphical passes and remaining owner findings

This commit is contained in:
Erik 2026-09-05 13:41:25 +02:00
parent 1e376c244b
commit 7724b63116
5 changed files with 180 additions and 0 deletions

View file

@ -778,6 +778,16 @@ automation queued it before next-frame recreation. Two files, root mutation
and restored68PASS, narrow reviewPASS; no GPU/retail change or new deviation.
Exact integrated graphical replay still owed; see476-lead-verification.md.
**Latest graphical results (packet§57):** exact1e376c244 Release0W0E/68PASS;
#476unchanged startup/two-resize route nowPASS, #480rest/combat/restPASS,
both provisional. Town Network High/off/High stays dark; Rynthid stable
complex view obtained but displaced part unproven. #478/#479stillFAIL/open.
All three clients closed gracefully exit0 without native errors; PNGs and
hashes in476-480-graphical-r1.md and478-479-graphical-observations.md.
Ordinary short Neftet correctness follow-up PASS/no crash on the same binary,
graceful exit0; not a long soak or recurrence guarantee. Evidence:
477-integrated-validation-r2.md. FPS/C2 deferred; G4FAIL/no merge.
## 14. Risk register (condensed)
- **R1 second scene graph.** Graph records own only topology/membership facts;

View file

@ -64,3 +64,47 @@ G4 remains FAIL. #478/#479 observation awaits the capture gate's resolution.
| artifacts/476-integrated-0ca10cf24/476-integrated-held92.trx | E31E56117DAB120EE874A2873445994363F7E10347B7E6A54B52734A539AEBA2 |
The TRX paths are relative to repository root, not the graphical run.
## Round 2 — first-frame/resize capture PASS
Exact clean Release1e376c244b5254c63f94b0b28063e92babb17abb integrates the
two reviewed F2 blobs from d43e10584, independently checked identical.
Fresh full Release0W0E10.98s and integrated68PASS/0SKIP.
TRX artifacts/476-f2-integrated-1e376c244/476-f2-integrated68.trx,
SHA256 DA8AE3846582931455CA311A5394DDC2FD5A4A040581F79801917D44A3156F54.
Unchanged route/session/profile, run
`logs/selfgate-20260905-132707-476-current-frame-hands-r2/`, PID16932.
ACE9000 PID13340, both clients absent before launch. Actual Khronos DLL
observed loaded. Route complete, graceful logout confirmed, exit0, client
absent before next run. No validation-error/device-loss/unhandled matches.
All three checkpoints visible/failures0; final complete=true; publication,
retirement, upload and warmup0 throughout. This is not a Neftet crash soak.
Root opened ALL eight original PNGs. No first image discarded or retried.
All names below are under this R2 run's `artifacts/screenshots/`:
| PNG | Verdict | SHA256 |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 476-00-startup-first-request.png | PASS coherent1600x900 startup tunnel/UI. | 9125B752C45812152DDEE8D6BB4AB45EBA66F9B29EB33AA5C8DB99503FEF4F6A |
| 476-01-first-1024x768.png | PASS coherent1024x768 FIRST resize capture. | 9C2FBBD4729075AE0D1D3E6E708466EED949D4E565E23213585031201097A539 |
| 476-02-first-1600x900.png | PASS coherent1600x900 FIRST return-size capture. | 59602BD6C94F0814CD674BA05F39003A7227B5117F7D7D89F2E4F1E7EDA1814C |
| 476-03-login-visible.png | Current transitional view, not settled-world proof. | 7105117A015068DD6746D052AE0A44304EC155C86CDC2E2EC6DD621BE7D6E969 |
| 476-04-neftet-visible.png | Current transitional view, not settled-world proof. | F3EEE80071E037C2565F0B27FC529E3921ED970FD7C583617913A82213CB72F5 |
| 480-00-neftet-rest.png | PASS local green item and NPC weapons visible. | A073009CECA4ED511DA1C6537DA043FEA926B65224009A0CC8C48C86513211AA |
| 480-01-neftet-combat-toggle.png | PASS local held item in combat pose, NPC weapons remain. | F9AB9F6E619941630FD8A5EE0243BF2CADE6C2E2D683C9DD77C9FD6CC35C6C5D |
| 480-02-neftet-returned-mode.png | PASS held item/weapons persist after rest return. | 73B05CA3110D9EEB15B62971930332BB73A6864EAD4CE85E0C35252D6375BF3F |
Log83→90→92 and96→102→105 now prove resize event→matching swapchain
recreation→first matching-size capture. The interim world-visible pictures
have completed=false and the current WorldFadeIn projection override;
TeleportAnimSequencer174187 and TeleportViewPlaneController4565 explain
the transition in current code. No changed retail phase or stale-buffer
claim. The later held-item views are settled, complete=true.
#476 current-frame/resize gate PASS; #480 narrow graphical PASS, both
provisional until owner looks. R1 FAIL remains preserved. #478/#479 visual
diagnostics may proceed; FPS/C2 still deferred and G4 still FAIL.
R2 client.log SHA2565B7C0121C894FAA42111AA1F962DC1552AA2C7426A84E2F77EC8DC5D13EE2F9F;
stderr52EB30D77924B0F27CFB236133679FD40462EEF5E889BA15EB0E00DCC76795D8;
checkpointsBC20E3EB17B581D86BE2DAB880A3C32444412C22B65546C112A5B4B98C3862EA.

View file

@ -62,3 +62,38 @@ Next:476capture/480items;478lighting/479placement evidence; ordinary477/481
workload; exact475route; preservedC1c, canonical lanes/C2 and owner G4.
No new intentional deviation. Never merge main before G4.
## Ordinary short movement follow-up — 2026-09-05
Exact clean Release `1e376c244b5254c63f94b0b28063e92babb17abb` after the
#476/#480 integrations: full build 0 warnings / 0 errors, 68 focused tests
passed. Run `logs/selfgate-20260905-133251-477-neftet-ordinary-r1/`, PID32548,
same route and session-v10. ACE UDP9000 was up and both client names absent
before launch. One background command, no build/test overlap. Process-only
DEVTOOLS=0 and validation-layer environment unset; log says debug names off.
The process ended before module inspection, so module absence is NOT proven.
**Short crash-check PASS, provisional:** route completed and runner/client
exited 0 with graceful logout confirmed; both clients absent afterward.
No device-loss, unhandled-exception or abandoned-shutdown matches. Windows
13:32:5113:34:20 Application1000/1001/1026 matching AcDream/LiveKernelEvent/
WATCHDOG=0; System4101=0. Six forward+jump and six stationary jump input pairs
are NOT twelve proven airborne jumps. This roughly one-minute run is not a
long soak, the owner's exact crash trajectory, or proof against recurrence.
No FPS profile, comparison, or optimization was run; #481/C2 remain deferred.
Five checkpoints have zero invariant failures. Rynthid login is initially
incomplete with one staged upload; all four Neftet checkpoints are complete
with pending publication/retirement/upload/warmup zero. All three original
1600x900 PNGs were opened by the lead. Paths below are relative to the run:
| artifacts/screenshots/ | Verdict and limitation | SHA256 |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 477-00-first-resize.png | Transitional Rynthid login, not a stable-world or real resize gate. | EF3D2A352CE4DC0BD1EF56446AA9695652E0AA2B9F65DFE07C40F5A32D20B9D6 |
| 477-01-neftet-before.png | Coherent Neftet and held items; portal caption remains, not full presentation PASS. | A452E7D687435E27BCF80516D8C51F66A358F608323A097F33915A4502779D4C |
| 477-03-neftet-after.png | Narrow visual PASS: coherent settled scene and held items, no portal caption. | C0208CBEF40212F622F45325D04B591B5E588CDD119DB405CFD73528702F0445 |
client.log SHA256 FED404ACF055514D512D6FB71BDCEE4E30DE8DE1DF16E8E378D49A12C0DFAFA6;
client.err.log BABB4691CB7DAB79EEFB822F7C7847C75BDEC6059328A4B88EFF69BF119CBE51.
This supersedes the earlier ordinary-workload TODO only. Owner confirmation,
#478/#479, exact #475 route and remaining correctness closeout still owed.
G4 remains FAIL; no merge to main.

View file

@ -0,0 +1,66 @@
# #478 / #479 first current-capture observations
2026-09-05. Both runs use exact clean Release1e376c244b5254c63f94b0b28063e92babb17abb,
fresh full build0W0E and68focused tests; #476 startup/two-resize R2 PASSED
before either run. High near4/far25/MSAA4/aniso16/A2C1,1600x900,
session logs/s5-c5-session-v10.json, recipe10 package. One background command
per client; no builds/tests beside them. ACE9000 PID13340 present and both
client names absent before each. No FPS profiling/optimization was requested
or run; incidental default checkpoint/metadata performance fields are NOT
performance-gate evidence. All visual verdicts provisional for owner.
## #478 Town Network — darkness remains, no fix accepted
Run `logs/selfgate-20260905-132854-478-town-lighting-ab-r1/`, PID16588,
route-478-town-lighting-ab.txt. Owner's cell00070143/XYZ70,-60,.005;
diagnostic identity heading, not a reconstruction of owner's camera.
Same pose High→retail/off→High; metadata confirms active generation1,
retail generation2 and active generation3, no failed fallback, Outdoor=false.
Root opened all three original1600x900 images. Corridor is dark in both;
High visibly darkens it further, so postprocessing alone does not explain
the reported difficulty seeing the room. Local player and nearby floor are
lit; visible flame sprites do NOT prove corresponding room-light selection.
No matched retail-client image, selected-light membership or measured
per-vertex contribution is yet available. Do not raise ambient speculatively.
| Under run artifacts/screenshots/ | Observation | SHA256 |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 478-00-town-high.png | FAIL owner lighting acceptance remains unresolved; dark corridor. | D864D499CEFF510564E4953D3484087C9B0F8E011FAF416334286E0261CEBE0F |
| 478-01-town-retail.png | Dark without enhancement; diagnostic control, not lighting PASS. | E6499C47186B6EB551B7BECD17E3D1F26B6F10E7A56A436F7C15869364404C73 |
| 478-02-town-high-repeat.png | Repeated darkness after re-enable; not fixed. | D44EE708AFEB8FFBD16AE3174ED61F30603A955DAF56D95BB545B9DA1BD6625B |
All3checkpoints complete/visible, failures0, pending publication/retirement/
upload0. LightOwners214 is LiveEntityLightController ownership, NOT actual
registered/selected shader lights. Route/graceful logout/exit0; no client
remained. Validation env enabled; process ended before module inspection,
so no actual module observation is claimed for this run. Neither log has
validation-error/device-loss/unhandled matches; VFX warnings preserved.
Next: passive observation of already-consumed PointSnapshot/per-cell light
indices at existing checkpoints. No selector or lighting change authorized.
## #479 Rynthid — stable view obtained, displacement cause still open
Run `logs/selfgate-20260905-133013-479-rynthid-observe-r1/`, PID28152,
route-479-rynthid-observe.txt. True Recall3032001C arrival settled
XYZ83.3,89.2,132.00499; documented upstream heading, not owner camera.
Root opened all five original1600x900 images. Elevated dark/red slabs are
visible west of the camp; exact displaced component is not identified yet.
Pitch changes are visibly effective. The two nominal pan shots show no
material yaw change, so do not count them as independent yaw coverage.
No transform edit or placement PASS follows from these observations.
| Under run artifacts/screenshots/ | Observation | SHA256 |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 479-00-recall-view.png | Stable camp/elevated complex; #479 unresolved. | 3326985B68C71D737BC46BDFFF2B0F803BBBB686735D3756FC12F95C2944D695 |
| 479-01-pitch-up.png | Raised view includes elevated slab complex. | 3E916D67E051C4AE912356364A066F3F67642C826A0EE2DDBBFE8478B38B5A96 |
| 479-02-pitch-up-further.png | Further pitch, not exact affected-part proof. | 556EEDFD9DDC53582B955FB7787E5511D1050F85ACFED679BD17A13B18EA5022 |
| 479-03-pan-left.png | No material yaw change observed. | 6BD8C5D338467BF82A9445918EBEB4D5BB8831E7D1D851C91B8A473B53D039DE |
| 479-04-pan-right.png | No material yaw change observed. | 64A993ADBEBAAFA0E8D3CEE691F1AAAB71B316941E1D94D885F8D9EF6FCCD979 |
All3checkpoints complete/failures0, pending publication/retirement/upload0.
Actual Khronos validation DLL observed in28152. No validation-error/device-
loss/unhandled matches. Route completed; input released, graceful logout
confirmed, exit0, absent before next client. Next bounded read-only trace
targets the candidate authored assemblies in479-rynthid-location-evidence.md;
do not guess an origin, quaternion, animation or package fix. #479 remains
unresolved/FAIL acceptance, G4 FAIL. No main merge.

View file

@ -4882,3 +4882,28 @@ no findings; no GPU/capture/retail/route change or new deviation. Integrating
successful-resize command-loop yield, then fresh exact-binary graphical
replay. 476-lead-verification.md has seals. No third fix round authorized;
unchanged FPS deferral and G4 FAIL remain.
## 57. Capture gate passes; first lighting/Rynthid observations
Clean1e376c244, exact two F2 blobs fromd43e10584, full Release0W0E/68PASS.
Unchanged26-command route R2: first requested1600x900, first1024x768 resize,
first1600x900 return all coherent and correctly sized; all8PNGs opened.
#476PASS and #480rest/combat/rest narrowPASS, provisional until owner sees.
PID16932 graceful exit0, actual validation layer loaded, no native errors.
476-480-graphical-r1.md now retains both failedR1 and passingR2 evidence.
Same binary then ran Town Network High/off/High (16588) and true Rynthid
Recall observation (28152). Both routes graceful exit0, no device loss or
validation errors, all checkpoints complete/zero invariant failures/backlogs.
478-479-graphical-observations.md records every PNG/hash/limitation. Town
corridor dark in both profiles, High darker; no selected-light proof yet.
Rynthid elevated complex visible, exact displaced part not identified. Both
owner findings remain open/FAIL acceptance; short read-only investigations
complete, no speculative rendering edits. Ordinary short Neftet movement
check completed on the same binary: PID32548, route/graceful exit0, no device
loss/unhandled failure or matching Windows crash event. Four Neftet checkpoints
complete with zero invariant failures/backlogs. All3PNGs opened; final settled
scene narrowPASS. Twelve jump input pairs are not twelve proven airborne
jumps, and this is not a long soak or proof against recurrence. See the
ordinary-follow-up section in477-integrated-validation-r2.md. NOT an FPS gate.
FPS/#481/C2 deferred. No main merge and G4 remains FAIL.